After 33 years in jail, Benton Harbor man wants to help community
After 33 years in jail, Benton Harbor man wants to help community Save Email Print
Posted: 6:00 PM Aug 26, 2008
Last Updated: 7:33 AM Aug 27, 2008
Reporter: Ryan Famuliner
Email Address: ryan.famuliner@wndu.com

A | A | A

A Benton Harbor man who has been in jail since the mid-1970's, for a crime he says he didn't commit, is now out on parole.

But 58-year-old Floyd Caldwell, who was 25 when his prison sentence started, says he isn't bitter; even though others say his sentence was one of the harshest they'd ever seen.

Caldwell received two consecutive life sentences for the knifepoint robbery of a retired judge and his wife back in 1975.

He says his attorney recommended he forgo a jury trial; so his conviction and sentence came directly from a judge.

The former judge and his wife, and the judge who sentenced Caldwell, have since passed on.

Even though Caldwell maintains his innocence, he says he's ready to move on, and now he's eager to make a difference.

For Caldwell, a nice hot lunch as a free man has a new feel to it, after 33 years in jail.

"We know that (the sentence) was quite excessive," Caldwell said Tuesday.

"You can look back and use it as a crutch to say, OK, I'm bitter because this happened to me. Or I'm bitter because the justice system did all of these things. It wasn't right. But what good would it serve?" Caldwell said.

Instead, he wants to work on the positive

"Why focus on myself, when I can stop someone else from going through what I went through?" Caldwell said.

Caldwell is certified in the culinary arts, and plans to take cooking classes at The Opportunity Center in Benton Harbor, that assists with re-introduction into society.

He wants to stay in Benton Harbor to mentor others, too.

"It wasn't my original choice (to stay). But it's my choice now, after I've seen what's happening, I wouldn't have gone any other place," Caldwell said.

What's happening is a lot of progress in Caldwell's eyes. He says he followed the events in Benton Harbor from jail, as it appeared to take a downturn over the course of his sentence. However, he feels it's now on the upswing, and wants to be a part of that movement.

The Opportunity Center says Caldwell will be a strong influence as a mentor, because the strength to move on and leave your past behind is a key attribute to pass on to former convicts.

"You can do all the right things, but you can't make someone want to change if they are not bothered by things that they do," said Virgil Hatcher, the mentoring coordinator for the Opportunity center. Hatcher was friends with Caldwell in prison; he was released in January of this year.

And for Caldwell, the anger and bitterness of a lifetime lost… is lost.

"Bitterness is something like when your negative energy is turned in on you. It's like a dog trying to chase its tail; you'll never catch it. I didn't have the inclination to be in that cycle," Caldwell said.

Caldwell says he also wants to work with a Berrien county circuit judge on a legal self-help program. He wants to work on judicial reform in the county.

He's been going around Benton Harbor since he got out earlier this August, and says he's excited about the future, and wants to be a part of the change for the better.

Caldwell's story of how he ended up in jail is that he got a ring from a friend, which he tried to get appraised at a local jeweler.

He says he didn't question where it came from… that greed "overwhelmed" his reason.

The ring was linked to the robbery, and ultimately he was arrested and convicted.

Caldwell has a wife, Cynthia, who lives in Muskegon. They were married while he was incarcerated.

WNDU originally contacted Floyd Caldwell for this story. He says he'd rather not have the media attention, but was willing to share his story.

More Stories
RedBud once again brings in big crowd to boost Buchanan economy

Three classic American rockers entertain Michiana at the Cove

North Liberty, LaPorte celebrate Fourth of July with parades

Hundreds gather in Niles for Independence Day TEA party

Mishawaka curfew in effect for teens

Michigan may cut subsidies that keep Amtrak running

Meijer recalls products linked to milk processor

'Stars of Tomorrow' take over RedBud Friday night

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: ashley Location: ms on Sep 4, 2008 at 10:54 PM
well this is my uncle and i dont like none of yall that are postin negative comments so if u have anything negative to say keep it to yourself... and jus stop hatin cause if u served that long in prison for nothin u would want tha same so jus BE QUIET... and i love u uncle... jus keep doin wat u r doin to make a difference...

Posted by: MM on Aug 31, 2008 at 10:00 AM
Mz V. I said if he's guilty he'll fit right in. um I'm sooo right. we all know how bad bh is.any 1 that thinks i'm lying- go to bh and see for yourself- day or nite.btw if you all support him get some $ 2 gether and file a lawsuit. he should get paid.are your kids with 1 person or different people?

Posted by: Karen Location: South Bend on Aug 27, 2008 at 07:41 PM
The man served his time and embraces a second chance. Leave him alone and let him live in peace before judging him.

Posted by: worker Location: indiana on Aug 27, 2008 at 06:09 PM
Criminals always say they didn't commit crimes. This should have been left out of this story. I wish this man well and think it is great if he wants to do something positive and not be bitter.

Posted by: cp Location: South Bend on Aug 27, 2008 at 02:39 PM
I hope this man does well - I wish him the best with his new life and his goals. Why do we have to "hang" someone with words when we don't even know the whole story? Brian-you are very quick to judge this man when you don't have all the facts.No one was EVER murdered by him, what do you mean "how long until he murders someone ELSE"? It was a knifepoint ROBBERY, not a murder!Give the guy a break, 33 years is a very long time for a robbery sentence. I think we need to heed to Deb of Dowagiac's posting. Obviously she knows more then we do. The man wants to make a good life for himself and also help others, I think that says a lot for him as a person if he was wrongly convicted. He probably had a PD for an attorney, they don't care if they win or lose a case, they're getting paid by the state either way. The more cases for them the more $$ they make. The man served his time, he deserves a second chance.

Posted by: Mz V Location: Benton Harbor on Aug 27, 2008 at 01:39 PM
Brian Lewis think before you type. Everyone that has been convicted is not guilty there's proof of that with DNA test that was not available in the past. Look at how many people were wrongly convicted until DNA test were done, but guess what 99% were african american men that were convicted of either rape (white woman) or murder (whites) our communities seem to think that if a black individual is accused of a crime against a white person then they are guilty no this is not always true. Brian your comprehension is not great where and when was he convicted of MURDER, this is the first that comes to your ming the worst crime that could be committed. MM what do you know about Benton Harbor I fit in here and I am not guilty of anything but replying to the stupidity of your comments. I have been here for over 40 years and have children and we live well with no problems. Walk in my shoes before you speak. I agree he's owed for those years spent in prison. We are here for him in BH

Posted by: Tim Location: Berrien County on Aug 27, 2008 at 01:12 PM
Not sure what you are saying Deb. I did google the name and it looks to me like a court case out of Mississippi where the black man gets the shaft while the whitties smile. (And I am white) This man deserves an appoligy from us not the slander we see here. I pray his attitude rubs off on some on this post and he is able to help A LOT of would be real criminals not to be.

Posted by: Deb Location: Dowagiac on Aug 27, 2008 at 11:57 AM
This case has been used by many, many law schools for educational purposes for many reasons, including any possible racial implications. If you are really interested, do some research and you will find that this case was not so cut and dry.

Posted by: Mary Perry Location: buchanan on Aug 27, 2008 at 11:25 AM
hope it all works out for you, always put GOD first.

Posted by: timmy on Aug 27, 2008 at 11:02 AM
Scary how that could slip through the cracks, how in 33 years nobody in the justice system took notice to this obvious injustice. A mass murderer sentence for an armed robbery.

Posted by: Scotty Providence Location: SBI on Aug 27, 2008 at 10:58 AM
I agree with Brian, this guy shouldn't be glorified for serving 33 years in prison. If he was innocent, why did his lawyer advise he skip a trial. That is what a trial is for to show you are innocent until proven guilty. Now he is treated like he is the mayor of Benton Harbor. He'll be back in in time.

Posted by: Brian Lewis Location: nappanee on Aug 27, 2008 at 10:51 AM
Wow "D". My comment should be deleted because it is an opinion that differs from yours? Your comment that actually is a threat toward me however should be on here. Hmmm that's cool. And Tim. Ok, guy says he didn't do it so the system is bad. Sure makes sense to me. We should ask everyone who is locked up if they did it or not? I guess if they say they didn't do it we should just let them out because they look like nice folks. He was legally sentenced and should not have been let out.

Posted by: Brian Lewis Location: nappanee on Aug 27, 2008 at 10:42 AM
He plead guilty. He was convicted. He was sentenced. If he was wrongly accused, arrested, represented, convicted or sentenced why did he not win an appeal before this. Also I know he did not murder anyone.... yet. My comment was how long before he murders someone else. Else as in another person. Sorry for the confusion.

Posted by: D Location: NAPPANEE on Aug 27, 2008 at 10:04 AM
EVEN IF HE DID DO IT, HE DIDN'T DESERVE THE SENTENCE HE RECEIVED. LOVE THE "HOLIER THAN THOU" COMMENTS FROM BRIAN. THOUGHT MAYBE HIS COMPUTER WAS BROKEN. HAVE A GREAT DAY BUD!!!

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 09:36 AM
Brian Lewis. ARe you serious?? Did you not read the story?? He didn't kill anyone. He was accused of robbing a Judge and his wife at knife. I beleive 33 years was way to harsh of a sentence

Posted by: D Location: So Bend on Aug 27, 2008 at 09:23 AM
Brian's comment should be deleted WNDU! Brain your comment was inappropiate. He didn't kill or rape anyone he was convicted of armed robbery. Child molesters get out on parole sooner! He has served his sentence & paid his debt to society. He is a free man now. He deserves a chance & he is giving back to his local community which is more than what I can say of you. Your quote "People like this should only come out of prison in a box" makes me wonder what we should do with you Mr Perfect.

Posted by: Travis Location: South Bend on Aug 27, 2008 at 08:58 AM
Wow, aren't we being a little harsh? There are actual murderers that get off with less time. This guy tries to pawn a ring and takes the brunt of a crime he probably had nothing to do with. If he's not bitter about it, we certainly shouldn't be.

Posted by: Tim Location: South Bend on Aug 27, 2008 at 08:40 AM
33 years later he says he didnt do it. 33 years is too long for ANY robbery. 2 consecutive life sentences for what ? I dont trust the system. Use this information to protect yourself from govt.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 27, 2008 at 08:18 AM
To Brian: The article does not state anywhere that he murdered anyone. The crime that happened was a robbery, no one died. Maybe he did it, maybe he didnt, but even if he did, he has served his time, and is now trying to better himself. There is nothing wrong with that.

Posted by: Karen Location: Winamac on Aug 27, 2008 at 08:07 AM
Brian Lewis, you are the one who scares me!

Posted by: guy Location: BH on Aug 27, 2008 at 07:24 AM
Brian, you are a idiot, he made a mistake and paid due time for what he did. There are people that do 10 times worse stuff and are out in 5 to 10. Floyd good luck!!!

Posted by: steve Location: warsaw on Aug 27, 2008 at 06:44 AM
Where the hell do you see the man was convicted of murder the story says robbery Brian ?? The man has done his time he is out !!!!!!!!!!!!!

Posted by: Big O on Aug 27, 2008 at 05:59 AM
whether the guy did it or not isn't the case here. the man served his time and his debt to society has been paid, now I am not defending him, but give the guy a chance, he may actually become a positive role model in this negative society.... please Mr. Caldwell don't let us down

Posted by: MM on Aug 27, 2008 at 01:34 AM
if he's innocent he should get paid.if he's guilty he should fit right in to bh.

Posted by: jro Location: south bend on Aug 27, 2008 at 12:45 AM
hey brian ,you do not know this man or anything about that crime, go pound sand ,I hope you do not ever break the law ,I will talk more smack about you than you can ever think about .

Posted by: MS Location: Indiana on Aug 27, 2008 at 12:21 AM
I wish him well in his "new life" and I hope the years ahead are good to him.

Posted by: Randy Location: Granger on Aug 26, 2008 at 10:59 PM
This person's defense attorney should be disbarred for the terrible advice that he gave....a judge instead of a jury involving the armed robbery of a JUDGE? You don't have to be Perry Mason to figure that one out.

Do not post multiple comments with different user names. Spamming the boards will get your other comments deleted and your IP address flagged which will slows down your approval process. Thank you. -WNDU.com


Posted by: Tye Location: Mishawaka on Aug 26, 2008 at 10:57 PM
Brian. I think you need to learn how to read a bit, he didn't murder anyone. granted armed robbery is a terrible crime but if you put down the crack pipe and read a little, you might be a more informed person.

Posted by: Brian Lewis Location: nappanee on Aug 26, 2008 at 10:03 PM
Why should he be bitter? He only served 33 years on 2 consecutive life sentences. I wonder how long until he murders someone else and goes back in. Shame on WNDU for glorifying this pathetic injustice. People like this should only come out of prison in a box.

Posted by: Bill Location: Elkhart on Aug 26, 2008 at 09:00 PM
God bless you!


WNDU News Poll
There are currently no active polls at this time.
Click here to view other polls on our site and past poll results.