David Snyder arrested during council meeting
David Snyder arrested during council meeting Save Email Print
Posted: 3:03 PM Sep 17, 2007
Last Updated: 12:05 PM Nov 6, 2008


A | A | A

Roseland council member David Snyder was taken to St. Joseph County jail and held overnight after an incident during a Roseland council meeting.

 
Do you think the police went too far with their use of force in David Snyder's arrest?
Yes
No
I can't tell
 

He was released after the prosecutor's office reviewed the police report and decided to drop the felony charge, clearing way for Dorothy Snyder to bail him out.

David Snyder was put in jail after David Snyder was ejected from a budget meeting Friday night, before being taken to the ground outside by a Roseland police officer.

The melee started because David Snyder protested after being given only one minute to speak by council member Charlie Shields. After a heated argument, laced with profanities, Shields kicked Snyder from the meeting.

Snyder slowly walked from the meeting, escorted by Officer Jack Tiller. When he got into the lobby, turned and said something to Tiller who appears to shove Snyder who falls hard into the glass door and outside.

NewsCenter16's camera then shows David Snyder on the ground outside the town hall with Officer Tiller on top of Snyder. There are calls for Snyder to stop resisting as the officer appears to pound Snyder's head.

David Snyder was then taken to the hospital to be checked out before being taken to jail.

Roseland town council member David Snyder is calling for the resignation of a town marshal after a fight at Friday night's meeting.

Snyder says while he was being arrested, he became a victim of police brutality.

A felony charge of battery of a police officer was dropped.

The St. Joseph County prosecutor's office reviewed the police reports Saturday morning, dropped that charge but left two misdemeanor charges. That meant he could bond out of jail. Now he’s recovering at home.

On that home, signs calling for the Snyders to leave still remain after vandalism months ago, and with those it may be a surprise to learn that some are actually "siding with the Snyders."

David Snyder said, “I'm a victim of a rogue cop a cop that should no longer be wearing a badge and he should no longer be on the streets. He is a danger to society.

There were only two real witnesses to the fight.

Snyder who was kicked out of the meeting who says, “I’m walking out of the conference room and Jack is breathing down my back and somebody yells at me to turn around and look at them. And I say to Jack ‘Oh the bully is still whatever’ and he is just goes ballistic. Just ballistic and he shoves me shoves me through the door. I pass out and come to and he is pounding on me.”

The other witness was Marshal Jack Tiller. NewsCenter16 tried talking to him, but his wife answered the door.

When we asked for his side of the story, she responded “We'll you guys have smeared his name enough thank you.” She added the video does not show all that happened.

Some say, such as council member Ted Penn who declined an on camera interview said in the time chaos erupted, David got a punch in.

But David claims that’s not the case and he is considering a lawsuit against the town.

“I think that when someone is victimized and brutalized by a police officer that is a good potential,” Snyder added.”

Snyder says he will have to appear in court in October.

Roseland town council president Charlie Shields kicks council member David Snyder out of Friday\'s budget meeting. Snyder was kicked out after arguing how long he was given to speak.
Click Pictures to Enlarge
Related Stories
Roseland budget approved

David Snyder released from jail after being bloodied at council meeting

Roseland residents frustrated

Excessive Force and Police Arrests

Roseland Budget

Roseland Police paid little more than minimum wage

Roseland resident offers David Snyder a job

Roseland's Police Force Future

David Snyder is not alone

More Stories
The full interview: "The Snyders Speak Out"

Tornado caught on police car dash camera

FOP President faces discipline by Police Chief

David Snyder arrested during council meeting

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Sonya Location: Florida on Apr 27, 2009 at 03:31 AM
Yet again more evidence of police brutality, more reasons as to why we should only allow EDUCATED men and women to police force.

Posted by: fabian Location: canada on Mar 16, 2009 at 08:15 PM
I can't believe these people yelling 'Just let the cops deal with it, youre not involved to step back and get out of the way'. This kind of police brutality crap should not be taken and all the people there, if they don't want to get their own beat-down sometime, should have stood up and ran the f*%^*^n cops out of there. Just pathetic cops on a stupid power trip, and given all the freedom to do so, digsusting.

Posted by: Jason Somers Location: Illinois on Mar 3, 2009 at 04:23 PM
This is sadly the state of the country. Cops are given free reign to beat and harrass citizens and everyone turns a blind eye. I hope David Snyder sues the hell out of this community. The disgusting part is the fat ugly council members standing around mocking the victim of vicious police brutality and the cops allow it. These men should not only lose thier jobs and be put into prison, everyone who witnessed this and did nothing should be charged as well. This is no better than the ambush of that high school girl in Florida that yielded multiple arrests for everyone involved. Fight the Power David Snyder, Fight the POWER!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Anonymous on Feb 4, 2009 at 02:48 PM
The Dvoraks said this was a "justified beating" so no charges against Tiller. Snyder is just lucky he wasn't shot sixteen times for lying face down on the ground.

Posted by: Anonymous on Feb 2, 2009 at 09:35 PM
The Snyder's have done nothing but line their pockets with the money of the honest and hard working for year. They have on more then one occasion silenced others that spoke out against them. They were oppressive in their self righteous agenda to the point of tyranny. They created their own little dictator ship. They may have not used violence to silence someone speaking their mind, but they had no problem using robbery. And really the video doesn't show it all. I really think anybody even considering police brutality has no idea what a cop goes through in their day to day. You have no idea the kind of risk they take, or the normal everyday objects that suddenly become dangerous weapons. The video doesn't show it all. You can only see half of Snyder's body. The cop saw the other half. And at the end, it looks as though the officer is trying to get his hands and Snyder is resisting putting his hands back. The video doesn't show brutality. This is just a case of people seeking drama.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Walkerton on Jan 25, 2009 at 02:49 PM
I am afraid of cops now

Posted by: David Location: Chile on Jan 20, 2009 at 08:57 PM
I have just seen this video and I didn´t believe it was happening in USA. A man being hit brutally on the floor only because of expressing his voice is not, at all, a sign of belonging to the "first world". What kind of police you have?. It seems to me they are allowed to do what they want with no restrictions, even they are allowed to run over the most elementary right of a man to open his mouth. The crime of that man elected by people, as I realize on the video, was to say what he thought. It is also amazing that no one on that meeting try to help this not so young man. I got to this web page looking for a similary case I watched on a program tv in my country this day, so I realize it is a used way of acting of your police. Poor of the ordinary people in the USA, if cops do what they want with "elected people", I can imagining the destiny of the others.....

Posted by: nean smith Location: middlebury on Jan 12, 2009 at 04:02 PM
This whole thing with both Mr and Mrs Snyder have became a big joke.They need to either move some where , where they can be on day time soaps. and leave Roseland alone

Posted by: Kevin B. Location: San Francsico on May 26, 2008 at 11:57 AM
This is endemic in the US under our current administration. Police go unchecked, rights erode further everyday and the "sheeple" continue to let it slide further. We have been feared into compliance by the "war president" and anyone that questions the police or any other authority is beaten and intimidated into submission. Did you know the police now claim taping them amounts to terrorist activities? We wouldn't want another Rodney King tape causing problems for the police again now would we? There are thousands of US troops fighting for Iraqi freedom while more and more of our freedoms are being taken away. As an American I am saddened by how low we have fallen in 8 years. Don't like it at all. And to the pinheads that would tell me to leave if I don't like it here, no thanks. I prefer to stay and fight to make this the great country it used to be before it was ruined by the neocon warmongers.

Posted by: bobbie Location: kewanna on Apr 21, 2008 at 09:14 AM
You can clearly see that snyder was pushed going out the door way. I would have to say this is most definitely police brutatily. That cop should be fired for the beating he gave his man totally uncalled for.

Posted by: randy Location: bloomington on Apr 6, 2008 at 11:12 PM
Who said " What happend did you fall down"?? You can see in the glass in the hallway that he was pushed out the door onto the ground, wonder when he had time to throw that punch? Police brutality absolutely no question, no matter how much you dont like this guy the police can not beat up people they dont agree with.

Posted by: Jason Location: Cleveland,OH on Mar 17, 2008 at 12:24 AM
I'm a former resident of Niles, MI. and have had to pass thru Roseland many a time. Its not uncommon to hear of the Roseland and Southbend police brutality going on. More of your residents need to speak up and get these cops out of service. This is rediculous! Of course if you'd rather live in fear then by all means let it happen again and again. Just like a rapist the cops are raping your right to freedom of speach and stomping out this information the best they can. Well if I've heard about it in Cleveland, OH. I guess your not doing that great of job. Let the country know that the Roseland PD are a bunch of liers and bullies.

Posted by: Anonymous on Mar 10, 2008 at 03:07 PM
Sounds like a clear cut case of police brutality, cops think they can hide behind the badge and its time for them to learn otherwise!!

Posted by: david Location: ohio on Feb 21, 2008 at 03:24 AM
you can see in the video and in the glass in the hallway that the cop went ballistic i think he just did not like mr snyder very well i would sue and get the officer fired he should not be on the force

Posted by: stanley Location: roseland on Feb 1, 2008 at 01:30 PM
snbyder shiould be jailed for two reasons, #1 stealing townspeople money, and fraud #2 failure to pay alimoney to a wife and ailing son.

Posted by: harry Location: new york on Jan 30, 2008 at 08:14 AM
just another out of control cop...america is full of them

Posted by: John Doe Location: NY on Jan 24, 2008 at 07:42 PM
That police office should be arrested and in jail. They accuse David Snyder of being a 'Hitler' however, their reaction is just like what one would expect from a totalitarian government like that of Hitler's.

Posted by: Chris Location: Boston, MA on Jan 6, 2008 at 08:51 PM
THe police officer should be in jail for abuse power, he's hjust hitting the old guy and all of those creepy old guys on the court should be vanished from earth.

Posted by: abu karem Location: japan on Dec 19, 2007 at 08:05 PM
TO: Doug Location: Valparaiso In, thats not the point your idiot!! police brutallity was done and thats the point..here we never do that or put a person in the ground during arrest and our cops never carry a weapon..we make arrest by calling in the phone and the suspect will report to police precent..but in roseland U.S you beat the innocent people and impresont him...thats violation of human rights..if these police officer will remain in the streets of roseland the civilians is not safe from brutally and impresonment without crime committed....

Posted by: David Location: Ill on Dec 7, 2007 at 11:27 AM
I know this is late but, if you look at the long version Snyder had the floor and was addressing the council, he tried to exercise his rights of normal parlimentary rules and was totally ignored. He evidently was talking the truth or the council chair wouldn't have acted in sure a rash and childish manner.

Posted by: Rich Location: Northern Ohio on Nov 4, 2007 at 07:22 PM
1. Snyder was speaking WITH A SMILE and turned to the front door and THEN was pushed down. Thus, Penn's testimony is questionable. 2. WATCH THE TWO OFFICERS Tapping a probing Tiller to stop his assult on Snyder!! Watch it and you will see they had NO concern that Tiller was ever in any danger 3. Look at the officer picking up Snyder, I think he was in disbelief and didn't know what to do since his fat lazy boss Tiller went crazy on a guy who was on his back and couldn't fight back 4. When is the last time you say a cop hit while other cops are around? Wouldn't you agree that when that happens they all get into the punching act? 5. Teh local procecutor knows Snyder didn't resist arrest, heck he was complying by leaving the building. The procecutor should be reviewed too, REMEMBER the DUKE incidence? A STATE/FEDERAL investigation should be conducted and I bet half would go to jail.

Posted by: Brad Location: USA on Oct 23, 2007 at 09:15 PM
I cannot believe there is any question what-so ever as to whether or not the police went too far. Wake up.

Posted by: The Real Uncle Sam Location: Ohio on Oct 21, 2007 at 03:16 AM
Welcome to America, 2007. Mr. Snyder, you are an insperation. Stand tall, and definately get paid.

Posted by: Keith Location: Melbourne, Australia on Oct 21, 2007 at 12:11 AM
This video is scary.The police appear to have no regard for keeping the peace free from favor or prejudice.The officer acted like a thug.More surprising was that no one stepped in to help this man.The people of this town must either be scared of police or hate this guy so much that they turned a blind eye during the attack.Continued pressure needs to be placed on the police & the town's leadership to force a dramatic shake up.The cronies need to be replaced with unbiased good governance.This man needs help too with all his legal costs. He shouldn't have to pay so much for fighting for justice.Is there a fighting fund for this man & if so could you please give the details on this internet site. Thank you.

Posted by: Anonymous on Oct 14, 2007 at 11:05 AM
This is factual information on how people are threatened in Roseland Indiana with council majority Ted Penn and Charlie Shields this was taken on February 22, 2006: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=tuVGqaYH9w0

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Roseland on Oct 13, 2007 at 12:35 PM
David Snyder was born in Roseland, his father was born in Roseland and his grandfather was also on the Roseland Town Council. A few bad eggs which you see on the video have used the media with lies and half truths to distort what has been happening in Roseland for years. "Hate the Snyders" is what they have been pushing, and sadly people were willing to buy it. Now, the brutality of this video is undeniable. The world sees who is in the wrong and who are the nasty people and the liars. Take stock Valparaiso, this could happen in your town. It could happen in any town. If there is a small group of felons and hate preachers/ugly mob, it can and will happen ANYWHERE to ANYBODY. David Snyder was attacked by Jack Tiller while lawfully doing Roseland town business. If you think this is OK, then you are part of the problem in America today. This ugly mob is trying to bully those who will stand up to them. Do you support this? If yes, turn in your American flag, you don't deserve it.

Posted by: Rico Location: Texas on Oct 5, 2007 at 08:12 PM
Just shows the kind of people who are being hired as law enforcement officers. Bullys bullys bullys. He needs some serious Texas style payback.

Posted by: Doug Location: Valparaiso In. on Oct 5, 2007 at 12:43 AM
David snyder is loud mouth bully who got what he had coming.That was garbage the way he spoke to that old man at that meeting.his actions brought about the intire event. he and his nasty wife need to get over the fact that there days of ruining roseland are over.I have been watching all these events unfold for quite some time now, and although I'm not a roseland resident, I feel for them all.The snyder family need to get a life.I can't believe he had the nerve to say having to pay child support was somehow a punishment what about his kids who have had to do with out because of there low life dead beat father, What a train wreck!

Posted by: Michael Location: Evansville, IN on Oct 3, 2007 at 08:14 PM
You know, I lived in the South Bend area for a little over 4 years. I left two years ago...............this nonsense is still going on? This man 'Snyder' and his lovely wife.....need to get a life!....an move on down the road!

Posted by: Ian Location: Louisville KY on Oct 2, 2007 at 11:54 PM
Well, I think the people have spoken, and this is the beuatiful thing about the internet. Our last chance to utilize our 1st amendment without complete fear of being detained for speakinf out. Soon, when the internet is taken from us, like they are trying to do in Aussie, we will get silenced. Until then, make noise!!! cheers

Posted by: Grant Cain Location: Wichita, Ks on Oct 2, 2007 at 10:25 PM
I can't believe the assault that cop got away with! Like many people have already stated, you can watch the reflection and tell that the accusations of Snyder provoking the altercation is absolutely absurd. Definitely assault & excessive force used by Tiller as you can see Mr. Snyders hands are restrained behind his back as Officer Tiller strikes him in the face and upper torso. We can no longer let this type of behavior go un-punished, Indiana or anywhere in America.

Posted by: Bob First Location: Vermont on Oct 2, 2007 at 02:45 PM
How about this woman wearing the yellow shirt, couldn't we charge her with the Indiana version of "inciting violence"? She certainly was encouraging the cop. Folks with that much hate need to find God, education, meditation or a little perspective. One thing is clear, Snyder was on his way out peacefully- if not with several mouthfuls of bad things to say- and nothing more would have transpired had he been allowed to leave untouched, even if Snyder did stop for 5 seconds to exchange verbal barbs. Bet Tiller is wondering what he did to deserve Penn's skillful help!!

Posted by: Greg Schmidt Location: Birmingham, Alabama on Oct 2, 2007 at 02:02 AM
The video tells the whole story, and clearly the reflection in the glass shows that the COP committed Police Brutality on Snyder. The COP needs to be fired, and Snyder will absolutely win a suit against the city. This kind of police brutality is typical of cops who have gotten away with this kind of behaviour in the past, and I'd bet a hundred bucks you can find other people who this cop has beaten. The video is being posted widely, including YouTube, so the word is getting out.

Posted by: jason Location: california on Oct 1, 2007 at 09:30 PM
This is not making national headlines? why?

Posted by: Ritch Location: Ft. Wayne, IN on Oct 1, 2007 at 09:56 AM
Penn was clearly lying. Firstly, Snyder was NOT handcuffed when Penn claims he was. Secondly, the video clearly shows that Tiller shoved Snyder with no physical provocation. Maybe Snyder said something Tiller didn't like, but Snyder did not swing at or shove Tiller prior to Tiller's shove. We can't see what transpired between the shove and when Tiller was pounding Snyder while he was on the ground, but Tiller was clearly beating on a subdued man. Snyder strikes me as a pain in the butt kind of guy, but Tiller was very much in the wrong and should be fired and prosecuted. I'm glad I don't live in Roseland.

Posted by: Eric Location: Florida on Oct 1, 2007 at 03:38 AM
Penns eyewitness testimony is a complete fabrication. Watch the video and his testimony a couple of times. Is that how easy it is to send an innocent man to jail in Roseland? In America? Is this how "official storys" are invented? Tiller clearly shoved Snyder threw the door and then Tiller gave Snyder some UFC ground&pound. I am not suprised if this Facist/Nazi/Soviet/Roman/redneck style of justice were to have happened down here in screwd up Florida. But to see it in Indiana? Indiana?? I thought you guys were the solid truthfull honest Christian heartland of America. Ron Paul 08

Posted by: Jess Location: Saginaw on Sep 30, 2007 at 01:20 AM
I find it funny that Tiller's wife claims that the media has smeared his name. No, sweetie, I think your hubby did that all by himself. So thank him.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: calif on Sep 30, 2007 at 12:11 AM
Cop is violent and way out of control...If he hasn't been fired, he should be.

Posted by: peggysue Location: south central la on Sep 30, 2007 at 12:08 AM
Ted Pen is a liar Snyder did not have hand cuffs on, and did not swing at no one. If he had swung at the cop his papers and camera would have been dropped in the hallway instead of outside. Ten Pen should be arrested for ubstruction of Justice and Tiller should be fired and never be allowed to work in public service again.

Posted by: Mark Location: SC on Sep 29, 2007 at 10:15 AM
It is obvious this incident was a one sided physical assault, with intent to cause harm, perpetrated by the police officer. He should be fired and prosecuted to the full extent of the law, for every crime imaginable or conceivable, involved with this incident. Futhermore, every and all previous arrests made by this police officer should be reinvestigated, as to the fact that the integrity of this said officer, is null and void. Which of course puts into any legal validity of any and all prosecutal evidence used by the justice system, stemming from said officer.

Posted by: Brian Location: Memphis TN on Sep 29, 2007 at 01:48 AM
It's clear that both officer Tiller and Ted Penn are liars. You can clearly see in the video that Snyder did not resist in any way. The reflection in the glass display case on the right shows that Tiller pushed Snyder through the doors and just started pounding. There is no reason for this kind of force in this situation. Snyder should file a lawsuit because he would surely win. Officer Tiller should be relieved of active duty pending a full investigation. Penn and Tiller are both liars. The camera just shows the truth.

Posted by: Vic Location: Los Angeles on Sep 28, 2007 at 11:47 PM
Tiller is an ignorant coward. A $6/hour petty-minded punk with a flimsy tin badge. Pushes an old man to the ground, then wails on him like he's in the UFC ring. What kind of small, cowardly man does something like that. Shame on Roseland and their thugs, (can't really call them the police now, can we, because they don't "protect and serve") Looks like a Saddam Hussein henchman, taking out the political opposition. Say, did Tiller previously work for Usay and Kuday, in their blackshirt death squads? Thats the same intellect they have on the force in Roseland.

Posted by: Jeannie on Sep 28, 2007 at 10:20 PM
WHAT HAPPENED TO AMERICA SOCIETY? I think Mr. Snyder is innocent

Posted by: shane Location: phila on Sep 28, 2007 at 05:46 PM
cop with an attitude, whats new ...............cops gotta stop punchin people in the head period!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Luke Location: Portland on Sep 28, 2007 at 01:33 PM
Even if he had hit the officer, this would still be unreasonable force. As it is, it's assault. If this officer doesn't get charged I'm going to be pissed. Had that officer gone just a bit further and have punched a bit harder he would have justified having a local CCL holder draw on him and use "all force necessary" to prevent injury to Mr. Snyder. Unbelievable.

Posted by: The Truth Location: Memphis, TN on Sep 27, 2007 at 07:11 PM
Analysis - I dont care about the personal attacks with these guys, I care more of the legal sense of all of this. He got kicked out for nothing. The cop said he hit him nervously and ran away from reporters, the old man said he elbowed him. Look at the reflection and for you small minded people, look at the very beginning, Snyder had so many things in his hands and between his arms and body that he couldn’t have given a hit, nor lift up his arms, proof? We heard the door open when he was thrown and saw the reflection of the door opening and his scream "ow" and 8 seconds later the camera is trying to film it all from the window, and you can clearly see that his camera and stuff was outside. Which brings us to the conclusion that he did not take a hit or else at least 1 of his things would of been inside the building! Period! Boo yah! Be very critical of what you read and see.

Posted by: Shocked Location: Wisconsin on Sep 27, 2007 at 05:14 PM
From viewing the video you can tell Ted Penn is not telling the truth. Why is Ted Penn covering for Jack Tiller. This whole thing stinks and gives the whole state of IN a bad name

Posted by: Jon Location: Colorado on Sep 27, 2007 at 04:38 PM
Pay attention to the reflection of the service window in the lobby as Snyder is being escorted out. Where's the violent act by Snyder that Penn mentions?? People have got to stop telling lies. For the good of humanity.

Posted by: Jon Location: Fort Collins on Sep 27, 2007 at 04:34 PM
This is freakin' rediculous. Ted Penn says he saw Snyder violently throw an elbow. You can clearly see through the reflection in the window that Snyder gets his head deliberately slammed into the glas of the outside door. Then to prove this was a violent crime by the officer you can hear a woman saying "that's what you get..."?! This is really sad, and the fact that the cop was intervied and says he was hit, Ted Penn saying he saw Snyder throw an elbow, and that others there are commending this action by the Police just shows how rotten some people in our society have become. Its time for the people of this country to take a stand, and elect Mike Gravel for U.S. President since he's the only guy in the race that is wiling to make some major changes, and allow our citizens to stand up for their rights. The time is now... We need to get Gravel the Democratic nomination! Its time for the people of good will in this county to take control of our fate.

Posted by: LUCKY on Sep 27, 2007 at 01:44 PM
The events in this video are terrible. Roseland has left a stain on America; on our police, our city governments and our citizens. Roseland is a disgrace and I wish I could say it was another country

Posted by: Sheesh Location: A Civilized State on Sep 27, 2007 at 08:20 AM
Why is it only outsiders can see that this mouse Tiller, was wrong and needs to be held accountable? It sounds as if Roseland and it's PD do not amount to anything more than a 6th grade education...Grow up Roseland.

Posted by: Matt Location: South Bend, IN on Sep 27, 2007 at 06:11 AM
O.K. I live in the same county as Roseland. This little stretch of land is embarassing. It is only a couple of miles when coming off the 80 90 toll road into Notre Dame, IN (South Bend). It does have several service and dining businesses. However, for the most part it is branded by poverty and crime. David Snyder is a real piece of work and I wouldn't throw him a rope if he were drowning. Hes is over $20,000 back in child support and constantly starts fights at these "town meetings." The whole panel is loaded with absurd characters (Yes, that means you Penn and Shields). However, Cptn Tiller, regardless of whether he was struck or not used excessive force. There was no resistance and the other officers were trying to get him off of Snyder. If he were struck I could see him throwing him through that door as you can see in the mirror, but certainly not beating him to a bloody pulp. Life is only gray, what do you see?

Posted by: ms.marie Location: michigan on Sep 27, 2007 at 03:18 AM
i have watched this comedy play out and it is fit for t.v veiwing.I'am so glad no people of color are involved i'am refering to mr.woods statement.If that was so they would have called in the national forces by now somebody would have been hurt or dead by now.yes mr.woods thing are still not equal or fair in this country yet.some of us have the right to protest in this country and not face retalation.yes i'am sure MR.SNYDER will take advantage of his rights as a white male and sue then he can write a book about his experiences.MR.WOODS if all involved had of been black this story and the outcome would have ended very differently.i'am sure "sir" you knew already.

Posted by: Val Horrorwitz Location: New York on Sep 27, 2007 at 02:41 AM
All of them; Fat, Ugly, Stupid, Violent. Filming each others acts of violence. So much repressed sadism going on. We need to reopen the book on Family Systems Psychology and take a long and hard look at how innocent children grow up to be disgusting over-fed, self-indulgent, immature sub-adults. But first we need to teach them how to read and write and think and feel beyond the 4th Grade level. The man may have been a boob but a Police Officer is a representative of the Rule of Law NOT the rule of a child-adult who has a big problem with his Parents that he's never worked out! The exchange between the two men during the meeting was solid, bonafide, Grade A immaturity in action. Does anyone who's seen this video need to ask themselves why they are letting immigrants in from all over the world? They are so anxious to get 'em in the country that they don't even care if they're legal. And I have NO doubt that one of the objectives is to get rid of people like the ones in this video.

Posted by: Shelly Location: Indiana on Sep 26, 2007 at 11:20 PM
If you even live close to the Roseland area, you would know David Snyder is out to gain more news coverage, he and his wife both enjoy the publicity. He and his wife need to go get a job for a change and maybe pay back the child support he owes, he's just another deadbeat Dad who needs the public eye to make him feel big. I'm sure officer Tiller is about as sick as the rest of us are, yeah excessive force, but Snyder running his mouth again is an excuse for him to sue someone else to pay his back child support....

Posted by: Mr Wood Location: Texas on Sep 25, 2007 at 08:00 PM
Good thing Snyder wasn't black, this would be on the evening news on all stations while they streamed about, "hate in America". Next riots would errupt and city would burn. This would all be followed up by a multi-million dollar lawsuit and the new richest man in town, Snyder would exclaim, "can't we all just get along?".

Posted by: Al Joelson Location: Texas on Sep 25, 2007 at 07:16 PM
Ted Penn is a LIAR. Snyder never threw any elbow at the officer. its clear as night and day on the tape. mr.penn u should be ashamed of yourself for lying so blatantly.

Posted by: Tom Location: Minneapolis, MN on Sep 25, 2007 at 06:12 PM
OMG, That Ted Penn guy is obviously lying in his video reaction. He says they were taking him out of the room in hand cuffs. They didnt hand cuff him until he was on the ground outside. And the guys hands were full and certainly didnt throw an elbow before the cop started shoving him to the door.

Posted by: Tim Location: NY on Sep 25, 2007 at 05:08 PM
Sure looks like the Tiller was way out of line. Snyder didn't deserve what he got. You have to wonder though if he is a royal PITA at town meetings on a regular basis. I have to laugh how some people are calling the pople in Roseland "rednecks". You people are small minded. This type of thing doesn't happen just in Roseland. It happens everywhere.

Posted by: Mike Location: Ohio on Sep 25, 2007 at 05:06 PM
So, Tiller only makes 6.50 an hour and blames this man for that? Perhaps he should change careers. To say this is good cause for police brutality is joke. The councilman in question was clarifying the chairperson didn't have the authority to dictate a time limit and that he did indeed have the floor.Why was he ejected for following the law? The chairperson was the man creating a public disturbance.(He had given up the floor and didn't seem to care about the laws governing the meeting)When judging the officers actions one really should take into consideration previous circumstances such as pay cuts,not as an excuse for his behavior, but rather as a motive in Officer Tiller's own criminal trial. Make no mistakes he is a criminal and it would appear the Prosecutor is one as well.

Posted by: Nathan Location: TN on Sep 25, 2007 at 01:53 PM
I can't stand it anymore. The use of excessive force is now a commonality and will continue as such until we take a stand against it. I believe that IQ tests should be a requirement for law enforcement. How is it that everyone seems to think that a police officer isn't just another citizen. This man is a citizen first and a PEACE officer second, therefor HE should be arrested and given time, not just fired or a paid leave. WAKE UP America. The police state is upon us. They can use force including tasering then just claim "he resisted". If you back talk a cop now-a-days they say you are resisting. It is sickening. And for all of the comments about "he has done nothing good for this town and deserves it", please think before making such comments. Watch some international news footage about how feds and police are allowed to abuse people. We do not want this in AMERICA! Ron Paul 2008

Posted by: Justin Location: Westwego, LA on Sep 25, 2007 at 01:23 PM
This fellow Ted Penn is a liar. You can clearly see from the RAW video in the window reflection that Snyder did not use any force on the officer. He was shoved out the doors to the ground immediately after he was out of camera range. If you listen closely you can hear Snyder make the comment "oh look the bully is back" then the officer gets outraged and shoves him out the doors. Then when we see him again hes being pounded on by the cop. If I were him I would SUE them, and the officer should be fired with charges being brought upon him. The people in the video also dissgust me. Its almost as if they were antagonising the whole thing. Snyder was also right about roberts rules of orders clearly he had the floor, and there is no time limit. That just goes to show you there are alot of uneducated people up there.

Posted by: Connie Location: Illinois on Sep 25, 2007 at 11:37 AM
My husband and I were considering a move to the Roseland area. He has been offered a position in the Mishawaka area and Roseland had the small town atmosphere that we were looking for. Not any more!! The city council's antics are reminiscent of grade school children when they are having tantrums, not to mention the policeman's actions....evidently civil rights in Roseland are non-existant. Even if the Snyder family is not the best neighbor and you don't agree with their lifestyle or actions. NO ONE should be treated this way especially by those in power...the council and the police. Roseland, you have lost a potential educator (myself), an engineer (my husband), and three beautiful children, a home buyer, community activists, and a family. We will not be the only ones staying away I'm sure.

Posted by: embarrased to be a Location: U.S. citizen on Sep 25, 2007 at 11:33 AM
I hope it was worth it Roseland. A moment of vengeance for the officer’s job, the town’s treasury, and a disgraced nation here in front of God and everyone. I’ve seen a few locals say “he had it coming”, but nothing more. Maybe some of you who have been to school could describe in this forum what did Snyder do to anger so many? My guess is he shut down your meth lab. Or is it just his fancy (sic) forren car?! Prepare yourselves world – the Jerry Springer generation has come of age! I’ll feel shame for you as you appear unable.

Posted by: allan johnson Location: washington dc on Sep 25, 2007 at 06:35 AM
obviously snyder has become a real thorn in that town's side, from the city counsel, to the da's office. this is about much more than just child support. but none of that justifies beating him up. and that cop is outright lying, proof: snyder's hands were full, one with papers and one with a tripod/camera. where did this stuff land? OUTSIDE. so snyder did NOT have use of his hands til he got outside, IF AT ALL. bcuz by the time the 2 reach outside, the camera is already there and we know from that point snyder was in no position to "hit" the officer.

Posted by: Hard to believe Location: America on Sep 25, 2007 at 05:50 AM
How can anyone believe that Tiller did not willfully attack a man that could not fight back? Snyder had his hands full and Tiller hit him from behind. Gross brutality. ST JOSEPH COUNTY PROSECUTOR MIKE DVORAK IS JUST LIKE MIKE NIFONG WHO USED THE DUKE BOYS FOR POLITICAL PURPOSES INSTEAD OF DOING THE RIGHT THING. It is a disgrace that Snyder was arrested after being beaten and it is ten days later and nothing has happen to the criminal Jack Tiller.

Posted by: The Outraged Person Location: Richmond Va. on Sep 25, 2007 at 04:52 AM
This video doesnt show the officer shoving the man into the glass door but you can hear it happen. when the camera finally reaches the incident, the footage clearly show the officer- repeatedly punching the man in his face. He didn't even get the opportunity to resist arrest. I don't believer that all police officers are bad, but americas police force is definately getting out of hand. I believer that a line should be draw somewhere, and that we as citizens of the united states of america should be able to bring up serious charges against any officer who crosses that line. I also believer that the charges should not just suspend an officer without pay or remove the officer perminately from duty, but the charges should carry some serious jail time. Maybe that might give the offensive officers something to thing about before they decide to use this type of brutality.

Posted by: Concerned person Location: Calgary on Sep 25, 2007 at 04:23 AM
From that video there is no way Snyder could have hit the cop. He was holding papers in his right hand, had a bag on his right arm, and was holding the tripod with his left hand. There's no way he can get a punch in without dropping all or some of the stuff he was carrying. Notice the papers as well as the tripod were all outside of the building on the ground beside the two men. When Snyder got shoved by the officer he reacted by hanging on to his possessions like most people probably would so everything went out the door with him. As much as it seems Snyder is not well liked in your town talk with your VOTES not with your FISTS. Tiller should receive 2 for instigating, 5 for fighting and a game misconduct. (In other words find another job.)

Posted by: Paul Location: Columbia, SC on Sep 25, 2007 at 02:20 AM
Is this town really a bunch of red neck vigilantes? Save some self respect for Roseland and prosecute Tiller, Ted Penn, his daughter and any one else in this premeditated criminal act. The fact that Penn's daughter is at the meeting with a camera to video tape this revenge is telling. She's taunting him with police approval through the entire incident. Where is her video? Where is the Attorney General? This is madness and these criminals need to be prosecuted and all charges against Snyder should be dropped. The video is clear as day.

Posted by: Leonard Location: California on Sep 25, 2007 at 01:24 AM
Penn's testimony should land him in jail for perjury, it's so full of holes. Beyond that, the brutality and taunting of the Marshall are on camera plain as day. Everyone playing along with this crime needs to be scrutinized.

Posted by: Corey Location: Chattanooga on Sep 25, 2007 at 12:58 AM
I'm a martial arts instructor with over 18,000 classes of experience teaching and in no way did David Synder attack the police officer like Ted Penn says he did. That police officer outright attacked David Synder. You can tell by the time that he left the room to the reflection in the glass that the police officer pushed him into the glass door. Penn says that David Synder hit the police officer by turning his upper torso but he didn't have time to do this. Also what's interesting is that Penn says the Tiller hit David and if you watch closely on the video you'll see that Tiller hit David not 3 but 4 times if you include Tiller's hit before he even went out the window. I hope that David Synder sues the butt off of that little piece of crap town for what they did to him. He deserves much more. The police are not what they used to be and the attitudes are just getting worse from the police. Be ready for a police state because it's coming. Go to infowars.com for more info on thi

Posted by: Jack Location: Seattle on Sep 25, 2007 at 12:54 AM
Clearly an over-reaction by the cops and probably intentional but given Indiana's rep as the true redneck capital of the planet, what else would Mr. Snyder expect in a town like Roseland?

Posted by: Fact Finder Location: Yankee land NY on Sep 25, 2007 at 12:28 AM
Roseland Indiana you are disgusting, because a man owes child support you would somehow decide that a severe and brutal beating is just reward-you cast the stone and if you are christians, you should say your deepest prayers-vengeance is thine sayeth the lord-is it ten or one hundred fold you will redeem? If you are just American you also should be ashamed of yourselves, this kind of behavior is dispicable-Across the country people have seen this terrible travisty of justice. I would never go to Roseland Indiana, and I would discourage others from going there to-for any event or reason! Disgusting!

Posted by: future cop Location: wisconsin on Sep 24, 2007 at 11:38 PM
to me it looks like when the officer grabbed snyder's arm then snyder said a remark..probably something like dont touch me and the cop went crazy..that ted penn's claim makes no sense..there wasnt even enough time in that hallway for snyder to turn and hit the officer and the officer hit back..it was just 3seconds at most and you just see the cop and snyder go forward into the door from a shove. i recently graduated to be a cop..and there are legal and illegal ways to make people comply when resisting...pumbling someones head is not a legal way..pressure points on the head yes..but not fist to the head..i'm sick of cops giving all cops a bad image we will all be portrayed this way and it's hard enough to gain citizens trust!

Posted by: Jesse Jackson Location: USA on Sep 24, 2007 at 02:09 PM
What is the status of this whole situation? Is the "cop" still paid with taxpayer dollars? What has the prosecutor decided to do? Any reaction on the lies Penn and Tiller told?

Posted by: Joe Location: Florida on Sep 24, 2007 at 01:20 PM
Is Ted Penn a politician? Cause he certainly lies like one.

Posted by: Sam Location: In Michigan on Sep 24, 2007 at 01:06 PM
What everyone seems to be forgetting is this: The Prosecutor has decided to go FORWARD with the charges against Snyder. If the Prosecutor thought is credible evidences he SHOULD go forward with it! Now on the other hand, if the Prosecutor thinks Mr Snyder has been a victim of police brutality, I would say in all fairness, charges SHOULD be filed against the officer. So far, I'm not aware of any charges being brought against him, correct?? From the angle of the camera, its at best, a GUESS as to what actually DID happen. Only those people sitting INFRONT of those doors would have any type of clear view. Reflects in the window doesn't get it for me. That's like "hear-say" evidence. Its a matter of one's perception and NOT a clear line of sight.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 24, 2007 at 01:00 PM
That's OK. Mr Snyder is BACK IN JAIL for contempt of court!! He won't be bothering anyone there, nor get himself into too much trouble there! Seems, he was ordered to FIND A JOB and pay $1800 a month. The Judge found out he only filled out ONE job application and paid less than $400 since last time he was before the Judge. Sooooo, the Judge got enough of him and its BACK to the jail for him!! If he wants to get out, this time it will cost him $20,800!!!! I LOVE this Judge! Justice is finally coming to this man. I don't know ANY PERSON ALIVE that would be out of jail for being this far behind in support...not one! I was wondering if the "system" was really broken (or worse yet, tainted) but the system is finally catching up to this man!! YEAH!!

Posted by: Terryk Location: Tifton GA on Sep 24, 2007 at 08:18 AM
As a 25 year veteran of police work I find the chiefs actions illegal. I can see clearly that the police were way out of line. Even when the chief was hitting Snyder another cop stops him from hitting him again. The reflection in the window as Snyder is leaving out shows Snyder with his hands full and his back toward the Chief. My GOD the chief attacked him!!! In the reflection Snyder never faces or comes around with his elbows as Penn described. NEVER! And Ted Penn was not anywhere near the truth in his interview. Penn lied an....Snyder was not hand cuffed until he left the room and was on the ground. IF he had cuffs on and the chief hit him, he was beating a prisoner that was in custody. I saw no resistance what so ever. Penn had his hands full of camera and files. I don't know what Snyder has done to anger so many but it appears he has suffered the wrath of an out of control vigilante group of thugs which includes the chief. My GOD what kind of people are the citizens of this town

Posted by: Brian Location: Louisville on Sep 24, 2007 at 07:11 AM
I hope that cop gets arrested and prosecuted and time. He is a threat to law-abiding citizens.

Posted by: marc Moldowan Location: san antonio , texas on Sep 24, 2007 at 06:23 AM
hope it ends up costing that city a ton!! they deserve to have it socked to them for this one!

Posted by: Melinda Location: Plymouth, Indiana on Sep 24, 2007 at 04:35 AM
ok, I have read alot of posts. I dont care what David Synder may or may not have done in the council. NOONE, and I mean NOONE deserves that. Especially coming from a cop who is paid to protect us. Thats not protecting us. He is the exact reason my kids are scarred of police. They watched their father and I be brutally ripped out oour home and their dad was beat by a cop because someone made a prank phone call to 911. There are methods of doing things in America, andevery day I see them get thrown out the door. If we dont put a stop to it, whats it going to be like when our grand children are born. What are we going to tell them? Its ok to hit someone for saying something that you dont like or how about, its ok for the police to attack you if they dont like you. If thats the case, than we would have people getting beat and killed every day just because their wages got cut or because someone did something that they did not like. Grow up! And to his wife, I feel sorry for you.

Posted by: marek Location: San Leandro on Sep 24, 2007 at 02:57 AM
This fat, huge and obnoxious cop is lying. No council member of half of the cop size will attack cop in uniform. Cop is a bully. He should be fired and prosecuted.

Posted by: Nick Location: Chester, SC on Sep 24, 2007 at 12:02 AM
There is obviously some kind of bias against the man who was attacked by the police officer. I could hear some encouraging the officer to "hit him for my Daddy"...what a nice place to live.... The lawsuit is gonna bankrupt their little militarized state...too bad.

Posted by: Mona Location: Glendale on Sep 23, 2007 at 11:37 PM
I want to nominate WNDU for the Pulizer Prize. Top professionalism in that the videoman did not turn off the camera just because he had to run out to watch the beating. This allowed us to count the seconds (3 seconds is what I get) from when Snyder left the door to the council chambers until the sharp sound of David's head being thrust into the glass door. Another thing this journalist did was to get a zoom on some sneakers to make sure his camera was working before he zoomed into Snyder's injures.

Professional video cameras need to have their color balanced when they move into different lighting environments. The photojournalist zoomed into the white sneakers and flipped a switch to make sure the color was not off. This process is called "white balancing." -WNDU.com


Posted by: Ben Location: Ohio on Sep 23, 2007 at 05:53 AM
What a circus!! Just one more example of corruption at its worst, even on a town council! First off, anyone that is willing to post a comment, needs to watch all the videos. Secondly, this story intrigued me to the point of going back and reading all the related articles posted here and on other sites. Amazing and disturbing stuff. Thirdly, having served in a law enforcement capacity in the past, the marshal here clearly used excessive force. The video clearly shows David turn around to walk out the building, then once his back is pretty much facing the officer, the officer immediately grabs Davids back and starts to lunge forward. Within a matter of about 2 seconds, you can see them slam through the door in the reflection. Meanwhile, the second officer walking behind shows no immediate need to intervene, as one would do if his fellow man was being attacked, as the marshal (and Penn) stated. Penn is plain lying, since David was NOT handcuffed, as he claimed on the video

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 23, 2007 at 05:46 AM
Looks like an open and shut case of police battery. The real question isn't if the police went too far, the real question is why hasn't Tiller been fired yet? Another real question is why isn't Tiller behind bars?

Posted by: Roy Location: Olalla Washington on Sep 23, 2007 at 01:59 AM
Watched the video and doesn't look as like David Snyder turned off his video camera. And if his video is clearer than the reflection in the glass door Marshal Tiller will lose his job & spend some time in the Iron Bar Hotel & David will become a very rich man. As to Mr Penn's testimony he must be waring X-Ray Specks to see throw the Marshal [very large man from the free dough nuts ]

Posted by: Amazed & Confused Location: Houston, TX on Sep 23, 2007 at 12:09 AM
Apparently the woman yelling about "you deserve it for what you did to my dad!" <--or something like that is the daughter of the Ted Penn guy. Apparently the Cop has a biased against David Snyder as well. The cop is lying, it's apparent. As many others have said, the reflection tells the story. He's carrying a camera in the left hand and papers in the other. He could achieve no force by swinging around like the lying Ted Penn claims. Classic case of a hill billy town "population approximately 700" & the people who think they are gods. This just speaks volumes of why the cititzens of this once great nation need to exercise their 2nd ammendment rights.

Posted by: Fire That Cop Location: Scotland U.K on Sep 22, 2007 at 11:25 PM
From what i can see on the video,the so called police officer started it.He pushed the gentleman through the glass doors onto the ground outside of the building then sat on the gentlemans back while pounding away at the back of his head.If this was to happen in Scotland U.K , that so called police officer would be fired and arrested and civil action would be taken against him by the state.this makes me so angry i travel to the U.S at least 4 or 5 times a year , and you have such a wonderful country with very friendly people , but someone like this thug can spoil what your forefathers built up and left for you all as a nation.the whole world is looking at you now America.please dont let thugs like this get away with breaking the law if you do,then its down hill from there.Stand up to thug police officers or any official that behaves in this manner.your country was built on truth and liberty for all,not for a selected few.get together and take your country back for your childrens sake .

Posted by: The Truth Location: Stockton,CA on Sep 22, 2007 at 07:30 PM
I had to watch this video twice. I can not believe there are places like this in America. I was upset listening to that jerk in city hall. I originally thought he was the guy that police were supposed to beat up and instead it was the calm and rational guy. He was taking verbal abuse from everyone. After he turned and said something on the way out, the cop shoves him ( look at reflection) out the glass door, while in handcuffs and is next on the ground getting pounded by a police officer. Then you have the girl in yellow shouting at him and now everyone affiliated /employed by Roseland have just started to lie to cover themselves. State investigation. I say fire the Cop and put him behind bars for a year. Fire the jerk mayor and put him behind bars for a year. Justice Served!

Posted by: sting bean Location: Austin, TX on Sep 22, 2007 at 06:21 PM
Ok. I watched the raw footage and I thought Snyder was the only one who acted professionally in the whole ordeal. You can see the actions of the officer, pushing Snyder at the door before the extensive beat down. Bottom line - excessive use of force on the part of the dirty dirty cop. He should be not only fired, but jailed. I don't care what provoked him, low pay or snide comments or what, nothing Snyder did justifies a filthy cop pushing a door open with his skull, shoving him to the ground, and beating him up. What a bully.

Posted by: PUNCH HIM on Sep 22, 2007 at 06:19 PM
He didnt have to do anything to provoke the cop he deserved it already

Posted by: string bean Location: Austin, TX on Sep 22, 2007 at 06:13 PM
That's messed up. That officer should be charged with assault just for beating the bejesus out of that man on the portion of the tape where you can see outside. I'd like to see the view from the person at the window that was there earlier.

Posted by: Harvey Highsmith Location: Vero Beach on Sep 22, 2007 at 06:04 PM
If you look at the tape close you can see what happened in the glass on the wall. Tiller pushed Snyder first! Synder could do nothing but fall. How could he have hit Tiller while falling. Penn's a not telling the truth.

Posted by: Randy Location: Warsaw Indiana on Sep 22, 2007 at 04:47 PM
It's just another example of the Police State that is bein erected around us. People need to wake up and take back OUR! country 911 was and inside job GO Alex Jones!!!!

Posted by: CORRUPTION Location: IN ROSELAND on Sep 22, 2007 at 02:02 PM
WHAT A FAMILY OF TRASH(PENNS). WHY DID THE "POLICE" LET THAT TRASH PENNS DAUGHTER HARRASS SNYDER?

Posted by: Luke Location: Wisconsin on Sep 22, 2007 at 12:36 PM
Officer Tiller's reaction is that Snyder hit him. Snyder did nothing of the sort and Officer is obviously lying, but somehow gets away with it.

Posted by: Luke Location: Wisconsin on Sep 22, 2007 at 12:31 PM
The original tape shows Snyder being provoked even more by the people around him. This is sick and I can't believe no one was standing up for him. You can see in the reflection in the display case that Snyder was shoved through the door and did nothing to provoke that action. Officer Tiller is a disgrace as a human being and a police officer.

Posted by: Paul Location: Roseland on Sep 21, 2007 at 11:58 PM
Snyder deserves that. If I was a Roseland cop I would of knocked him out the first punch. Looks like everyone is doing that UFC nowadays. He was driving a brand new jag and we dont even got nets on the basketball rims at the park!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! He is incompetant!!!

Posted by: Justin Location: Fords, New Jersey on Sep 21, 2007 at 11:53 PM
My question is: Did Snyder's actions (turning around and speaking) warant the sudden, violent attack and takedown by the police officer? People are saying that you can't see what really happened. From what I can see, Snyder made no movements which can be construed as aggressive. The attack was highly unprofessional on the part of the (hopefully soon-to-be-ex) police officer. Even if Snyder did respond by defending himself, I would like to think his lawyer could argue he did it out of self defense, instinctively because there was no verbal warning of the impending attack by the police officer (hence the dropped charges).

Posted by: Clayton Location: Hayden, Idaho on Sep 21, 2007 at 11:32 PM
I obviously wasn't there, and don't know what happened before the video starts, but it appears Mr. Snyder was trying to leave and was attacked from behind by the officer. Now I don't care what Mr. Snyder said about that thug's momma, it doesn't look like the officer handled the situation very well. The sarcastic question he posed as to whether Mr. Snyder tripped and fell was also very unprofessional.

There is an extended version of the video listed above. You can click on the RAW VIDEO option at the top of the screen to see the disagreement that lead up to the incident. -WNDU.com


Posted by: Jim Location: Arizona on Sep 21, 2007 at 11:25 PM
David Snyder himself brought much of it on himself by the treatment of cutting the police pay to below poverty level wages. YOu people need to understand the underlying cause of anger here.

Posted by: James Location: Osceola, IN on Sep 21, 2007 at 11:11 PM
The actions of the Snyders is very disgusting and unthinkable. Davids cocky attitude will finally get the best of himself. He is the one who should resign from office!

Posted by: Tom Location: Toronto Canada on Sep 21, 2007 at 09:21 PM
Sadly, this will likely end with a conviction. Why? Not because he did anything illegal or inappropriate, but because the US is corrupt to the bone, and very vengeful. Hearing the woman screaming for him to be beaten, disgusting. Its incident like these, that discourage me from visiting the US. I just don't feel safe.

Posted by: ernie Location: michigan city in on Sep 21, 2007 at 09:11 PM
jack tiller, the new face of american law enforcement. this country has been cripto-facist for some time, and now its going to a full on martial law police state. this is not the country i thought it was, and i believe that i have been betrayed. the school i went to, the air force i was a part of, and the flag i saluted is nothing but a big fat LIE. and here is the frightening part. its not going to ever get any better. its going to get worse and worse. there is no new world to escape to. i will continue to work hard, get just enough to keep a cheap rented roof over head, and simple food to keep alive earning money for my master, and to wait for the day when i will be sent to a concentration camp for this thought, and others i have left on the internet. the law is a tool of the mighty to press the weak, the gun the great equalizer. too late for the gun, im afraid. we had our chance 15 years ago, america is full of cowards. too bad for your children, they are doomed to be slaves . amen

Posted by: Dustin Location: PA on Sep 21, 2007 at 07:09 PM
FREEDOM OF SPEECH people. I have respect for a man who stands for what he believes and doesn't hide behind his little servants to do his dirty work for him.

Posted by: Adam Location: Houston on Sep 21, 2007 at 06:27 PM
This is truly sickening. Your town is the laughing stock of the country. Not because of whatever policies the Snyders implimented, but because of your thuggish police force and the city officials boldly lying to protect them. I hope everyone is happy that bubba police officers who can't keep their belts on and redneck cackling women is the face of Roseland. Your town may not be advanced enough to have it yet, but the internet disperses information very quickly. Soon your police force will be laughed at, lampooned, and seen as the norm not just by americans but also by the world. Corrupt officials, violently brutish police officers, and rednecks: this is how you have portrayed our country to the world. Thanks a lot Roseland.

Posted by: Eric Location: Park City on Sep 21, 2007 at 04:03 PM
There is no criminal lower than a crooked cop. We place our trust in them, pay them (albiet poorly) and give them authority over us. In return, they're supposed to uphold the law and protect us from lawbreakers. When they turn on us, as the sorry pig in this video clearly did, they are betraying more than our laws. They are betraying our trust, and their own honor. This loonbird needs to be in PRISON. I don't care how much child support that Snyder guy owes, or how big a jerk he may be. That has nothing to do with it. Dirty cops are scum, and need to pay. They give the entire profession a black eye, and they also place their hard working, brave collegues in physical danger. Why? Simple: If there are enough corrupt, violent cops then it is inevitable that society will eventually begin to defend itself against them. After all, that is precisely why we have the 2nd Amendment. We have a COUNTRY because citizens turned on corrupt officials and began shooting them.

Posted by: kay Location: ft wayne on Sep 21, 2007 at 12:57 PM
Ted Penn said he went to hit him with his "handcuffed hands or whatever" David was not handcuffed at the time.

Posted by: Mike Location: Miami on Sep 21, 2007 at 11:39 AM
All those people stood and gawked while a man was brutalized by a state goon who clearly - and rightly - feels he is untouchable. Disgusting. The person who said "Let the police handle it" should be ashamed of himself. People get the government they deserve.

Posted by: Interested Location: Florida on Sep 21, 2007 at 11:01 AM
Look at the reflection in the glass. As soon as the police office thinks he is out of sight, he shoves the councilman forward and slams him through the door. That reflection in the window tells the whole story. The councilman could subpoena that video from the TV station and use it to sue the police department for brutality. Penn is a liar and goes so far as to claim that the councilman is handcuffed as he is being escorted out. That, obviously, is not the case.

Posted by: Amir Location: South Bend on Sep 21, 2007 at 10:11 AM
I moved here from NYC. What on earth is wrong with that place? I thought Brooklyn was bad...

Posted by: Brad Location: Texas on Sep 21, 2007 at 03:45 AM
The only other "eye witness" (Ted Penn) his credibility ruined- not to mention that his statement is a lie, if you look close with the video full screen Snyder switched his books to his right hand and had the camera in the left so how could he have swatted at the officers face? Penns cred. was ruined because if you look he is wearing glasses in the meeting, but for his statement they are off... now the last time he was on vid. he had them on, but since they are off for camera interview I would suspect that he doesn’t like to wear them alot (maybe he likes to take them off when looking out into the public eye like the everyone in the back of the hall). Even if he had them on at that distance he still might not have the best eye site. So I would conclude that what I see from the video is valid and his statement was fabricated after the confrontation.

Posted by: Helen Location: USA on Sep 21, 2007 at 02:56 AM
Don't you see what's happening? This is Nazi Germany all over again.

Posted by: policebrutalityisreality Location: colorado on Sep 21, 2007 at 02:15 AM
i'd like to say how glad i am i moved out of the south bend indiana area after seeing this, but the reality which anyone who's paying attention knows is that THIS TYPE OF THING HAPPENS EVERY DAY, IN EVERY AREA OF THESE UNITED STATES... get your heads out of your...well, wherever they are. This country was founded on violence. wake up.

Posted by: John Location: Iowa on Sep 21, 2007 at 01:58 AM
I'm a junior in high school and for as long as I can remember have wanted to become a cop. After seeing this, and other videos of police brutality, I will NEVER be caught dead wearing that badge. The 'police' in that video are absolutely DISGRACEFUL and a complete embarrassment to American law enforcement everywhere.

Posted by: Jon Location: St. Louis on Sep 21, 2007 at 01:15 AM
The unmistakable stench of corruption is hovering around that cop in his short interview.. as well as Tiller's. Its obvious that all of the prominent voices heard in the background of the actually incident are of a morally impoverished, clannish mindset.

Posted by: A.E. Moose Location: USA on Sep 21, 2007 at 12:54 AM
It is perfectly clear that we are now the Nazis.

Posted by: Wes Location: Nashville on Sep 21, 2007 at 12:35 AM
To Craig in Bristol Tennessee: To answer your question, the police in Roseland appear to be the same type that have been just down the road from you in Bluff City, Mount Carmel, Kingsport, Weber City Virginia, and many other locations around the country. The problem in Roseland has been going on as long as we have had police. The problem is our justice system does not have enough checks and balances to keep those with power honest. Read Freakonomics. It's all about incentives; whether they be positive or negative.

Posted by: Erik Location: Pennsylvania on Sep 20, 2007 at 09:49 PM
Still in shock after watching this video! To watch that incident makes me so irate. I pray that justice is served here, and that police officer never serves a day on any police force again. Is this what our Law Enforcement is coming to?? What country are we living in anyways?

Posted by: Forrest Location: Whelan on Sep 20, 2007 at 09:47 PM
The corruption of that town council is vividly apparent when the one councilman says, "Battery, Jack? How's that? Who hit you, Jack?" Then, "Did you trip and fall?" There are some extremely corrupt officials in that town. I wouldn't trust a single one of them in my home alone.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 20, 2007 at 09:27 PM
Like I've said before, this is better than any WWF Raw or Smackdown I've ever watched....and it's FREE too!

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Chicago on Sep 20, 2007 at 08:45 PM
I have driven through roseland many times and one thing is for sure, you always slow down when you get there or they are on you. This is just one more example of how cops are out of control. major lawsuits and jail time is needed against these roseland cops. that cop couldn't even keep his belt on. total disgrace.

Posted by: JAY Location: GRANGER, IN on Sep 20, 2007 at 07:27 PM
It appears like this cop has gone to far...but what most people don't know is that this "victim" is quiet deceiving. Just look how he handles himself after the "fight". I would have been outraged with anger, instead this guy has his snide remarks. Mr. Snyder himself has had several encounters with the law and particulary this police force, including a previous fight with another counsel members in which I believe he was charged. The police officer knowing this guy is a THUG instead of a poor little counsel member may have caused him to act more force fulling than what we would feel comfortably with. I feel we need more history and background info before we stake our claim. All I have ever heard is that this guy is an absolute crook! I promise...he is loving this attention and as previously stated by others...I'm sure he will sue, the problem is he already bankrupt the town!

Posted by: gail Location: niles on Sep 20, 2007 at 06:55 PM
If the prosec lets this go, then it will be open season on cops. The good ones will suffer and the bad ones will have everything to back them up when it happens to you! Everyone needs to call the pros. office and give your opinion. How about the other times that Tiller has gotten away with the same abuse? What else has he done over the years. Wasn't he a county cop for awhile? Why was he let go?

Posted by: Justin Location: Ohio on Sep 20, 2007 at 05:27 PM
Amazing, simply amazing that people are standing up for this cop. The reflection in the glass window shows no hitting by the accused, just an angry monkey cop abusing his authority.

Posted by: Anon Location: U"SA on Sep 20, 2007 at 05:12 PM
Those responsible should be sued by Mr. Snyder under 42 US Code Section 1983 Civil action for deprivation of rights. This includes every police officer and the councilembers. http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/html/uscode42/usc_sec_42_00001983----000-.html

Posted by: Paul Location: USA on Sep 20, 2007 at 04:38 PM
Everything you need to see is on the tape and in the reflection. I hope authorities outside the town will launch a full investigation. That cop needs to be prosecuted, along with anyone that provided false witness statements in support of the cop. To the people in that backwards town who support the cop, what is wrong with you people? You've demonized the victim to the point that you are only a half step away from a full lynch mob mentality and the complete loss of your humanity. Let go of your hate and pray to God for forgiveness, the path you are on is founded in deep evil.

Posted by: Craig Location: Bristol, Tennessee on Sep 20, 2007 at 03:54 PM
I'm in Tennessee and I see this video. What kind of police do you people have? The police are suppose to "serve and protect" not beat the living crap out of us. Thank God that cop didn't have a taser or he would have put 50,000 volts into that councilman. Good Greif...

Posted by: Jeff Location: California on Sep 20, 2007 at 03:48 PM
I am very glad I don't live in the town of Roseland. The bald council member should be removed from office for being a jerk. Why not have the the audio tape replayed to answer the question of how much time was given Synder to speak. That would have taken 1-2 minutes, and then it would have been over. Makes Roseland look really, really, stupid as a town.

Posted by: Kathy Location: Texas on Sep 20, 2007 at 02:30 PM
Looks like most every small hick town in Texas. I know what the video showed, I saw a so called marshall react to name calling.

Posted by: Paul Location: Florida on Sep 20, 2007 at 02:27 PM
This many comments and the only ones that side with the cop's story are people who just don't like Snyder? The guy may be a jerk, but what happened to him was illegal.

Posted by: A G Location: Washington DC on Sep 20, 2007 at 02:05 PM
LOOK CAREFULLY. The video does show all. Look at the reflection of the glass in the hallway.

Posted by: pj Location: colorado on Sep 20, 2007 at 01:59 PM
Remind me to never drive through your backward little town. Geez! What a total disgrace you rednecks are.

Posted by: Sally Location: Michigan on Sep 20, 2007 at 01:53 PM
Ok, why do they have council meetings on Friday nights? Seems to promote the Friday Night Fight mentality. Don't people in Roseland go to high school football games? I can understand being frustrated with the Snyder mentality, but this whole ongoing saga has made Roseland a world-wide laughing stock. Why the residents put up with it is beyond me.

Posted by: Ally Location: Elkhart, IN on Sep 20, 2007 at 12:56 PM
I see a cash law suit against the police in Roseland with this video. Maybe now David Snyder will get the extra money to pay his X the child support she's owed. Or maybe another sports car. Hmm

Posted by: Janet Location: NC on Sep 20, 2007 at 12:48 PM
I feel sick to my stomach after watching what that officer did. So much for the slogan "to serve & protect". These ongoing Gestapo fascist tactics have got to stop. I will never ever visit that town. I sent the story and video to everyone I know so that the world will see what kind of people you are. Shame on you all.

Posted by: Robert Location: Kansas City on Sep 20, 2007 at 12:30 PM
How much longer will the American people allow the brutality from police, criminal infractions from the government? Protesters arrested, wheelchair bound woman tasered, university student tasered after he was cuffed on the ground and more. I can only suggest to anyone reading this, stop listening to the lies they're brainwashing you with and start researching into events with your mind.

Posted by: Rob Campbell Location: Prague, Czech Republic on Sep 20, 2007 at 12:17 PM
I hope everyone who sees this calls to complain to the local police department. Yet another example of police abusing their power. Hopefully he'll sue the department and get a few million.. it's the only deterrent in cases like this, since of course the investigation (if any) will find he acted appropriately.

Posted by: John Location: Kansas City on Sep 20, 2007 at 12:02 PM
If I'm out of gas anywhere near Roseland, I wouldn't buy a gallon there for fear a fraction of that money might go to pay the salaries of a horrible police force. Seriously, the people at that meeting sound like pathetic rednecks who get off on seeing people beat up. Can we just relinquish your entire town from our country.

Posted by: Rachel Location: Indiana on Sep 20, 2007 at 11:59 AM
I can't believe they are still charging him with resisting an officer and disorderly conduct! Has anyone at the DA's office actually watched the video? The guy was walking out the door. Making comments as he was leaving does not equate to disorderly conduct. Nor did I see him resist the officer. What charges are being brought on the cop? He committed a crime, and also filed a false police report. He gets suspension, or some other wet-noodle treatment, for committing a violent crime. He needs to be arrested.

Posted by: Mary Location: Texas on Sep 20, 2007 at 11:43 AM
I saw the marshal push him, in the video, as he went out the door. Another example of a narco fascist thug losing control and assaulting a citizen for no reason. Felony charges should be filed against the marshal for abusing his authority by using unreasonable, excessive force. Too many people are being abused because of expressing their first amendment rights.

Posted by: lanny Location: little rock ar. on Sep 20, 2007 at 11:31 AM
check out the reflection in the glass in the foyer

Posted by: Jeff Location: Granger on Sep 20, 2007 at 11:29 AM
While we did not see what transpired in the hallway, I found the physical force of the police officer disturbing. Clearly Mr Snyder is on his stomach in a non threatening position. The sucker slaps from the police officer were unnecessary.

Posted by: Carl Location: Roseland on Sep 20, 2007 at 11:02 AM
Fire that cop.

Posted by: Jeff Location: Louisiana on Sep 20, 2007 at 10:30 AM
What amazes me is the blatant lies by Jack Tiller and Ted Penn. I've watched the video a few times, and Snyder never initiated any physical contact. See how easy it is for false charges to be brought upon a person? If not for the video, these false statements by eye witnesses would be taken as gospel. Snyder may not be liked, but there's no excuse for a man to be treated this way in America.

Posted by: Ted Location: las vegas on Sep 20, 2007 at 10:26 AM
What a disgrace of a town. The world can see your lies, idiots.

Posted by: Michael Location: Dallas, TX on Sep 20, 2007 at 10:24 AM
Whoever this "Ted Penn" person is, he is obviously related, or a cheerleader for the local police department. His on-camera testimony directly contradicts the video footage. Mr Penn states that Snyder is being led in handcuffs by Marshall Tiller, when the video clearly shows Mr Snyder LEADING the officer with books in his left arm and a video camera/tripod in his right. Snyder then said something to the officer and was shoved through the small hallway and into (and subsequently out of) the glass door. If one pays attention to the reflection from the wall, he will recognize Mr Snyders head bouncing off the door! The first portion of the scene outside shows Mr Snyder clearly laying on his stomach being punched in the head. I'd like to know who the loudmouth girl (child?) was saying "get him once for my dad' and "he nearly killed my dad" and "can I kick him once?" Clearly, the townsfolk don't like Snyder, but isn't it more legal to express dislike by not voting for him?

Posted by: Nathan Location: Houston, TX on Sep 20, 2007 at 10:14 AM
Ted Penn is a liar. LIAR! and This feud had nothing to do with the events of that day. What the heck people.

Posted by: JD on Sep 20, 2007 at 09:40 AM
Fascist country! And look at the bystanders laughing while the cop bashes the guy's head. What a display of moral superiority for the rest of the World... Pathetic and sickening!

Posted by: Jim Location: Elkhart on Sep 20, 2007 at 09:41 AM
Watching the Roseland situation from a distance and knowing what's happened in the past with the council, I think this is one of the funniest things I have ever seen! Never have I seen a happier guy get his butt kicked by an underpaid cop. I'm sure there's a line of people that would do the job for free and maybe with the money savings, Snyder could take it and pay his child support like a man. Keep up the good work Roseland, you make us all proud!

Posted by: Anon. Location: Not the U.S thank god. on Sep 20, 2007 at 09:32 AM
Well at least the guy is probably going to walk away with a decent settlement. Take that taxpayers!

Posted by: Concerned on Sep 20, 2007 at 09:25 AM
Roseland Council President Charles Shields must have forgotten that this occurred... could someone please remind him... he needs to call an executive session to get Officer Tiller off the streets.

Posted by: Darrin Location: Louisiana on Sep 20, 2007 at 08:27 AM
How did Snyder get a punch in? He had a packet of papers in his right hand and a camera or something on a tripod in his left hand, how do you punch with both hands full. The cop is on top of him punching him, Snyder is face down while he does this. Had I been there and saw this Jack would have recieved a swift kick in the face, right in front of his two cop buddies.

Posted by: Simon Location: Dublin, Ireland. on Sep 20, 2007 at 08:11 AM
Disgrace actions by the police. You can clearly see in the reflection that he wasn't resisting at all, got pushed smack into the outside door and fell. If there was any provocation it was him saying "Oh look the bully is back". He also clearly looked like he was out cold when he was getting the face punched off him. Hope he looses his badge for this.

Posted by: jennifer Location: Florida on Sep 20, 2007 at 07:55 AM
My comment, opinion, and something to think about is if you think that is bad what do you think they do to black people? Does it make more people open their eyes to how those with authority sometimes abuse it??? So, now I have a question, Are we still going to just turn the other cheek make the wrong a right or is real JUSTICE I mean REAL JUSTICE going to be upheld here for this man? Let's make an example in the favor of the right this time!! Charge the cop CLEARLY responsible for this ASSAULT with the right charge. If you or I had done this we would be in jail right now waiting to go before a judge, we would have something like assault or battery as our charge! Not to mention if the gentlemen had put his hands on an officer he would have been charged! This country is going to hell in a hand basket. NOT ALL COPS ARE A REFLECTION OF THIS ONE! But it makes it a little more understandable why some have no respect for the law when you see things like this!

Posted by: AndyM Location: Ireland on Sep 20, 2007 at 07:29 AM
I am shocked to see suck outrageous police brutality. I had though tAmerica was a land of justice wiht a police that protects and serves, but this video and the brutal beating from that officer of a man on the ground (what threat was the man then???) make me question that belief. Best wishes to David Snyder for a speedy recovery, and hefty compensation from the lawsuit! Small town tyrany? I think so. Isn't their some law about filming and taunting someone in handcuffs? I refer to the girl shouting "You get yours, this is for my father" and so on. Reminds me of Abu Gharib!

Posted by: Frank Location: America-Home of the not so free on Sep 20, 2007 at 05:17 AM
Everything about this story is blowing my mind. I am just floored by the fact that the police attack and assault this man. and then try to charge "him" with assault! I love that Ted Penn's reaction video. That guy is the biggest and worst liar I have ever seen. That guy needs to be fired along with the bad thug cop.

Posted by: John Location: USA on Sep 20, 2007 at 04:51 AM
This is horrific police brutality. Yes matt you can clearly see in the glass reflection that this victim of police brutality did not take a swing at the officer. You should also note that before he is assaulted by the police officer, you can clearly see that he is carrying an expensive camera and tripod in one hand, and a notebook in the other hand. He didn't have a free hand to take a swing. I am especially disgusted at how after he is on the ground cuffed that they joke at him that he tripped and fell and "who hit you?" -and the vicious lady saying you deserved it. I'm tired of cops lying and sticking up for each other even when they commit murder and brutality. Are there any decent honest cops left?

Posted by: Troy Location: Clemson on Sep 20, 2007 at 04:12 AM
First, I don't live in Roseland, and I'm not familiar with Snyder. But I have witnessed the effects of poor politicians, drama-queens, manipulative people, and downright awful human beings. They can wreak lives, and maybe even towns. It looks like this alleged "manipulator" outsmarted the cop and did what he does best on center stage. He got under the cops skin, and was rewarded with a remarkable opportunity. Anger and stress overtook Tiller's better judgment, and he made BIG mistake. A bad move, by someone who is given a gun and trusted with keeping the peace. To those supporting the officers actions, consider this... You probably don't like this Snyder character, but this incident played right into his hands. An irrational move, by a hot-headed cop just made Snyder a Martyr. Jack Tiller needs to be severely reprimanded, or relieved of duty. His poor decisions were ruled by emotion, and served the best interests of no-one. Also, Snyder needs to move! Good luck, Roseland

Posted by: human Location: earth on Sep 20, 2007 at 03:53 AM
WOW! Did all these people just crawl from the primordial stew? I don't even know how I exist in the same plane of reality as these people. Even the article is full of bad grammar and misspellings. What a great place to live huh?

Posted by: Tex Location: Au,TX on Sep 20, 2007 at 03:28 AM
Civil settlements do nothing to prevent this. We need real jail time for such people.

Posted by: Gary Location: Winnipeg on Sep 20, 2007 at 03:20 AM
I watched the video and found it quite disturbing. There was no doubt that this was Police Brutality and the officers that were responsible should be fired and then charged with assault. Your town/city has just proved that Idiot America is alive and thriving so if you want change then I suggest you fire the entire corrupted police for along with the DA and make sure you hire replacements with an IQ higher than 70. This man that was attacked was a council member and was beaten for what reason? Good luck to your barbarian culture.

Posted by: Richard Location: Modesto, CA on Sep 20, 2007 at 03:01 AM
Now that this video is getting wide attention, I hope Roseland, IN will take advantage of the ensuing publicity for drawing tourists. Perhaps they could devise a festival or attraction focusing on their love for FASCISM? Perhaps a statue of Mussolini in the town square, or a goose-step parade by their fine police force, ending with a burning of the Bill of Rights. The community could prosper as a focus for freedom-haters and others who oppose liberty. Perhaps a name change would put the point across further - How about IRON GUARD...or HITLER CORNERS.

Posted by: Paul Location: South Bend on Sep 20, 2007 at 02:49 AM
What a bunch of inbreds, letting the cops beat that man up. Outrageous

Posted by: Danielle Location: Adirondacks, NY on Sep 20, 2007 at 02:36 AM
Cops are over militant these days. These people need to be reconsidered before being hired. Their power makes them feel above the law. I could see escorting the man out of the building and locking him out. But beating him repeatedly in the head is WRONG!!!! The cop should be jailed!!!!!

Posted by: Raymond Location: Washington on Sep 20, 2007 at 02:32 AM
Being a police officer for 10 years I am absolutely disgusted and appalled after watching and following this story. I truly hope that there is no Blue Wall of Silence with this incident.

Posted by: Matt Location: Charlotte, NC on Sep 20, 2007 at 12:27 AM
Why would you ever justify this nonsense? It is clear this man was shoved out the door and onto the ground where he was beaten face down on the pavement. People have said otherwise, but you can even see the reflection off the glass as the officer charges behind him – guy never had a chance to strike back so stop insulting people’s intelligence. Sickening abuse of power was clearly demonstrated here. No one has offered a single concrete example of what this guy has done to deserve this. Of coarse these accusations come from angry mob like mentalities which are unable to use facts to justify this brutality. Nothing this guy could have said ever warrants this type of treatment. Are you so feeble minded that you can’t hear his words, besides, didn’t we used to take pride in a free country? Scary, we put so much trust into people who have a badge, sometimes the only word over the accused. This is tyranny in a small town, but a sign of where this country is going...

Posted by: Becky Location: Atlanta on Sep 20, 2007 at 12:25 AM
This is a total outrage. It is policemen like this that give the good policeman a bad name. It happens everyday, wake up people and take back our right. Police do not have a right to abuse anyone, even criminals. I am engaged to one of the last few "good policeman" and he sees things like this all the time, it makes him very angry. Small town government and police departments can ruin a persons life in a matter of minutes. It is time for the "good ole boy system" to be done away with and sweep our departments clean to restore what our police departments and government bodies were meant to be, not what they have become.

Posted by: Matt Location: Charlotte, NC on Sep 20, 2007 at 12:04 AM
Why would you ever justify this nonsense? It is clear this man was shoved out the door and onto the ground where he was beaten after being forced face down unto the pavement. People have said otherwise, but you can even see the reflection off the glass as the officer charges behind him – guy never had a chance to strike back so stop insulting people’s intelligence. Sickening abuse of power was clearly demonstrated here. No one has offered a single concrete example of what this guy has done to deserve this. Of coarse these accusations come from angry mob like mentalities which are unable to use facts to justify this brutality. Nothing this guy could have said ever warrants this type of treatment. Are you so weak that you can’t hear his words, besides, didn’t we used to take pride that this was a free country? Scary, we put so much trust into people who have a badge and nearly always take their word over the accused. In fact, there are plenty of times when the arresting officer’s words are the only justification needed to lock someone up. This, I’m afraid to admit, is where tyranny begins…

Posted by: Joe Location: Kansas City on Sep 19, 2007 at 11:54 PM
I can't believe that some of you people actually believe this warranted. I'm also amazed at the people that blame him for destroying Roseland's economy, when the people of that town are just as much to blame, since they let it happen. Gary, what part of being an aggressive bully is part of a cop doing his job. Also, with his arms pinned beneath him, how can he be resisting being put in handcuffs? Why was he arrested for arguing with the cop in the first place? What are we paying taxes for?

Posted by: Adam Location: California on Sep 19, 2007 at 11:50 PM
Wow, what kind of backwards town defends cops for beating citizens for speaking at city council meetings? No matter what David Snyder said to the office there is not excuses for beating a man pinned to the ground. It is clear that the other office realizes Tiller is in some crazed state of mind and taps him out of his assault on Snyder. It does not matter what actions Snyder committed in the past (it is clear many people in Rosewood dislike him), when we allow our peace officers to brutalize our fellow citizens we begin a quick decent into a totalitarian lifestyle. Today it was a disliked neighbor and we justify the officer's actions because, "Snyder had it coming." But tomorrow it might be someone we care about, someone we respect, a good neighbor and we won't become apologetic for the police. By giving into the mistreatment of even a despised peer we give into the future mistreatment of our friends and family.

Posted by: Bob Location: Chicago on Sep 19, 2007 at 11:34 PM
"Marshal" Jack Tiller is a coward and should not only be fired but sent to jail for the obvious abuse of power. Wearing a badge is not an excuse to be a sadist.

Posted by: Tony Location: Caso on Sep 19, 2007 at 11:32 PM
Those are not the actions of a "peace officer", what I saw was a hired thug looking for an excuse to pounce on his victim. Another sad example of our country becoming a police state.

Posted by: john Location: washington dc on Sep 19, 2007 at 11:27 PM
you can clearly see in the reflection that the cop just shoves him straight to the ground outside. There's no chance mr snyder did anything other than maybe try to break his fall. That's assault, pure and simple. I hope that cop not only loses his badge, but goes to jail.

Posted by: Hank Location: Police State, North America on Sep 19, 2007 at 11:22 PM
the officer was within his rights? Maybe in communsist china. Fired isnt good enough, he needs to be charged with assault and battery. "dont taze me, bro!". Yeah its really funny till youre getting lit up up with 50,ooo volts. Keeping turning a blind eye to the police state, and you can rest assured you will.

Posted by: Concerned Citzien Location: Police State on Sep 19, 2007 at 11:10 PM
Reading these comments makes me sick. A man was brutally assaulted for no reason. The cop tackled him from behind sat on his back and repeatedly punched him in the face while some women cheered on "get em for ma dad". How can you people defend these actions. This was a violent savage unprovoked attack on a human. Wake up America!!!

Posted by: Bill Location: Canada on Sep 19, 2007 at 11:02 PM
No matter what Snyder did or said to the officer on the way out, when the officer got on top of him and started punching, that was inappropriate behavior. The only thing the officer should have done after the suspect was on the ground was to handcuff him. Throwing punches is excessive use of force, and the officer should be reprimanded.

Posted by: Joseph Location: Michigan on Sep 19, 2007 at 11:00 PM
Thiis officer was clearly out of line and should be fired. He seems very unstable indeed. Wearing a uniform should not give anyone the right to act like lunatics. A disgrace to police officers everywhere.

Posted by: DanM on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:59 PM
Well, Jackie in Michigan, I don't like your comments very much - maybe I should send an officer to your house to physically assault you. Seriously, grow up or move.

Posted by: Sam Location: Richmond, IN on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:56 PM
Considering this and everything else that has come up lately, it just seems like everyone involved needs to take a chill pill.

Posted by: Mike Location: Colorado on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:55 PM
This cop should be put in jail.

Posted by: Peggy Location: DFW Texas on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:55 PM
I hope Mr. Snyder sues that town into bankruptcy. I also hope that bully cop gets what is coming to him. He should be ashamed of himself and should be fired. Mr. Snyder should contact the ACLU. This sincerely ticks me off, I don't care what you have against the Snyders, the policemans actions were unjustified.

Posted by: Kenton Location: Louisville, Kentucky on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:54 PM
When they are escorting Snyder outside and and give him a rough shove they move out of the view of the camera. The cops will try to use this to their advantage and say that he struck one of them the moment before they pushed out of the front door. (Which is exactly what Tiller did). What they may forget is that you can clearly see in the reflection what happened when they were out of view of the camera. In the reflection no arms were swung and there wasn't even time for resisting. Clearly this cop just barged him out of the front door and slammed him to the ground and started beating him. Jack Tiller says that he hit him. WATCH THE VIDEO, WATCH THE REFLECTION. JACK TILLER IS LYING. He was not struck. Also in the reflection you can see the violent severity of how Snyders body was used to push the door straight open. In the reflection you see Snyder, the very moment he leaves the cameras view, falling forward from Tillers push, tripod with camera and folders still being held.

Posted by: Yatti Location: Canada on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:53 PM
Way out of line!!!! Excessive force, beyond belief... All officers involved should be placed on temporary leave.. Without Pay!.. Pending investigation!.. Very, very sad... Who was the lady screaming stuff about her father etc? Seems like lots of people at that meeting need anger management. Out of curiosity was it her tape that WNDU used?? Sue her in court for the hell of it for encouraging the excessive force..

NewsCenter16 was covering the meeting because of the on going budget debate in Roseland. That's when the incident happened. All the footage placed online came from the WNDU camera present at the meeting. -WNDU.com


Posted by: Zack Location: clarksville on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:49 PM
Eller, obviously you didn't pay attention. You can see in the reflection of the window that Snyder is pushed into the door and onto the ground without "throwing an elbow" as Penn said. This is clear police brutality. The cop needs to lose his job, spend 2-5yrs in jail, and spend the rest of his life giving half of his money to David Snyder after a nice fat civil suit award.

Posted by: Rick Location: America on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:49 PM
Regardless of your opinion of Mr. Snyder, or the severity of whatever cuss word he spewed on the way out, the police are paid and trained to protect and serve. This cop over-reacted, which of course is only human, but he will lose his job for it... and he should. Sucks to be a cop sometimes. Get a less stressful job if you have anger management issues.

Posted by: Matt Location: New York on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:34 PM
Folks, this happens every day in the Police States of America. Wake up fellow citizens!

Posted by: WJoseph Location: Tampa, FL on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:33 PM
Anyone who doesn't view this as excessive force and clear cut Police Brutality doesn't deserve the freedom that our sons and daughters are in Iraq fighting for!! Sickening!! Fire that animal and try to restore whatever dignity your city has remaining after clearly advocating this sort of behaviour!

Posted by: Joe Location: California on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:29 PM
I don't know anything about David Snyder, or why people hate him, but from watching the video, the police officer was out of line. David Snyder may have made a remark of some sort to tick off the officer, but that doesn't give the officer the right to tackle and start beating on David Snyder. David Snyder was cooperative and was leaving the building and showed no resistance. Yes, he is making comments as he is leaving, but he is cooperating and leaving. The officer needs to be disciplined and fired. Wherever this Roseland town is, I'm glad I don't live in it as people there seem to support forceful and aggressive behaviors.

Posted by: Jon Location: Ft. Bragg North Carolina on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:09 PM
How could something like this be allowed to happen? That officer should be fired, if not charged with assult, and sued by Mr. Snyder. Upon close examination of the video you see Mr. Snyder turn around to reply to someones remark, then say something to the officer, then clearly the officer pushes him and Snyder goes headfirst into the glass door, which you can see all in the reflection of the opposing glass door! Then to say he was resisting arrest? I would too had an "officer of the law" did this to me, infact, I would have done more to defend myself, had I been armed! I will be glad to hear if any lawsuits are filed and if this officer is fired and forced to move towns and become a local mall rent-a-cop!

Posted by: Nik Location: Gladly not Roseland. on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:06 PM
Your town sickens me. The reaction by that fat woman in the yellow proves that the whole world, or at least this country, has gone to hell. No matter what he did aside from blatantly striking the officer warranted such reaction. The officer should be put in jail. If anything, I'd like to spit in his face. For shame. I hope your backwards, hick town learns from this video. Keep up with the rest of the world and quit being so barbaric.

Posted by: Dan Location: Corvallis on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:04 PM
The video of Ted Penn's reaction clearly shows a bias of how he feels about the victim, the man hit by he police officer. He clearly did not ever get a hit in on the police officer. It is plain on the video how slowly he moves. It is not a fast twist as Ted Penn claims. Just my 2 cents.

Posted by: Luke Location: Wisconsin on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:04 PM
I didn't see David resisting arrest at all. He was CLEARLY shoved through the door and then beaten while he was face down in the asphault. Officer Tiller should no longer have a badge, but sadly there are a lot of cops like Tiller who get away with things of this nature all the time. Why were the felony assault charges dropped? I don't know what the Synders did that was so horrible, this is purely and outsider's perspective, but no one deserves to be treated like that.

Posted by: j on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:03 PM
That cop should be fired and jailed. At least...

Posted by: Mark Location: Australia on Sep 19, 2007 at 10:01 PM
America land of the free? You guys are turning into the worst country in the world! And Gary I am sorry but the Police need to be above that, I don't care what he has done in the past. Just sick!

Posted by: Bill Location: Massachusetts on Sep 19, 2007 at 09:59 PM
Clearly Mr. Snyder knows the local ordinance as well as Roberts Rules of Order. The Chairman was out of Line and there was no reason to eject Mr. Snyder from the meeting. It is also clear that Mr. Snyder is NOT a favored local politician ... but too bad, he was elected and must serve the city to the best of his ability ... regardless of if the other councilors agree with him or not. That being said, it is obvious Mr. Snyder did nothing to provoke the attack by the police officer who clearly abused his power and authority. It is clear he also took a cheap shot at Mr. Snyder from the beginning. I hope that he is fired for his actions and I strongly encourage Mr. Snyder to pursue his grivances in court where he is sure to prevail! Good luck Mr. Snyder!!

Posted by: Bruce Location: Texas on Sep 19, 2007 at 09:57 PM
Police brutality has become policy it seems with as many of these horrendous illegal and uinconstitutional acts that are carried out on a daily basis across our nation. Pfft, and we are supposed to be role models for the rest of the world. How pathetic.

Posted by: Craig Location: VA on Sep 19, 2007 at 09:54 PM
Dropped the charges and dropped your rights. Lets hear it for small town Wal-mart America. 'The heartland'.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 19, 2007 at 09:48 PM
(YYYYAAAAWWWWWNNNNNN!) Has anything important happened yet? Sorry, I'm really BORED with all this mess. It all proves no point other than people wanting to argue and fight all the time. Sounds like its the old "Hatfields and McCoys" are at it again.

Posted by: Brad Location: Iowa on Sep 19, 2007 at 09:46 PM
Fire that cop! No more of this! NO MORE BRUTALITY!

Posted by: Gary Location: Eller on Sep 19, 2007 at 07:23 PM
The officer bullying David Snyder? Anyone that thinks that hasn't been paying attention to David Snyder. He clearly stops as he's being escorted out and has words with the officer. He then resists being put in handcuffs. This has nothing to do with policy and politics of Roseland, but an officer not taking anything from David and doing his job. If David had any respect for the police, he'd have just left without saying or doing anything -- and that he did not do.

Posted by: Alan Location: Kerrville, Texas on Sep 19, 2007 at 06:59 PM
Absolutely sickening, Police are constantly abusing people's rights!!!

Posted by: Dana Location: DFW Texas on Sep 19, 2007 at 05:57 PM
Snyder made a point of parlimentary proceedure and calmly packed his stuff when he was ejected for doing so. (He was given the floor, then the guy denied he gave it to him. Senile indeed.) If you watch the subsequent videos of his wife's reaction you'll hear whoever is behind the *news* camera make "waa waa waa" sounds to indicate she's beinga whiner. The guy in the last clip, Ted Penn, outright lies when he says Snyder struck the marshall. From the sounds of the first tape, some woman is saying stuff about "Now you know how my dad felt" and "Give him one for my dad". This cop lied on camera too when he said Snyder struck him, as the charges of battery on a peace officer were dropped after review of the reports. This is another example of the growing tyrannical police state in our nation and it needs to be stopped immediately. I'd like to know what issues this guy stands for, and why his neighbors have spray painted "Move Out" on his garage door?

Posted by: Jeremy Location: Tennessee on Sep 19, 2007 at 02:50 PM
No matter what could have been said by Mr. Snyder as we walked from the meeting, the officer's actions are without a doubt out of line. Not to mention, the officer had Snyder's back and was beating on him, that, in itself, is just pathetic. The so-called "officer" involved does not deserve the position he holds and should be barred from ever wearing a badge again.

Posted by: Penny Location: Ligonier on Sep 18, 2007 at 09:22 PM
Upon viewing the footage, it is pretty clear to me that the officer escorting Mr. Snyder out was out of line. No matter what Mr. Snyder might have said the Officer's type of action is not justifiable. It may be possible that the officer may have used this opportunity to release some built up frustration he had against Mr. Snyder. We all know, or have known, at least one police officer who feels they are "super tough" and "have the right" to use force even when excessive force is not necessary. I don't feel this was a situation that warranted the excessive force that was used. I was a small town meeting for crying out loud! Maybe Roseland should have the S.W.A.T. team on standby at their next meeting! Grow up Roseland. You aren't going to get your town anywhere when all you do is battle for power.

Posted by: Cathy Location: Stevensville Michigan on Sep 18, 2007 at 06:48 PM
Watching and listening to the replay.... David Snyder is right. He was given the floor WITH a time limit. He is the one who started baiting the others into an argument. He is the one who started the name calling. He forgets that fact and blames everyone else. This man needs this kind of interaction with others in order to feel superior. He is a manipulative person. He can dish it out but not take in return. He likes the media coverage. He likes being a martyr. I'm glad I don't live in Roseland and will be glad when David Snyder is up for re-election. The election outcome will be interesting. If he isnt re-elected it will be interesting watching how Roseland will be governed. Mr. Snyder, his wife and the treasurer all appear supisous and in cahoots.

Posted by: Jan Location: Tippecanoe on Sep 18, 2007 at 06:45 PM
IMO,The officer was within his rights with the way he delt with Snyder. The Snyders have done nothing to improve the town and have caused more trouble than the town deserves. It's a shame the town has to deal with these people.

Posted by: Kim M Location: Mishawaka, IN on Sep 18, 2007 at 04:56 PM
The state or fed. gov. should look into fining or firing public officals when they act like children instead of adults. Most people would have been fired for workplace fights.

Posted by: dolores Location: elkhart on Sep 18, 2007 at 08:57 AM
I think this is dispiteous. Any police officer that treats any one like this should be taken off the force!!!! This man didn't deserve this treatment!!

Posted by: dan Location: lagrange on Sep 18, 2007 at 08:23 AM
that cop should be fired and charges pressed. how does that "police officer" justify hitting a man in the head while laying on his stomach with his hands were full of camera equipment? If snyder were black we would be seeing this on the national news... maybe we will anyway

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Elkhart on Sep 18, 2007 at 05:58 AM
I think the snyders are for lack of a better term "crybabies". They are supposed to be adults and they always are the center of nearly incident that makes the news. They waste more time trying to get their way than trying to get roseland back on its feet. I think the actions of the 6.50 an hour cop were warranted. If I were asked to leave a meeting I certainly wouldnt continue to make the derogatory remarks that got me thrown out in the first place. I am tired of the snyders antics and think they are in need of a definite wakeup call.

Posted by: Jackie Location: SWMichigan on Sep 17, 2007 at 11:33 PM
The Snyders have destroyed Roseland for so long. I'm surprised they even show their faces in the town. The Snyders put the town in the mess it is in, and now try to blame it on the current council.

Posted by: Shirley Location: Bremen on Sep 17, 2007 at 09:03 PM
Although I don't like the things David Synder has done or approve of most of his actions when I viewed this video I didn't see him do anything to the officer. It appeared that his hands were full. I think the reason the officer reacted the way he did was because Mr. Snyder wouldn't quit talking. This is not a reason to do what the officer did. I do think he used unreasonable force.

Posted by: Brandon Location: South Bend on Sep 17, 2007 at 08:36 PM
The neighborhood sure has gone down hill..........

Posted by: Elkhart Teacher Location: Indiana on Sep 17, 2007 at 05:11 PM
That officer was out of line and should be fired! We teach our kids not to bully others so why should it be any different for adults..especially police officers who are supposed to uphold the law? The video clearly shows that Snyder had both hands full and was a victim in this case. That officer needs Anger Management classes!

Take Charge of your life.
WNDU News Poll
There are currently no active polls at this time.
Click here to view other polls on our site and past poll results.
Click here to find out about our current contests.