Medical mistakes in Michiana Save Email Print
Posted: 6:40 PM Aug 26, 2008
Last Updated: 9:03 AM Aug 27, 2008
Reporter: Alana Greenfogel
Email Address: Alana.Greenfogel@WNDU.com

A | A | A

Indiana hospitals are under the microscope as the state works to prevent medical mistakes.

The Indiana Health Department released a study of the Medical Error Reporting System. It outlines the 105 medical mistakes that took place in 2007.

"We can stop and say, ‘What are the best practices across the country? What do we need to do here in Indiana? What can we identify that we can standardize across the state to really help everybody?’" says Dr. Judy Monroe, Indiana Health Department.

Here’s a look at Michiana’s hospitals.

Memorial Hospital:
1 case of death of serious disability because of a medication mistake
1 case of an object left inside a patient during surgery

Elkhart General Hospital:
1 case of a surgery performed on the wrong body part
1 case of severe pressure ulcers, or commonly known as bed sores

Laporte Hospital and Health Services:
1 case of an object left inside a patient during surgery

Goshen Ambulatory Care Center:
1 case of surgery performed on the wrong body part

St. Joseph Regional Medical Center
1 case of an object left inside a patient during surgery
1 case of severe pressure ulcers, or commonly known as bed sores

"Sure there were two, and only two, but that's two too many. And we want to make sure that two becomes a zero and remains a zero forever and ever," says Mike Stack, St. Joseph Regional Medical Center.

The state reports 105 mistakes in 2007.

"But there's actually a lot more than 105 cases out there."

Peter Agostino is a medical malpractice attorney in South Bend. He says the number mistakes in hospitals and healthcare facilities would surprise you.

"A lot do involve miscommunication inside a hospital. Orders don't get passed along the way they should be. Or the nurses in the hospital sometimes don't know what the doctor wants. The doctor's not given information about patient needs and then things go bad from there," Agostino explains. "There's a pressure to move things along through surgery in hospitals so they can maximize the number of surgeries they do."

The Journal of American Medical Association reports 100,000 people a year die in the United States related to medical mistakes. That’s almost as many deaths as if the World Trade Center was attacked every week.

"I presumed the emergency room meant quick treatment so a patient doesn't die."

Betsey Betz’s father died at a local ER after, she says, a doctor made a mistake.

"The mistake was to not treat him promptly and to not treat his blood pressure,” Betz says. “If they had done this, as an emergency room should do, I don't think dad would have died, at least that night."

More Stories
More lake effect snow for northern Indiana

South Bend man to serve 30 years for robbing, beating elderly woman

St. Joseph still hoping to own iconic lighthouse

Police maintain tight security following threats

Man flips car, lands in front of house

Penn High School holds Kaleidoscope Concert

Two men arrested for attempted robbery

James Kapsa discusses his goals for South Bend School Corporation

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 30, 2008 at 09:06 AM
Hey Truth, that does not negate the fact that it happened and is not included as well as the numerous other occasions of neglect.

Posted by: Sarah Location: Michigan on Aug 29, 2008 at 09:33 PM
I would LOVE to see a report on the wonderful Lakeland facilities up this way.. they are a complete joke! When I went into premature labor with my daughter I was told because my water broke I had to deliver within 24 hrs.. I was rushed to Bronson who completely laughed at that ignorant diagnosis.. they kept me there for another week before we couldn't stop labor and delivered 2.5 months early. They also blew my vein with an IV that I told them was bad, and they patronized me over it.. then had to say.. oh I guess it isn't in right after my arm went completely numb from being filled with fluids! Quacks there! And don't forget the nice MRSA infection I got when I had my second daughter there. Then my sister had gullbladder surgery a few months later and got MRSA as well, they had the nerve to report that staff infections are not an issue there! Two out of two people I know that had surgery there got it! dirty, crazy people work there!

Posted by: Jo in the know Location: SB on Aug 28, 2008 at 03:26 PM
Hang on to your butts....I have heard a lot of health care providers at good ol' Memorial are going to be getting pink slips real soon.....the usual 3-4 year cycle

Posted by: Zee Location: Elkhart on Aug 28, 2008 at 01:08 PM
Nearly 2 years ago, my brother had surgery at the Elkhart Hospital, which left a huge, gaping hole in his skull, and orders not to apply any kind of dressing. He had two or three days of beautiful recovery in a rehab facility before he was rushed back to the hospital with a fever of 105. We are 100 percent certain that he contracted meningitis through that head wound (though the doctors would never admit it). To make a sad story sadder, he was released from the Critical Care unit after 59 days, 18 hours - just six hours short of the time Medicare would have had to restart his nursing home coverage - imagine that! He has been severely mentally disabled since, and always will be.

Posted by: Truth Location: South Bend on Aug 28, 2008 at 12:22 PM
Hey Brad . . .that stuff with the NRC and radiation treatment happened four years ago . . .the report is for 2007.

Posted by: Jen Location: Elkhart on Aug 28, 2008 at 12:17 PM
Posted by.....6:39 P.M. .... Personal family situations.....is that "fact" enough.....not just 1 or 2 either......good enough for you??????

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 28, 2008 at 11:42 AM
No need to fear for Memorial....there's budget cuts and layoffs coming!!!!!

Posted by: Brad Location: Niles on Aug 28, 2008 at 08:10 AM
I agree, the information they have here is by far incomplete. SJRMC had 5 people that received ulcerations due to being overexposed during Radiation treatment and were under investigation by the Nuclear Regulatory Committee as well as failing to report the incident in a timely manner.

Posted by: Chad Location: Northern Indiana on Aug 27, 2008 at 08:19 PM
These stats are wrong by a mile. I had an Aunt that use to go to Memorial for dialysis. The accidentally pumped air in her veins which gave her a stroke and paralyzed her from the neck down. The wonderful people at memorial said she would take a year and could possibly by a small chance be normal again. Small chance my foot they took that chance away when 30 days later she went to get the treatment again and they accidentally pumped air in her veins and Killed her. Quality of Life? maybe after life!! Don't go to Memorial they are money hungry, malpractice, idiots.

Posted by: .. on Aug 27, 2008 at 05:39 PM
Jen - I'm interested, how do you "know for a fact" that there are more incidents at Elkhart General then reported here? (I always find these kinds of comments interesting.)

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 05:16 PM
Wait a minute these are Indiana hospitals NOT Michigan hospitals.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:58 PM
You so need to look into memorial hospital and it's getting rid of nurses and educational staff. ER and Critical care areas are so short staffed. Administration is laying off nurses due to the cut in funding from the state. But management isn't being touched. How many life's need to suffer because of this? Nurses are and staff are very unhappy. experienced nurses are leaving. Pay is less then other hospital. Memorial is telling us they pay the same or more. Yes they pay higher for new grads. No when it comes to nurses with experience. More people will die at memorial will nurses having to take more patients when they are not staffed for that high. People have come into the er with c/o feeling anxious and sent home with benadryl and coming back 2 hours later in full arrest. When are you going to look into what's going on? Funny how memorial is building and at the same time getting rid of nurses. Does it take a death for you to care?

Posted by: Josh Location: Elkhart on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:44 PM
Most of the time I've spent in the ER, either for my family or myself, or for a fellow employee I've taken to the hospital- all too often the ER wait is too substantial. There have been times where there was only one or two others there, but we spent 3 or more hours there.

Posted by: Sarah on Aug 27, 2008 at 04:26 PM
a few years ago my daughter had a blood infection. Elkhart hospital sent her home with the advice to see the pediatrician first thing in the morning. The pediatrician sent her to Goshen hospital where she was admitted to ICU for 5 days !!! They said just a few more hours and she would have been dead. Another time my other daughter fell and hurt her arm, Elkhart took xrays and sent her home. 2 days later I took her back, they looked at her old xray and said oops it is broken. I wouldn't take my dog to Elkhart hospital.

Posted by: Mother of Child @ Memorial Location: Elkhart on Aug 27, 2008 at 03:59 PM
I noticed Memorial did not report any pressure ulcers. My son left there with a stage 4 as deep as the bone unrelated to his injury.....hmmmm makes ya wonder.

Posted by: Jen Location: Elkhart on Aug 27, 2008 at 01:29 PM
I know for a fact there's more at Elkhart General than reported here.....people are just too scared to go back to the hospital and confront them.....they think they won't win anyway because the place is so "big"......Their ER doctors are a bunch of quacks! They sent a guy home who had a slight stroke and his left arm was all numb....told him he slept on it wrong! DUH! It's a pitiful hospital!

Posted by: Leo Location: Granger on Aug 27, 2008 at 11:56 AM
My mother in law was taken to the hospital for a bad case of the flu several years ago. She was getting better and was to be released soon. They had her on so many medications I don't know how they kept track, then we got a call that she had a bad stomach infection and she died the next day. This was not relevant to what she was admitted for. We believe that she was over medicated and her stomach just could not take it. I know of way too many people that get staf infections in the hospital.

Posted by: confused Location: mi on Aug 27, 2008 at 11:21 AM
what does immigrants not paying hospital bills have anything to do with this story?? What about the american citizens who don't pay for their hospital bills?? Not that either of these are even relavant to what this story was talking about!!

Posted by: terry Location: mish on Aug 27, 2008 at 10:42 AM
thats is what happens when immigrants dont pay for hospital bills

Posted by: jlh59 on Aug 27, 2008 at 10:40 AM
What happened to accounting for all the pieces used? OMG have we lost all common sense! This is unacceptable!

Posted by: karen Location: south bend on Aug 27, 2008 at 10:12 AM
My dad died 20 years ago. He had a physical 4 days before surgery and the doctor detected an irregular heartbeat. He pulled thru surgery fine and died the next day from a heart problem.. If he would have been monitored after surgery, he might still be with us today, enjoying his family. The only way to deal with this is that he is with our Heavenly Father and in a better place.It was his time.

WNDU News Poll
There are currently no active polls at this time.
Click here to view other polls on our site and past poll results.