David Snyder arrested during council meeting Save Email Print
Posted: 2:03 PM Sep 17, 2007
Last Updated: 1:28 PM Nov 4, 2007


A | A | A

Roseland council member David Snyder was taken to St. Joseph County jail and held overnight after an incident during a Roseland council meeting.

 
Do you think the police went too far with their use of force in David Snyder's arrest?
Yes
No
I can't tell
 

He was released after the prosecutor's office reviewed the police report and decided to drop the felony charge, clearing way for Dorothy Snyder to bail him out.

David Snyder was put in jail after David Snyder was ejected from a budget meeting Friday night, before being taken to the ground outside by a Roseland police officer.

The melee started because David Snyder protested after being given only one minute to speak by council member Charlie Shields. After a heated argument, laced with profanities, Shields kicked Snyder from the meeting.

Snyder slowly walked from the meeting, escorted by Officer Jack Tiller. When he got into the lobby, turned and said something to Tiller who appears to shove Snyder who falls hard into the glass door and outside.

NewsCenter16's camera then shows David Snyder on the ground outside the town hall with Officer Tiller on top of Snyder. There are calls for Snyder to stop resisting as the officer appears to pound Snyder's head.

David Snyder was then taken to the hospital to be checked out before being taken to jail.

Roseland town council member David Snyder is calling for the resignation of a town marshal after a fight at Friday night's meeting.

Snyder says while he was being arrested, he became a victim of police brutality.

A felony charge of battery of a police officer was dropped.

The St. Joseph County prosecutor's office reviewed the police reports Saturday morning, dropped that charge but left two misdemeanor charges. That meant he could bond out of jail. Now he’s recovering at home.

On that home, signs calling for the Snyders to leave still remain after vandalism months ago, and with those it may be a surprise to learn that some are actually "siding with the Snyders."

David Snyder said, “I'm a victim of a rogue cop a cop that should no longer be wearing a badge and he should no longer be on the streets. He is a danger to society.

There were only two real witnesses to the fight.

Snyder who was kicked out of the meeting who says, “I’m walking out of the conference room and Jack is breathing down my back and somebody yells at me to turn around and look at them. And I say to Jack ‘Oh the bully is still whatever’ and he is just goes ballistic. Just ballistic and he shoves me shoves me through the door. I pass out and come to and he is pounding on me.”

The other witness was Marshal Jack Tiller. NewsCenter16 tried talking to him, but his wife answered the door.

When we asked for his side of the story, she responded “We'll you guys have smeared his name enough thank you.” She added the video does not show all that happened.

Some say, such as council member Ted Penn who declined an on camera interview said in the time chaos erupted, David got a punch in.

But David claims that’s not the case and he is considering a lawsuit against the town.

“I think that when someone is victimized and brutalized by a police officer that is a good potential,” Snyder added.”

Snyder says he will have to appear in court in October.

Roseland town council president Charlie Shields kicks council member David Snyder out of Friday's budget meeting. Snyder was kicked out after arguing how long he was given to speak.
Click Pictures to Enlarge
Related Stories
Roseland budget approved

David Snyder released from jail after being bloodied at council meeting

Roseland residents frustrated

Excessive Force and Police Arrests

Roseland Budget

Roseland Police paid little more than minimum wage

Roseland resident offers David Snyder a job

Roseland's Police Force Future

David Snyder is not alone

More Stories
The full interview: "The Snyders Speak Out"

Tornado caught on police car dash camera

FOP President faces discipline by Police Chief

David Snyder arrested during council meeting

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Kevin B. Location: San Francsico on May 26, 2008 at 10:57 AM
This is endemic in the US under our current administration. Police go unchecked, rights erode further everyday and the "sheeple" continue to let it slide further. We have been feared into compliance by the "war president" and anyone that questions the police or any other authority is beaten and intimidated into submission. Did you know the police now claim taping them amounts to terrorist activities? We wouldn't want another Rodney King tape causing problems for the police again now would we? There are thousands of US troops fighting for Iraqi freedom while more and more of our freedoms are being taken away. As an American I am saddened by how low we have fallen in 8 years. Don't like it at all. And to the pinheads that would tell me to leave if I don't like it here, no thanks. I prefer to stay and fight to make this the great country it used to be before it was ruined by the neocon warmongers.

Posted by: bobbie Location: kewanna on Apr 21, 2008 at 08:14 AM
You can clearly see that snyder was pushed going out the door way. I would have to say this is most definitely police brutatily. That cop should be fired for the beating he gave his man totally uncalled for.

Posted by: randy Location: bloomington on Apr 6, 2008 at 10:12 PM
Who said " What happend did you fall down"?? You can see in the glass in the hallway that he was pushed out the door onto the ground, wonder when he had time to throw that punch? Police brutality absolutely no question, no matter how much you dont like this guy the police can not beat up people they dont agree with.

Posted by: Jason Location: Cleveland,OH on Mar 16, 2008 at 11:24 PM
I'm a former resident of Niles, MI. and have had to pass thru Roseland many a time. Its not uncommon to hear of the Roseland and Southbend police brutality going on. More of your residents need to speak up and get these cops out of service. This is rediculous! Of course if you'd rather live in fear then by all means let it happen again and again. Just like a rapist the cops are raping your right to freedom of speach and stomping out this information the best they can. Well if I've heard about it in Cleveland, OH. I guess your not doing that great of job. Let the country know that the Roseland PD are a bunch of liers and bullies.

Posted by: Anonymous on Mar 10, 2008 at 02:07 PM
Sounds like a clear cut case of police brutality, cops think they can hide behind the badge and its time for them to learn otherwise!!

Posted by: david Location: ohio on Feb 21, 2008 at 03:24 AM
you can see in the video and in the glass in the hallway that the cop went ballistic i think he just did not like mr snyder very well i would sue and get the officer fired he should not be on the force

Posted by: stanley Location: roseland on Feb 1, 2008 at 01:30 PM
snbyder shiould be jailed for two reasons, #1 stealing townspeople money, and fraud #2 failure to pay alimoney to a wife and ailing son.

Posted by: harry Location: new york on Jan 30, 2008 at 08:14 AM
just another out of control cop...america is full of them

Posted by: John Doe Location: NY on Jan 24, 2008 at 07:42 PM
That police office should be arrested and in jail. They accuse David Snyder of being a 'Hitler' however, their reaction is just like what one would expect from a totalitarian government like that of Hitler's.

Posted by: Chris Location: Boston, MA on Jan 6, 2008 at 08:51 PM
THe police officer should be in jail for abuse power, he's hjust hitting the old guy and all of those creepy old guys on the court should be vanished from earth.

Posted by: abu karem Location: japan on Dec 19, 2007 at 08:05 PM
TO: Doug Location: Valparaiso In, thats not the point your idiot!! police brutallity was done and thats the point..here we never do that or put a person in the ground during arrest and our cops never carry a weapon..we make arrest by calling in the phone and the suspect will report to police precent..but in roseland U.S you beat the innocent people and impresont him...thats violation of human rights..if these police officer will remain in the streets of roseland the civilians is not safe from brutally and impresonment without crime committed....

Posted by: David Location: Ill on Dec 7, 2007 at 11:27 AM
I know this is late but, if you look at the long version Snyder had the floor and was addressing the council, he tried to exercise his rights of normal parlimentary rules and was totally ignored. He evidently was talking the truth or the council chair wouldn't have acted in sure a rash and childish manner.

Posted by: Rich Location: Northern Ohio on Nov 4, 2007 at 07:22 PM
1. Snyder was speaking WITH A SMILE and turned to the front door and THEN was pushed down. Thus, Penn's testimony is questionable. 2. WATCH THE TWO OFFICERS Tapping a probing Tiller to stop his assult on Snyder!! Watch it and you will see they had NO concern that Tiller was ever in any danger 3. Look at the officer picking up Snyder, I think he was in disbelief and didn't know what to do since his fat lazy boss Tiller went crazy on a guy who was on his back and couldn't fight back 4. When is the last time you say a cop hit while other cops are around? Wouldn't you agree that when that happens they all get into the punching act? 5. Teh local procecutor knows Snyder didn't resist arrest, heck he was complying by leaving the building. The procecutor should be reviewed too, REMEMBER the DUKE incidence? A STATE/FEDERAL investigation should be conducted and I bet half would go to jail.

Posted by: Brad Location: USA on Oct 23, 2007 at 08:15 PM
I cannot believe there is any question what-so ever as to whether or not the police went too far. Wake up.

Posted by: The Real Uncle Sam Location: Ohio on Oct 21, 2007 at 02:16 AM
Welcome to America, 2007. Mr. Snyder, you are an insperation. Stand tall, and definately get paid.

Posted by: Keith Location: Melbourne, Australia on Oct 20, 2007 at 11:11 PM
This video is scary.The police appear to have no regard for keeping the peace free from favor or prejudice.The officer acted like a thug.More surprising was that no one stepped in to help this man.The people of this town must either be scared of police or hate this guy so much that they turned a blind eye during the attack.Continued pressure needs to be placed on the police & the town's leadership to force a dramatic shake up.The cronies need to be replaced with unbiased good governance.This man needs help too with all his legal costs. He shouldn't have to pay so much for fighting for justice.Is there a fighting fund for this man & if so could you please give the details on this internet site. Thank you.

Posted by: Anonymous on Oct 14, 2007 at 10:05 AM
This is factual information on how people are threatened in Roseland Indiana with council majority Ted Penn and Charlie Shields this was taken on February 22, 2006: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tuVGqaYH9w0

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Roseland on Oct 13, 2007 at 11:35 AM
David Snyder was born in Roseland, his father was born in Roseland and his grandfather was also on the Roseland Town Council. A few bad eggs which you see on the video have used the media with lies and half truths to distort what has been happening in Roseland for years. "Hate the Snyders" is what they have been pushing, and sadly people were willing to buy it. Now, the brutality of this video is undeniable. The world sees who is in the wrong and who are the nasty people and the liars. Take stock Valparaiso, this could happen in your town. It could happen in any town. If there is a small group of felons and hate preachers/ugly mob, it can and will happen ANYWHERE to ANYBODY. David Snyder was attacked by Jack Tiller while lawfully doing Roseland town business. If you think this is OK, then you are part of the problem in America today. This ugly mob is trying to bully those who will stand up to them. Do you support this? If yes, turn in your American flag, you don't deserve it.

Posted by: Rico Location: Texas on Oct 5, 2007 at 07:12 PM
Just shows the kind of people who are being hired as law enforcement officers. Bullys bullys bullys. He needs some serious Texas style payback.

Posted by: Doug Location: Valparaiso In. on Oct 4, 2007 at 11:43 PM
David snyder is loud mouth bully who got what he had coming.That was garbage the way he spoke to that old man at that meeting.his actions brought about the intire event. he and his nasty wife need to get over the fact that there days of ruining roseland are over.I have been watching all these events unfold for quite some time now, and although I'm not a roseland resident, I feel for them all.The snyder family need to get a life.I can't believe he had the nerve to say having to pay child support was somehow a punishment what about his kids who have had to do with out because of there low life dead beat father, What a train wreck!

Posted by: Michael Location: Evansville, IN on Oct 3, 2007 at 07:14 PM
You know, I lived in the South Bend area for a little over 4 years. I left two years ago...............this nonsense is still going on? This man 'Snyder' and his lovely wife.....need to get a life!....an move on down the road!

Posted by: Ian Location: Louisville KY on Oct 2, 2007 at 10:54 PM
Well, I think the people have spoken, and