Roseland Town Marshal killed in hit-and-run
Roseland Town Marshal killed in hit-and-run Save Email Print
South Bend
Posted: 8:13 PM Nov 1, 2008
 Last Updated: 1:11 AM Nov 2, 2008
156 comments
A | A | A

South Bend police say Roseland Town Marshal Craig Toner was killed in a hit-and-run accident Saturday afternoon in South Bend.

It happened around 4 p.m. at the intersection of Ironwood and Rockne.

Police say Toner was off-duty, and riding his motorcycle with his brother, northbound on Ironwood, when a driver heading southbound in an SUV crossed the centerline and struck Toner’s motorcycle. Toner landed on the vehicle’s hood.

The SUV’s driver -- Alexander Orta, 26, of South Bend – stopped his vehicle and Toner slid onto the ground. Orta got out of his SUV, surveyed the scene, and then got back into his vehicle. He subsequently ran over Toner and crashed a half mile from the initial impact.

Toner was pronounced dead at Memorial Hospital.

The St Joseph County Fatal Alcohol Crash Team (FACT) was dispatched to investigate the crash. They secured a forensic blood draw and results are pending.

Orta was arrested for two class C felonies – Operating While Intoxicated Causing Death, and Leaving the Scene of a Fatal Crash. Jail records show that Orta has been arrested 19 times since 2000.

Toner, who loved to ride, was recently promoted as Town Marshal for Roseland police after 3 years. Before that he served as a Captain for Mishawaka Police for almost 20 years.

Toner is survived by a son and daughter.

Friends and family gathered Saturday night to mourn the loss at Moondog’s on the south side of South Bend, the place that Toner liked to go and unwind.
“Craig’s the kind of guy who would go out of his way to help people,” said Mark Lewandowski, one of Toner’s friends. “When I was a rookie and he was a Captain, if he would see me struggling with something, he would just walk up and say hey, let me help you out, show you what to do.”

Many will simply remember him as an all around great guy. “A happy guy,” said Lewandowski.

Anyone who has any further information regarding the crash should contact Captain Tim Spencer, Mishawaka Police Department, at (574) 259-2966, or Sergeant Gene Eyster, South Bend Police Department, at (574) 235-9201.
More Stories
Take Charge Thursday - Health care assistance

Elkhart doctor pleads guilty on weapons charges

16 Curb Appeal finalists: The Magers family of Mishawaka

Police search for suspects wanted in 7-11 armed robbery

 Teen indicted for making bomb threats at Indiana schools

New Carlisle couple arrested for attempting to hire a hit man

Police search for suspect in South Bend bank robbery

Would Mishawaka take option tax cash?
Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Robert J that's what my friend called me. Location: South Bend, IN on Nov 7, 2008 at 10:11 AM
I started my law enforcement carrier a while ago. I have never met "Alex". My personal opinion is that, he made a bad choice. He then made another choice...TO KILL. I can't say "ALEX" is(nor is his family) bad. But I can say (on a blog) that this is %%EVIL%%. no death penalty just let him think. I Lost one of my best friends and my mentor.
Posted by: Sb Location: South Bend on Nov 6, 2008 at 07:56 PM
Lil Mex, Maybe President Obama can provide an education for you. It is obvious there is room for improvement in your grammar and thinking.
Posted by: ♥kendra♥ Location: south bend on Nov 6, 2008 at 02:28 PM
craig will you please hant the people that are sticking up for the ediot thanks craig.
Posted by: CA Location: South Bend on Nov 6, 2008 at 10:25 AM
To Jessica: Sounds like you picked a winner to be the father of your son. Now I feel more sorry that he has you for a mother! Good heavens --BLAMING THE BYSTANDERS FOR LETTING HIM GET BACK IN THE SUV??? ARE YOU KIDDING ME? What makes you think any bystanders could have stopped him? You haven't been able to curb his behavior, have you? You need some help --- you're a classic example of what an enabler is!
Posted by: bob Location: goshen on Nov 6, 2008 at 09:55 AM
it is amazing that some of you peaple do not think this scumbag should be punished he should be fried no questions asked and anyone that condones his actions are part of the problem that sb is having now. and to say he is not responsible for his actions are as irresponsible as he is
Posted by: Jack Location: South Bend on Nov 5, 2008 at 05:42 PM
To Lil Mex: Do you really think Orta, or you for that matter, are the type of people President Obama would defend? I would venture to say no. Perhaps the only "currupt" person in this tragedy is Mr. Orta. (By-the-way "currupt" is actually spelled corrupt.) It is absolutely appalling to blame the witnesses for not stopping your buddy. Do you also blame the bar for serving the alcohol, the dealer for giving a "good guy" the coke, and the car dealership for selling the car that was used when Orta chose to run over this good citizen? At what point is it the perp's fault? People can still support Orta without supporting his heinous act. The sooner people start taking responsibility for their actions, and stop blaming everybody and everything else, the better society will be. God's blessings on both families.
Posted by: N on Nov 5, 2008 at 12:30 PM
Lil_mex is quite possibly the most retarded person I have ever come across on the internet. Ever. I think its so nice that WNDU allows him to post when he obviously has a mental condition that he needs checked.
Posted by: Ralph Location: Granger on Nov 5, 2008 at 06:36 AM
Hopefully, this scum Orta will spend the rest of his life behind bars. This guy is a Punk.
Posted by: anonymous Location: south bend on Nov 4, 2008 at 06:57 PM
i have known alex for almost five years. there is no excuse for what he did and he does deserve the death penalty his 8 year old is better off without him. it's like he never had a father to begin with he has always been in and out of jail. if you ask me, he is not being charged with nearly enough. coked up or not, he should have made better decisions, not only that night but throughout his life. he deserves the death penalty. his entire family has always told him to straighten out his life for the sake of his child and he never did. at least he has a good mother. if this is what it takes to get him to realize that his entire life has been a waste then so be it. i am a friend but i do not defend anything he has done or any of the decisions he has made. to get out of the vehicle and look at the man and then procede to run him over was cold hearted. and you cannot use the race card, i'm latino too but God gave me a heart!
Posted by: Annoymous on Nov 4, 2008 at 01:58 PM
I have known Alex for over a year now. I never was able to figure out why he made the descions he made. He chose to be friends with the wrong people even worse half of them are family. I am disappointed in Alex I have always told him, keep choosing the path your on you will end up dead or in jail. Guess I can say I told you so. I never knew it would come down to him taking a life. I will tell you this everyone makes mistakes and bad decisions. Alex came from a loving immediate family with whom I have the utmost respect for, this is Alex's problem so leave his family out of it. They have the right to support him in anything they choose. Alex is amazing with kids polite in public, and giving to his family friends. He wanted to change become a better person in society, honestly people,he did, he just couldn't handle the slow boring life of responsibilities and hard times. Now he is going to learn what hard time is. Alex did not kill Officer Craig on purpose! He was scared!
Posted by: IUSB STUDENT on Nov 4, 2008 at 11:03 AM
To the Friends and Familiy of Orta--Print these comments and let him read them in jail. To the judge and Prosecutor who failed to the job of locking this guy up--I wish it were that got hit an run into the ground. This is why we need elected judges. You are all losers and make me sick.
Posted by: mike on Nov 4, 2008 at 10:16 AM
Here we go with the racist bit again. We don't feel sorry for this poor "misguided soul" so were all racist. I guess that means ortas is also a racist for picking someone other than his own race to murder. I guess that's the only way his "friends" can defend him. I'm guessing it's the cops fault because he's white. Why didn't ortas family & "friends" do something to straighten this idiot out before it came to this.
Posted by: Oh, get out the crying towel on Nov 4, 2008 at 09:41 AM
To Reina at 6:13PM. You can reccomend a good professor? Do you mean a shrink? Just goes to show the very, very, very low mentality sticking up for this animal.
Posted by: Hey, Jessica @8:42 on Nov 4, 2008 at 09:32 AM
Maybe if you knew the english language and knew how to spell, people would take you a bit more seriously. Till then, take it elsewhere.
Posted by: Oh yeah! on Nov 4, 2008 at 08:44 AM
Here we go again w/people defending the POS. Leaving an 8 yr old behind? Please...they have visits in jail, the Toner family doesn't have that luxury now do they? Stop defending your dirtbag friend..your all just as bad as he is.
Posted by: Steve Location: South Bend on Nov 4, 2008 at 08:16 AM
William, why is murder pushing it? He got out of the car, knew Mr. Toner was down in front of his vehicle, yet got in and drove over him killing him....There is intent there.
Posted by: Brian Location: Springfield, Ohio on Nov 4, 2008 at 07:58 AM
Nice to see people defending scum like this. The initial impact didn't kill him. The scumbag RAN HIM OVER while trying to escape. I don't care what color he was. He deserves death.
Posted by: sportymom89 on Nov 4, 2008 at 07:03 AM
he was not drunk he was all coked out what a total waste. he is now up for murder charges and hopefully death penalty. t-bird nice friends you have here.
Posted by: Don Location: indiana on Nov 4, 2008 at 02:12 AM
To the posters that are saying no to murder. Well Toner was injured after the first impact, he was killed on the second. The first might have been a "mistake" if that is what you want to call it. The second impact was intentional and the vehicle was the weapon. that makes it murder. If you dont like all the shootings then quit defending the thugs, it seems like the same crowd says lock up everybody but then this happens and you jump on the side of the suspect. Pick a side then stay on it.
Posted by: jay Location: MI on Nov 4, 2008 at 01:22 AM
It does not matter to me that the victim was a police officer or that the suspect is hispanic. What matters is that Mr. Orta chose to drive intoxicated and hit a PERSON. He then looked over the scene, got back into his car and drove over this man. That is what killed Craig Toner. What kind of "person" would do that? I hope that Mr. Orta receives a life sentence for the Murder, so I do not have to worry about him hurting anyone else. And yes, I feel bad for both families. I could not imagine if my "bum" relative killed someone so ruthlessly. I would be appalled and embarressed, and certainly would not know what to say to the victim's family. How can you explain his actions? I wish strength and comfort to everyone involved in this tragic incident. Mr. Orta, please stay in jail where you cannot hurt anyone else.
Posted by: Anonymous on Nov 4, 2008 at 01:12 AM
Reina Shut up. A scumbag is a scumbag. Not racist. Orta's family should be glad he's in jail. I know I am.
Posted by: Boomer Location: Mishawaka Police Dept. on Nov 4, 2008 at 01:09 AM
Hey Joey (Al's cousin)..Al is a piece of s#*t. According to you when he's sober he's a funny guy huh? Well when he's not sober he's a "MURDERER." At least you can go visit him for a chuckle....don't forget to tell him the one about the Q-ball. I'll see you in court during sentencing when they haul his sorry A#& to prison....
Posted by: Mick Slater Location: Elkhart on Nov 4, 2008 at 12:17 AM
This memorial page will remain in Craig's honor for as long as visitors post comments. http://craigtoner.blogspot.com/
Posted by: Mick Slater Location: Elkhart on Nov 3, 2008 at 11:20 PM
I met Craig one night in November 2007 when he was working security at St Hedwig's. I struck up a conversation with him and ID'd myself as being a former Deputy Marshal. Craig's face broke into a smile and he patted me on my back, shook my hand and said, "Let's go inside where it's warm and get a cup of coffee." I spent a wonderful 30 minutes chatting with Craig and felt once again that instant bond that exists between LEOs. Craig treated me like a long-lost friend and even though I had never before met him, he made me feel as if he had known me all his life. We talked about past experiences, motorcycles, and life in general. At the end of those 30 minutes I felt as though I had known Craig all my life, too. He was an honest, genuinely good person who had a left a wonderful impression on me. As he returned to his duty, I told him that if he were to have any problems outside to yell, and I'd have his back. And I meant it, and he knew I meant it. God bless you, Craig. I salute you.
Posted by: William Costigon Location: renee on Nov 3, 2008 at 10:54 PM
Wow!! That was a quick investigation!!! A few people start posting comments on saturday; by Monday we have murder charges? I think Murder is stressing it a little. They might get vehicular homicide, but murder.
Posted by: T Location: South Bend on Nov 3, 2008 at 07:29 PM
Update, the scumbag's been charged with murder. Thank you Dvorak.
Posted by: Anonymous on Nov 3, 2008 at 07:14 PM
Interesting that all of those people defending Orta can not even spell simple words or write a simple sentence. Their comments just demonstrate how those people that are continuously exposed to alcohol and drug abuse and frequent run-ins with the law just don't think it is a big deal...just a "mistake". They also assume that since that is THEIR normal lifestyle, everyone does it. These types of lifestyles have contributed to the deterioration of society's values all around. It wasn't a drunk, "rich", ND Alumni driving and it wasn't a drunk law enforcement officer. It was your friend and relative and he should be responsible for his actions. Quit making excuses. I live far above your inferior standards and values and am proud of it. It's one thing to ruin your own life, but when your abuse problems take away the life of an innocent victim, you deserve to be punished as the CRIMINAL you are.
Posted by: john mcpalin Location: oc on Nov 3, 2008 at 06:30 PM
ok...now the news reports that officer toner was talking after the accident, thats when orta got back into the suv and ran him over. oh yeah, he's being charged with murder now too, such a fine and upstanding citizen huh? short rope and a long tree...and all you losers sticking up for him may join if you want.
Posted by: Reina Location: South Bend on Nov 3, 2008 at 06:13 PM
This goes for everyone who is posting racist comments. Who are you to judge others. Instead of leaving racist comments people should put comments to support both families. Not just the family of Craig Toner is suffering, but also the Orta family. For all you racist people you should consider taking a race and ethnicity course to become better people. I can recommend a good professor.
Posted by: anon Location: s.b on Nov 3, 2008 at 05:01 PM
To "Listen to this"! O.k. This Orta creep sounds like a real nice guy. Arrested 19 times since 2000? I guess he's just "misunderstood".
Posted by: Concerned Citizen Location: Mishawaka on Nov 3, 2008 at 04:43 PM
I have been a dispatcher for the past 15 years and had the pleasure of working with Craig. He was caring, considerate and very street smart. I will miss his boyish grin and smirk he would get on his face. I feel he is up in heaven at this moment along with Bryan, Tom and Tim looking down on us and laughing. His sense of humor along with his caring nature is what made him Craig. I will miss you and know you will be taking care of all of us. My prayers go out to your family, friends and fellow officers. Take care
Posted by: Gus Location: South Bend on Nov 3, 2008 at 04:11 PM
To: Listen to this! What do you mean, live like us? Do you mean - DRUNK? That's your problem. Get over it! Am I afraid to live DRUNK? You better believe it.
Posted by: Lil_Mex Location: South Bend's West_Side on Nov 3, 2008 at 04:03 PM
Get over it the damage is done. OMG gage me w/ all ur bullshytt. Your just mad cause its a cop all of them are currupted anyway thats why they get away w/ everything. Obama needs to do something about all u foolish white folks who are always raggin on us colored people. For Crist Sakes the officer wasnt even wearing a helmet that could of prevented him from dieing did you ever think of that, he sealed his own fate by not wearing it. He is going to pay for his mistake he made. For the other charges the other 19 he already served his time for it so shut the hell up idiot. REMEMBER ALL YOU WHITE FOLKS ALCOHOL IMPAIRS A PERSONS STATE OF MIND. ALOT OF PEOPLE DRINK DURING HOME GAMES. SO WHY ISNT IT ILLIGAL TO GO TO A BAR AND GET WASTED AND THAN BE ABLE TO GET BACK IN YOUR CAR AND DRIVE. ALOT OF PEOPLE ARE AT FAULT. SO WHY DIDNT ANYONE OF THE BYSTANDERS TRY AND STOP HIM FROM GETTING BACK INTO THE CAR. SO IT'S THERE FAULTS TOO THEY COULD HAVE PREVENTED SOME OF THAT TOO. SO JUST GO SUCK A FAT 1
Posted by: Chris Location: Argos on Nov 3, 2008 at 03:55 PM
Not even death is a good enough punishment in this case. Yes everyone makes mistakes but this is way to extreme of a case to say he deserves "another chance" He drove drunk and had an accident, That alone may be understandable although a bad choice. But then to not check on the person you hit, who could of still been alive at that point, and then run them over? That is just mind boggling and sick. I would say at that point "the accident" becomes murder. I hope he gets everything he deserves. His race does not matter nor does his record i would feel the same about anyone who did this crime, you want to call people racist? you need your head checked. and then even worse you say that god wanted it to be this way? What? are you kidding me, i can't stand that argument. Your god must be one twisted freak to want someone to have to die that way.
Posted by: amazed Location: sb on Nov 3, 2008 at 02:40 PM
How can anyone defend a guy who drove drunk, hit a civilian then fled..im not judging Mr. Orta but whatever Mr. Orta gets he deserves..God Bless to both families
Posted by: Renee on Nov 3, 2008 at 02:35 PM
William C - Why did Orta Drive drunk? (He had a choice) Why did he drove over the Officer after he hit him with his SUV? (Again - he had a choice) Then he tries to leave the scene (Again - he had a choice). Orta only deserves death- the same as he gave Officer Toner It's a tragedy for all.....
Posted by: marijayne Location: SB on Nov 3, 2008 at 02:06 PM
Hey "Lil-Mex" First off- your thug buddy Orta hit this Officer during day light hours, he should have seen and heard the Officer who landed on his SUV for christ sake. Orta gets out of his vehicle obviously something effected his brain cells cause then the thug gets back in his vehicle and runs the Officer over, which probably killed the Officer. Bottom line - Once a Thug Always a Thug! Judges give him the death penalty!
Posted by: Defenders of Orta Location: SB on Nov 3, 2008 at 02:04 PM
HE GOT OUT OF THE CAR...LOOKED AT THE VICTIM...GOT BACK IN AND DROVE OVER HIM..DRAGGING HIM 15 FEET...THAT IS NOT AN ACCIDENT, IT IS MURDER!!!!
Posted by: Gus Location: South Bend on Nov 3, 2008 at 01:24 PM
SB - That must stand for $h!! for brains. This guy DROVE OVER an already injured person and all you can say is, "Stuff happens." Then, you try and blame other people for not stopping him. I'm sure that the guy didn't stand around for a half hour before he jumped back in his vehicle and ran over Craig Toner (may he rest with God). To Racist: It sounds to me like your friend Alex played God and chose Craig Toners fate. To William: There weren't 80,000 drunk drivers at the game, tailgating. It wasn't some rich ND alum that hit Craig Toner and if it was, it wouln't make a difference. Don't try to make excuses for Orta by naming others who have been caught driving intoxicated. Besides, they didn't kill anyone.
Posted by: Bob Location: SB on Nov 3, 2008 at 01:22 PM
Sick scum like this do not even deserve a trial. Tie the guy to the railroad tracks.
Posted by: Brian Location: South Bend on Nov 3, 2008 at 01:03 PM
To William Costigon...You are correct, that could have been any of a number of other people that hit Craig Toner. The difference is, this idiot got out, looked at the carnage and decided to drive away, in the process killing Toner. This ceased being a drunk driving ACCIDENT when Orta MADE THE CHOICE to run over Toner. This was much more than a mistake..if you can't see that, then you are an idiot too.
Posted by: DFLT Location: E.I on Nov 3, 2008 at 01:01 PM
The posting by "Racist People Make me sick" had ONE valid point... " He just made bad choices." And when one makes bad choices they pay the consequences. I don't see where people are getting that this is any sort of "race issue." The facts are that one human being made several bad choices and as a result another human being is dead. The results are horrible for everyone involved. May God help bring some measure of peace to both families in this time.
Posted by: Terri Location: Michigan on Nov 3, 2008 at 12:27 PM
It amazes me that our justice system allows this sick individual to be arrested 19 times(that alone should be a red flag)and did nothing knowing he would end up killing someone else or himself. Since he killed a police officer and left the scene he will be put in prison where he belongs; hopefully? It always takes something this tragic to open people's eyes; WHY!! God bless all involved, and my condolences to the Toner family.
Posted by: this is for sjc on Nov 3, 2008 at 12:25 PM
What is that supposed to mean that if he gets out he wont stand a chance out on the streets. Is that a threat?? See its people like you who dont have a heart. People make mistakes and I personally known him for a long time. I give my simpathy for The Orta Family especially his Son who is only 8 yrs old. and has to understand why all of you people talking bad like this about his Father. People make mistakes and on 11/1 Alex make a mistake and I know for a fact that he was not in his right state of mind and he wouldnt have ran over the officer. Why was'nt he wearing a Helmet huh?? Did anyone even check to see if Mr. Toner had been drinkin?? Mr. Toner was an officer and know's the Law so why was'nt he protecting him self. Think about that. I heard Toner was a dirty officer anyway. He looked like he was an A-Hole!!
Posted by: friend Location: ??? on Nov 3, 2008 at 12:10 PM
i dont want to get caught up in this fueding, but I am sick and tired of people saying, "it could have been anyone drunk driving". At the end of the day it wasnt anyone, it was this guy Orta. Stop with the what if's or what could of's. Because none of those things happened. we have to deal with what did. A great man that loved to do nothing but help people was taken away from us by the irresponsible, and i'm sorry but unforgiveable, actions of a person who has spent about a third of his life making the wrong decision which has landed him in jail 19 times. And to say people are being racist? It has nothing to do with Orta being hispanic. When I was told what had happened by friends, no one said that a hispanic man had done anything, all that was said is that our friend was hurt by a drunk driver. There was no race card being pulled. So please stop making your own opinions and just pay attention to the facts. Craig, we'll miss you forever, and see you later.
Posted by: William Costigon Location: G.I on Nov 3, 2008 at 10:42 AM
Maybe it's time for Indiana to make helmets mandatory for motorcycle riders. Aside from Mr. Toner I know 4 others who died on a bike with no helmet. Race is not the issue here at all!! Have any of you ever been drinking and driving hit someone, and kill them? I doubt it!!! He is 26 years old which in this day, and age is really 16!! Put yourself in his shoes!! He is sober now, and knows the rest of his life is probably over!! For the jail deputy you should think before you speak moron!!! Your comments show and prove why people can't stand police officers!! When I was a kid cops use to know all the kids in the neighborhood by name, and they gave a sh** about us and the community. Now you have all these guys on HGH patrolling the streets with horrible attitudes against everyone not in their uniform!! Cops are very cocky, and use their badge as a way of breaking the law!!! Whatever jail you work at should fire your a**!!
Posted by: William Costigon Location: G.I. on Nov 3, 2008 at 10:07 AM
Hey Pam that could have been anyone drunk driving, it just happened to be someone with a record!! There were 80,000 people tailgating, and drinking like Alex was. It could have been some rich N.D alum that hit him, then we wouldn't be discussing this!! I have four children, and I hate drunk drivers but don't attack someones previous record for a terrible mistake they just made!! We have all saw, and read the news before when Debra Daniel was drunk driving, and hit, and run. Or how about when SBPD captain hit a tree on Ewing St Drunk Driving. All I am saying is he is not the first person driving intoxicated! The kid is 26 years old do you think when he left tailgaiting he thought he was going to kill someone?!! I doubt it. What do you mean he knew how to work the system? 19 arrests since 2000!! Apparently the system doesn't work!! Maybe Notre Dame should ban alcohol from tailgating. I feel sorry for both family's who will never be the same again.
Posted by: Racist People Make Me Sick Location: Lil_Mex on Nov 3, 2008 at 09:28 AM
Vote Obama and than it will be a better place. Show all these Racist people make me sick. Who are all of you to Play God and Try and Choose the Fate of Another. This happened for a reason thats the way God wanted it. Alexander wasnt a bad person He just made bad choices. Think about the other Family that is involved not just the Toner Family. He is not an Illigal you Morons go find something to do and Choke on something.
Posted by: Jessica Location: South Bend on Nov 3, 2008 at 09:21 AM
You people have alot of nerve talking all this crap. Yes Alex was'nt the best person but who is. My son who Loves his father and doesnt understand any of this does'nt think anything bad about him, Why?? He is just an 8 yr old boy thats why. I've known Alex since Pre-school. He has a good Brain but does'nt use it for the right rasons. Sad to say. I feel for the Toner Family as well,as well as our families. All of our families were born and raised in the states,so for all of you talking this Mess Choke on It. God does'nt like Ugly so all you people who say bad things and want bad things to happen are the ones who go to hell. Alex was not in the right state of mind when this happened. It could have happened to anyone. I know for a fact that if he knew Toner was in the front of the SUV he wouldnt have ran him over. Our society is so messed up. How come no one try'd to stop him from going back in the SUV?? O and now everyone is sad?? Be mad at the bystanders too for just standing nd watching
Posted by: I AM Location: Everywhere on Nov 3, 2008 at 09:14 AM
May you rest in our Fathers house forever. I see Snyders HAD to get on here. To bad Craig is gone and they are still here. Sad.
Posted by: michelle Location: south bend on Nov 3, 2008 at 09:10 AM
NO! ALEX HAS NEVER HIT AND KILLED ANY ONE BEFORE!!!!!
Posted by: Listen To This!! Location: Lil_Mex on Nov 3, 2008 at 08:56 AM
OMG..You people need to get it right. What about Police officers who drink and drive?? What do you have to say about that huh. No one is perfect the world isnt perfect. Just let something like this happen to one of your family members who were to drink and drive and accidently kill someone see what you say than. You people are no better than anyone else so take the stick out of your behind. Mr. Orta is not a scum he just made a wrong choice. Alcohol can distort a person's mind Think About That. If it was any other person in Mr. Toner's place would you be saying all this negitive stuff. Mr. Toner probally was a good guy, I would'nt know but just because he has a badge on does'nt mean a thing. I am so sick of you people just because you think your better than everyone else. Come live the lives we live, but no your too scared and yeah "So are We"!! You think we like to live like this. "No We Do'nt" We are all Different that's the way God Made Us. One day I hope for a better place.
Posted by: Jessica Location: South Bend on Nov 3, 2008 at 08:42 AM
God lets things happen for a reason. I Alex know what he did was wrong. If it was the other way around no one would be saying stuff like this. If his alchol level was that high how could he know what was going on. Alcohol makes some people loose there state of mind. I know this person well and I know if he had new that the officer was infront of the car he would'nt have ran him over. All people want to do is make the person bad. We are all human. God does not like ugly. We wonder why are world will never be a good one. People make mistakes thats a part of life and I know that does'nt condon what he did. I know he is just as sorry and wish'es he can take back that day but the damage is done. Mr. Orta also left behind a son who is 8 yrs. old. Who is so torn by this. Who does not understand how to understand this situation. I give my condolences to the Toner Family. I dont know what else to say that can make things better, but I know I can't. We need to try to make this better for everyon.
Posted by: Pam Location: South Bend on Nov 3, 2008 at 08:36 AM
To Al's cousin, post 11-2 Are you stupid too, it must run in the family, you stated your cousin Al needs one more chance, what 19 isn't enough. He killed before, he had a second chance and obviously is too stupid to go straight. He knew how to work the system, and our worthless appointed Judges in St. Joe county let him go every time. Until the people of this county and Lake county wake up and get these overpaid idiots out of our court system, this will continue to happen. The police can arrest them and the prosecutor press charges, it is the Judge's that let them go with a slap on the wrist and a stern warning not to do it again. Big deal !! this is the results we get.
Posted by: Anonymous on Nov 3, 2008 at 06:29 AM
WNDU do you read what you post here? Read Cindy and Don's post--clean up the language. Or were you people drunk on the job too?
Posted by: T Location: South Bend on Nov 3, 2008 at 04:16 AM
Illegals out in force defending this selfish killer's name. Incredible.
Posted by: Dispatcher Location: South Bend on Nov 3, 2008 at 02:08 AM
Thank you Craig for all the excellent police work you did in your lifetime. It was a privilege to have known and worked with you. I pray that your suffering was short and that God will bring comfort to all who are grieving your passing. It was always a pleasure to assist you. Even your voice had a smile. You are greatly missed and sadly mourned by all that knew you. I am still having trouble understanding how any human being can run another over in the street like an animal after getting out and looking into their face. What kind of a man does such a thing? Please God bring justice to this horribly wrong situation. For those that are taking the comments personally, let them understand that anger is part of the grieving process, and the grieved have a right to express themselves. Only God knows if this was murder or an accident and may he bring swift justice. God Bless you, Craig. May we meet again in Heaven, for that is surely where you are. You will never be forgotten.
Posted by: To Vicki @ 10:58 on Nov 3, 2008 at 01:58 AM
That is one of the most beautiful things I have ever read and a true tribute to a man I was not lucky enough to know...it brought tears to my eyes. Thank you. My thoughts go out to the Marshal's family. RIP.
Posted by: easy math on Nov 3, 2008 at 01:11 AM
Your elected officials can only enforce the laws on the books. To change the laws, YOU have to write your representatives. You won't because you love your violence too much.
Posted by: Anonymous Location: South Bend, Indiana on Nov 3, 2008 at 12:08 AM
God Speed Toner... You will be greatly missed by all..
Posted by: sjc on Nov 3, 2008 at 12:07 AM
Craig was an exceptional man and police officer. Not one time did I ever hear anything negative come out of his mouth. What disgusts me is the brutality of this crime, and the fact that a 'friend' of Orta's is on here defending him. I can guarantee any LEO on here can verify fact that Orta has a record a mile long. And NOT for 'minor things', as 'Alex's Friend' stated on 11-2-08 at 3:59 pm. Of course, it would depend on what one would consider 'minor', I guess. If he felt bad, had morals, or had been rehabilitated for his past mistakes, as 'Friend' states, he would've gotten out of the SUV and made an attempt to help Craig instead of making things worse. I'll bet Orta is hoping he stays locked up for a long time. He stands no chance on the streets now. ~Rest In Peace Craig~
Posted by: Anonymous Location: Elkhart on Nov 2, 2008 at 11:43 PM
Wow listen to yourselves people. Do any of you believe that either of these men set out that day with the intentions of starting a racewar? None of you could possible know the fear going through both of these mens minds right before impact. None of you has the right to judge either of these men or their families. As far as Orta's arrest record it clearly shows that 19 arrests and no convictions means that the police and prosecuters are doing a horrible job and that the judges are doing theirs.
Posted by: amanda Location: south bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 11:38 PM
I agree with mike, this "friend" calls people by racist names and wonders why people think things about each other. I am not looking at his skin, I am looking at the FACT that he has been arrested 19 times, once for a fatal crash. If he has a problem with his drinking, he should stop. Apperently, he wasn't taught or didn't listen when his parents or teachers talked to him about drunk driving when he was in school. It is time our elected officials start doing their jobs and get these people in jail where they should be. If that was the case Mr. Orta would not have done this.
Posted by: Vicki Location: Osceola on Nov 2, 2008 at 10:58 PM
On Saturday afternoon I was taking my grandaughter to do some shopping and I think we saw Officer Toner on his Harley when we were driving down McKinley(20) about an hour and a half or so before he was hit. As we pulled up to a light my grandaughter pointed and said to me gramma, thats a Harley and my daddy has a Harley. I said to her,thats right honey he does. At that moment the man looked over to my grandaughter and gave her the biggest smile and wave to her delight! I continued on when the light changed and we lost sight of him. We did our shopping and were on our way to the fire station my son is at so she could see her daddy and on ironwood we had to go around where this happened, I knew when I saw the bike that it was the one that was carrying the man that so kindly took the time to give a little girl a big smile and wave.May God Bless this man and his family, he had such a kind face and smile.I think in death he still protected others from the same fate.
Posted by: Friends of Craig Toner Location: Roseland on Nov 2, 2008 at 10:42 PM
Please WNDU stop posting all of this nonsense. This is supposed to be about Craig Toner and the pain his family and friends are enduring now, please don't add salt to the wounds. Maybe you could put up another storyline for people to talk about this Orta guy. We need to be honoring Craig right now, after all he certainly deserves it after all he has endured in his tenure at the Roseland Police Department. Thank you.
Posted by: Jonathan Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 10:15 PM
It really saddens me that race and ethnicity has anything to do with this. Two families are affected by a TRAGEDY! Tragedies happen and are irrespective of race, gender, ethnicity, social status. Please, let's not degrade the memory and accomplishments of Officer Toner by attacking Mr. Orta. Mr. Orta made a mistake and unfortunately Officer Toner lost his life. The pain of the tragedy cuts both ways. Both families face losses.
Posted by: Timothy E. McConnell Location: Elkhart on Nov 2, 2008 at 09:55 PM
As a fellow officer, and fellow motorcycle rider, I'm sure he will be missed. My deepest condolences to the family and friends. Keep the faith......
Posted by: JULIE Location: mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 09:44 PM
not all mexicans are illegal aliens and the man could speak english and what he did is not excusable but the things you people are saying are wrong and you all need to greave and quit judging and just help support the family moning in a loss. my heart goes out to the families. and sorry that people are saying stupid thing and i understand everyone is angery but this is not helping anyone only making people madder
Posted by: Stan Location: Zebell on Nov 2, 2008 at 09:39 PM
Arrested 19 times in 8 years and only 26. Surveyed the scene and promptly ran over the officer to assure his death. This guy needs his life revoked...And anyone wishing to defend this scum needs to seriously consider Madison Center's mental health clinic for further evaluation.
Posted by: Recollection?? Location: Searching the archives on Nov 2, 2008 at 09:19 PM
Wasn't Alexander Orta involved in a hit and run fatality a few years ago??
Posted by: Honk Honk Location: The curb by your house, waiting on your sister.. on Nov 2, 2008 at 09:16 PM
It never ceases to amaze me that people condone the behavior of people like Alex Orta and then those people turn around and dare to ask WHY or act all suprised when something happens. Aw gee, I know he drinks and drives but I didn't think he'd kill anyone.. Again.. I've met Alex Orta and quite honestly, it shocks and amazes me that people can stand to be around him and claim him as a friend. The Alex Orta that I know has a substance abuse problem and he's a little A-Hole even when he is sober. Alex is a waste of space and it's a shame that a guy like Craig Toner had to die at the hands of a man who has never been, and never will be good enough to tread the same footpath.
Posted by: Retired Officer on Nov 2, 2008 at 09:06 PM
MY prayers and condolenses to Craig's family and children. He was a great person and officer as I had the opportunity to work with him. Craig you will be greatly missed. Rest in peace my brother.
Posted by: steve link Location: mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 08:27 PM
I worked with Craig on many occasions while driving tow trucks in Mishawaka. He was always a class act and always had a kind word to way when your were down. He will be truly missed my the Michiana community. My thoughts and prayers go out to his family and friends. I will surely miss him.
Posted by: Buford Location: On task on Nov 2, 2008 at 08:21 PM
Honor the man, not argue. It is a tragedy. I would hope that Officer Toner would not approve of all this sniping. Pathetic and Disrespectful.
Posted by: Jason Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 08:07 PM
My deepest sympathies go out to Craig's family and freinds. He will truly be missed.
Posted by: Billie Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 07:55 PM
My children and i witnessed this CRIME, we will never forget what we saw that day. Anyone posting a comment defending Alex I cannot understan, i have sympathy him. This is not something anyone is capable of doing. I do not drive drunk. He drove over him to get away thinking only of himself. Horrable unthinkable I was in disbelief that a human could do that. Alex showed his character on Sat. He should be locked up for life. To the family of Criq I send my prayers and hope you find the strengh to get through this unspeakable act of ignorance. We will be left with the memory of what we saw that saturday afternoon forever. My three and four year old children are pledge now with viewing Alex's horrible actions.
Posted by: Mishawaka Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 07:55 PM
Craig, you are so loved and missed. People that truly knew you know what kind of a man and a true hero you are. RIP my brother in blue. You are so loved and so missed. God bless his family and friends. I hope that his brother that was with him is trying to cope as well. This is just hard for all the Toner family all the way around. I will be saying a prayer for all of you.WHAT A REAL MAN AND HERO
Posted by: SB Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 07:46 PM
All you that say Alex is scum and he should be punished. Well do any of you know him? And how do you know what happened and if he Did get out and look at what happened, Why didn't those "witnesses" try to stop him from getting back in his vehicle? Shows how much they wanted to help. And any one friends or not who defend him can post here if they want to. And when did this go from talking about Alex to talking about all Hispanics? & he isn't from Mexico! All you people should think before you talk. I am sorry for the loss but no one knew it was going to happen that way. I STILL say it's no ones fault. Stuff Happens.
Posted by: Anonymous Location: Sbi on Nov 2, 2008 at 07:41 PM
I want to send my sympathies to the Toner Family, I can only imagine what you are going through. To Alex's Family my sympathies also go out to you because you have to ashamed for what he did. I mostly feel bad for his son because he doesn't have much to look up too. Alex has to realize that not only did Mr. Toner have to pay the ultimate price for his mistake everyone else does also. It is a continuest cycle. I think that everyone should keep there racist thoughts to themselves its hard to believe that in 2008 and the fact that we could have a black president that racial profiling still occurs. Fortunately this could of happend to anyone at any given time, you go by the liquor store and at 7am there are patrons there. Alex's prior arrest shouldn't dictate his future or his son's. Again my prayers are with the Toner Family.
Posted by: tom wroblewski Location: roseland on Nov 2, 2008 at 07:21 PM
From A fellow rider GOD speed bro.. cagers watch out for cycles this happens to often...
Posted by: T'd off Location: south bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 07:11 PM
I totally understand your pain. My uncle Bill had his brain blown out of his head from a drunk 16 year old boy who was drunk. He ruined my whole family's life as well for a long period a time, but people do not have the right to say that there should mobs sent out, or that his family should die!! Ill defend or say what the hell I want! obviously everyone else is. I have said nothing to hurt you or your family. I will not. I, and all of everyone that I know is so sorry for your this family to be faced with such horror.
Posted by: Al's cousin joey on Nov 2, 2008 at 07:05 PM
I think my cousin should get one more chance and get some AA classes or something like that cause he never did get them..when Alex is sober he is one funny dude, and i know because i was with him almost every day..you ppl need 2 get your facts str8 before talking bad about my cousin..And to my aunt and uncle....we gotta stay strong on this one..luv u guys
Posted by: Cindy & Don Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 07:04 PM
Okay, This is really pissing me off. The thing that needs to be addressed now is the Toner Family and how they all go on from here. We were close friends with Craig and he was someone who stood head and shoulders above the rest. He didn't deserve this but his friends will help with that along the way. Once a cop always a cop. One damned good one left us and we will never forget him. God speed our friend, We will always love you
Posted by: life Location: south bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 06:46 PM
I would hope no one would do something, like take matters into there own hands and hurting Alex. It will only cause you to put your own life faeing the same fate. Don't listen to SCUM like that!
Posted by: Wendy Location: Niles on Nov 2, 2008 at 06:27 PM
I can't believe people are defending this person. He drove drunk, hit someone, then purposely drove over them to get away. I don't care if he had a record or what his skin color is-his actions are disgusting and horrible to any normal person.If drinking/drugs makes you do things you wouldn't normally do then don't do it. My thoughts and prayers go out to all innocents in this.
Posted by: A Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 06:16 PM
To t'd off...at least Orta gets "to live" with this forever...I am not judging Orta..but please stop defending him...this is not the place for that....everyone that knows the Toner family is expressing our grief...be grateful that is just words. I personally know Craigs' daughter and you cannot even begin to imagine what this has done to her...friends of Orta please stop posting here!
Posted by: Jail Deputy Location: Jail on Nov 2, 2008 at 05:23 PM
How could you ever blame Craig? Because of scumbags like Orta we have had 8 shootings and 4 murders in a week! I think that it should be 5 murders! I personally know this turd Orta and his arrest record basically explains it all! My thoughts and prayers are with the Toner family and the judges of St. Joseph County!
Posted by: Steve on Nov 2, 2008 at 05:17 PM
Plesase put this suspect away for a long, long time. I have to wonder if this suspect has been arrested 19 time what the H$%l is he doing on the street. When are people in this community going to wake up and demand these judges be accountable. They are not protecting you.WNDU look into this defendants past...This could have been anyone killed by this man. God bless you Craig, I will always remember the nice guy and great cop you were.
Posted by: Morgan Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 05:14 PM
I meant Craig aka Dutch for the first time last weekend. I didnt know that my first time meeting this exceptional man would be my last. He brought so much joy to my friends and family. He's also pushed one of my best friends into being a new but amazing cop. His memory will live on in my family's hearts forever. I hope that Orta gets the max punishment for taking this wonderfull man away from his and my family and friends.
Posted by: Chief Scoob Location: Indiana on Nov 2, 2008 at 04:45 PM
First off, the Police are doing their jobs. He was arrested 19 times. It's the courts that release these idiots from Jail not the Police. So to everyone that is complaining about the Police please get a life. This piece of crap just killed a Police Officer. Lets just hope the Courts will actually keep this idiot in Jail this time. RIP peace brother.
Posted by: gods kid Location: south bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 04:29 PM
I hope that everyone that is judging Mr. Alex Orta, has something to say to the Lord on there day of death, and tell god why he should show you mercy, when you did not! Good luck with that. I'll pray for you.
Posted by: t'd off!!!! on Nov 2, 2008 at 04:23 PM
Everyone has all this hate inside of them. There are a lot of people that need to be locked up for the stuff that they did. Alex did his time for everything that he's done in the past! Everyone needs to understand that this young man has to live with this forever. He will do his time for this, but it is for the most unforgivable things. it is without words the heartbreak and embarrassment that his family must face now. We are all so very sorry of the choice Alex made yesterday.
Posted by: Insider Location: SB on Nov 2, 2008 at 04:22 PM
Sorry T-bird. You're not gonna get any sympathy here. I do have sympathy with Orta's family though. They have to deal with being associated with him. Maybe this time he'll be locked up for good. If he's not, the Judge must be held accountable! Let's all pay attention to this one!
Posted by: S on Nov 2, 2008 at 04:21 PM
Maybe T-bird SHOULD pray for the scum Orta. Pray that others don't find him and take care of justice on their own. After being arrested 19 times it's obvious that the courts can't do their job. Drinking and driving is NOT 'just an accident'. Judges, lawyers...any comments? Or just excuses.
Posted by: ORTA Family FRIEND. Location: South Bend, IN on Nov 2, 2008 at 04:14 PM
Yes I know he made the wrong choice, but none of you know nothing about him but his record. If you knew the real ALEX ORTA like his friends and family do you would know he would never do something like this on purpose. You think he hit the officer on purpose then purposely ran him over. Then you all are stupid. You and I know what alcohol can do to a person. Alex would never do something like that in his right mind. Just because a guy is arrested all these times does not mean nothing maybe we need to check with all the racist police officers that were involved in these arrest. Ask yourself one question if Alex was white would all of you still think the same thing. Get your facts straight before you talk about him and his loving parents. We are all sad for what happened and my condolences go out to officer Toner's family, but it could have happened to anyone and I'm sure Alex is very sorry about what happened and for all of you to say he did it on purpose is nuts. Stay up Alex!
Posted by: cant believe it Location: south bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 04:09 PM
Dear Edward, I am his friend! I have been for a very long time. I grew up knowing him from the neighborhood. I wouldn't call myself a scum bag. You shouldn't either. you don't know me, I could be the very person working on you if you get hurt! The point is, you never know who, what, when or where, but bad things happen to people, and I'm so sorry it was Alex that has done so. Every one has people in there family who does stupid stuff all the time, but you just always hope that they or some one else doesn't get hurt. This time it just had to be little Alex. It's a horrific tragedy. Now he must face the life ahead of him, no matter what. My sympathy and prayers go to all the family and friends involved. The Toner's and the Orta's.
Posted by: Stephanie Location: Osceola on Nov 2, 2008 at 03:43 PM
First and fore most T-bird you need to get your facts straight before you run your mouth, and also should probably find some new friends. Second to the person that is talking s#@! about everyone gathering at Moondogs Pub... Were you there? Probably not so you also need to find out the facts before you make comments that you know nothing about. Everyone needs someone at this horrible time and that was a gathering spot for everyone to meet. Yes people had drinks but its one thing to have drinks and be irresponsable and then there is having drinks with what some people call a designated driver...so please don't talk s@#! about stuff you have no clue about...Rest in peace Craig you will be greatly missed...
Posted by: D Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 03:04 PM
Godspeed, Toner. I'll miss working with you. My thoughts and prayers are with your family and our brothers and sisters in blue. It is certainly time for the judges and prosecutors in this county to take DUI seriously. Don't plea it down to reckless driving... DUI kills and hurts innocent people! It's also time to realize that it's the same 5% of the population that commit crimes over and over. These people need to be held responsible for their actions, so innocent people don't have to keep paying. How did the safety of the public become less important the a proven criminal's 19th "second chance"?
Posted by: Mr. Obvious Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 03:04 PM
How are you still on the streets and able to drive while being arrested 19 times in 8 years? He won't meet Sparky fast enough for me.
Posted by: 20109 on Nov 2, 2008 at 02:54 PM
Rest in peace brother.
Posted by: Anonymous Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 02:36 PM
I also knew Alex personally and yes he would hurt somebody intentionally. He was a piece of trash and I won't be surprised when they confirm not only alcohol in his system but some drugs as well. My prayers are for Toner's family, not a piece of garbage who has made a bad decision at least 19 times, not to mention the numerous other times he was not caught. You speak of Karma so does that mean Alex should be killed as well?
Posted by: MK Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 02:35 PM
My thoughts and prayers go out to Officer Toner, his family, and the Roseland Police Dept. T-Bird, it is hard to understand where you come from when you say that this Orta character would never hurt anyone on purpose, HE HIT HIM THEN GOT OUT, LOOKED, AND RAN HIM OVER!!!!! That was not an accident, he knew he was wrong was just trying to get away to avoid making his 20th trip to jail. At least he gets to live to see another day. You are a hero in my eyes Craig, R.I.P.
Posted by: Katherine Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 02:22 PM
I take exception with "T-bird" blaming the victim, Craig Toner, for his death. Orta had a choice to drink or to drive. He chose to do both and an exceptional human being, a good person, died. I have no sympathy to spare for Orta -- who is obviously a drunk and a coward. He drove over the man to make sure he was dead! I do extend my sincere sympathies to the Toner family. Craig was a good and honest man.
Posted by: Edward Location: south bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 02:07 PM
Hey, Tbird, I was a county deputy who had contact with Orta. He IS a scumbag and if you hang with him, you probably are too. Decent people dont have 19 arrests!
Posted by: Melissa Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 01:56 PM
what?? not hurt anyone on purpose, like running them over after hitting them isn't on purpose? he may have not been the only drunk driver on the streets but he's the only drunk driver to hit someone and then run them over!! i think you need some new friends, t bird.
Posted by: A friend Location: Right here...... on Nov 2, 2008 at 01:47 PM
Hey Tbird....your friend would never do this on purpose? Hmmm.... you sure about that? How many times did he not mean to do so before? You may want to check your FACTS and not your feelings? We'll see about Karma you jerk!
Posted by: a friend on Nov 2, 2008 at 01:46 PM
To the comment written by sad on everyone going to moondogs afterwards: we needed our time to be together and mourn the loss of a great man, a great police officer,and a great friend! Those who did have a drink didnt drive!!! So please no comments or remarks about things you have no idea about, this is a hard time for all of us and we do not need any negitivity right now. Craig i love you and you will be missed by all ! Rest in peace hun
Posted by: T bird Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 01:11 PM
First of all, I understand Alex was Wrong for drinknig and driving. I know Alex personally and Ill tell you first hand that he would never hurt anyoe on purpose.Everyone knows he wasnt the only drunk driver on the streets, he just made a big mistake while doing it.I heard that the victim was also invlovled in a drug money situation in the past. Karma will turn around and bite you in the rear. My prayers go out to the ORTAS!!
Posted by: BUCKSHOT Location: St Joseph County on Nov 2, 2008 at 01:02 PM
Prayers and thoughts to the family of Craig and to the Roseland Police Department and Community.
Posted by: Rachel Location: MIshawaka IN on Nov 2, 2008 at 12:54 PM
I still cant believe that he is gone. he was a great guy who if he saw you needed help he would help. My thoughts go out to his family and friends. R.I.P Craig
Posted by: Anonymous Location: Niles on Nov 2, 2008 at 12:52 PM
I always had a feeling something like this was going to happen with Alex. Everytime you would see him out he was always messed up. He never had any common sense. I feel deeply sorry for Craig's Family. Its so sad that this had to happen to your loved one.
Posted by: Juan Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 12:34 PM
I had the privilidge to work with this man. It was a short time in which I am greatful for. I was a young officer that Craig befriended and gave lots of great advice. I have so much respect for Craig. It is with tears that I write this as I think of the great guy that Craig is. My prayers go out to Craig and his family. Thank you for everything Craig.
Posted by: Sad on Nov 2, 2008 at 12:28 PM
Ill miss you Craig.
Posted by: Very Sad on Nov 2, 2008 at 12:18 PM
I am so sorry to hear of this man's untimely death. I am troubled that the drunk driver was arrested "19" TIMES! Who didn't do their job? Why was the idiot on the streets? I will gladly pull the lever to eliminate this trash from our society. Ok, so the policeman was killed by a drunk driver and everyone gathers at Moondogs Pub to mourn? What kind of message are you sending? How many mourners had drinks and drove home? Tell the truth and don't make excuses.
Posted by: Shane Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 11:55 AM
I don't understand how someone arrested that many times is still out on the streets. I think it is time for tougher sentences.
Posted by: Anonymous on Nov 2, 2008 at 11:48 AM
Orta never deserves freedom again. Prayers to the family.
Posted by: Informed on Nov 2, 2008 at 11:32 AM
It's not the criminals you should fear in St. Joe County, YOU SHOULD FEAR THE JUDGES OF ST. JOE COUNTY!! This guy should have been in jail and not on the streets getting drunk and having a good time! WHEN ARE YOU IDIOTS ARE GOING TO REALIZE THAT THE JUDGES NEED TO BE ELECTED AND NOT APPOINTED??!! Now, more blood on the hands of the judges in St. Joe County! Craig was a great guy. God rest his soul!! And to Rich, no this was not him. Craig was a good and honest Cop.
Posted by: Kelly Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 11:11 AM
God Speed Craig....you will be deeply missed. My thoughts and prayers go out to your family.
Posted by: amber Location: goshen on Nov 2, 2008 at 10:34 AM
My thoughts and prayers go out to his family, this is such a tragedy.
Posted by: firefighter Location: SB on Nov 2, 2008 at 10:07 AM
Craig was a great guy. I worked with him on calls and he was a fantastic police officer and a severe loss for the community.
Posted by: Pam Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 09:15 AM
Another tragic crime committed by a known felon. He was charged before for leaving the scene of a fatality accident, so how many chances do these low life's get. If arrested 19 times since 2000, sounds like the typical work of our St. Joe County Judges. Wake up St. Joe County , our legal system has a revolving door, how many more inocent and decent people have to be killed, while the carreer criminals roam free to do it all over again. This dirt bag better get charges that stick and make him do hard time. He's killed two already, what does it take to go to jail here? God speed Craig, you were a gift to this community, and a great person, you will truly be missed by those who know and love you.
Posted by: Linda Location: warsaw area on Nov 2, 2008 at 08:44 AM
what a sad story! Im glad i dont live in South Bend to much drama there! Orta should get the death penality! Its sad he hit the officer then ran him over! That should be murder! I hope orta gets life in prison without parole! my thoughts and prayers are with Craig and his family! Rest in peace craig!
Posted by: Scott Location: Bristol on Nov 2, 2008 at 08:41 AM
I hope they throw that guy in jail for the rest of his life. When will the courts get smart. How can someone be arrested 19 times, once for another leaving the scene of another fatality accident, and still be out on the road, being a danger to others. Here he is killing an innocent person because of his stupid choice to drink and drive. I truly hope to hear that his is going to jail, for life, with NO chance for parole.
Posted by: N Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 08:38 AM
Maybe this time they will lock him up for good. Even in death Toner is looking out for people.
Posted by: Mary on Nov 2, 2008 at 08:36 AM
Please tell me why someone who has been arrested 19 times, with one arrest for leaving the scene of a fatal accident, is out on the streets!
Posted by: Liz Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 08:11 AM
Craig was a great guy. I always saw him with a smile on his face. He will be missed greatly. My prayers go to his friends and family.
Posted by: Juan Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 08:04 AM
I want to offer my sincerest condolences to the family of Officer Toner. I experienced firsthand his kindness and decency, just as others have decribed. He assisted me in a hit and run involving another vehicle leaving the scene after hitting mine. And I have nothing but the greatest respect for Officer Toner after that incident. After the accident, I told my wife and so many others 'what a great guy, really nice guy, Officer Toner is!' I felt this after only one encounter with him...but when someone is such a wonderful, caring, and decent human being...it only takes one impression to know it. That's all it took for me. One simple traffic accident to experience the greatness of this kind man, Officer Toner. Thank you, to his family for sharing him with this community, and for his service here...making it a better community for every one of us whose paths he crossed. May God Bless him. Our prayers are with you.
Posted by: Marguerite Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 07:53 AM
Craig had no known enemies! He was there for anyone who needed him. My prayers go out to his family, both police departments he served on and the town of Roseland. He was a dear sweet man and they just don't make them any better than Craig. Rest in peace Craig, you will be and are missed!
Posted by: T Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 07:44 AM
My thoughts and prayers go out to his family and friends.
Posted by: scott Location: southbend on Nov 2, 2008 at 07:26 AM
greg was a dear friend of mine and to my family!we will miss him so much!he was an awesome person to know and to love.we will miss you greg!!may god bless his family!1
Posted by: Mike Location: South Side on Nov 2, 2008 at 06:35 AM
He was arrested 19 times? I would like to know what all the charges are for.We will see if the prosecutors office will plea bargain this one too.
Posted by: CH Location: SB on Nov 2, 2008 at 06:20 AM
Such a sad lose!! Please know you are all in out thoughts and prayers. Too bad this guy was on the road. When will people ever learn??
Posted by: wayne Location: nappanee on Nov 2, 2008 at 05:57 AM
what a tragedy of this cruel life. god comfort his family.
Posted by: Sad on Nov 2, 2008 at 05:21 AM
I hope this piece of trash, Orta, gets everything he deserves! Rest in Peace, Craig.
Posted by: Anonymous on Nov 2, 2008 at 04:13 AM
Arrested 19 times wow. He shouldn't even be out doing anything! How tragic. Hopefully he goes away for a long time now. So sad it took something like this 2 hopefully put this loser behind bars.
Posted by: Angie Location: South Bend on Nov 2, 2008 at 04:30 AM
My thoughts and prayers go out to the family. 0:)
Posted by: Me Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 02:44 AM
This SCUM ORTA was arrested 19 times since 2000??!! Thanks again to the worthless judges of St. Joseph County who should have sent this SCUM to prison a long time ago!!!!!!! May god be with Officer Toner's family.
Posted by: ram Location: chesterton on Nov 2, 2008 at 01:54 AM
This alleged drunk was arrested 19 times in less than 9 years? This is another tragedy that could have been avoided if some decent jail time waqs handed out on say the tenth "second chance". My heart goes out to this poor guy and his family...very sad.
Posted by: SBLaw Location: 701 on Nov 2, 2008 at 01:44 AM
Godspeed Craig. A man dedicates his career to taking scum off the street and a POS like this leaves the scene while driving under the influence and kills a police officer who is off and enjoying life like Joe Citizen. Unreal. Hopefully a charge more than causing death while intoxicated can be had.
Posted by: Anonymous on Nov 2, 2008 at 01:40 AM
Horrible. R.I.P.
Posted by: Melanie Gibson Location: Mishawaka on Nov 2, 2008 at 01:33 AM
Mt. Toner was my sister-in-laws father. He has a 3yr old granddaughter. We were all together last night for trick or treating. His family is devasted at the loss. He had just purchased a home in South Bend and was looking forward to maoving and being closer to his daughter and granddaughter.
Posted by: Jena Location: Nicolini (Perkins) on Nov 2, 2008 at 01:16 AM
You will be missed Craig. You are a great man and a wonderful man. We love you and you will always be in our hearts.
Posted by: ron on Nov 2, 2008 at 01:09 AM
Sorry to say ,"He was killed by a DRUNK DRIVER"!!!!Last place I would want to go was a bar.And that moron was arrested 19 times in 8 yrs? what about 3 strikes your out? condolences to Craig`s family......
Posted by: Mike Gillam Location: Roseland on Nov 2, 2008 at 12:05 AM
This is very tragic and sad, our town has lost a fine officer, and our hearts and prays go to his family.
Posted by: m Location: sb on Nov 1, 2008 at 11:28 PM
Guess it wasn't enough to have crashed into him, he had to run him over also?! That's why MADD calls them crashes, not accidents. He shouldn't have been on the road. May all Craig's family, friends and loved ones find strength, healing and blessings in their time of sorrow.
Posted by: steph Location: oc on Nov 1, 2008 at 11:14 PM
Yet another police officer killed...Toner was a very caring person that will be missed by many...his family is in our thoughts and prayers at this time of need!
Posted by: Dawn Location: Mishawaka on Nov 1, 2008 at 11:12 PM
This is very sad as Craig was a very nice person as well as a nice officer. I have known Craig for years and this a tremendous lost to all that knew him as well as his family & the community. I am so sick of hearing about drunk drivers killing people & taking away good people only for the drunk driver too do a year in jail and back out on the streets driving & enjoying time with there family...WHEN IS ST JOSEPH COUNTY going to say no more Pleas & start throwing the book at these individuals??? Craig you will always be in our hearts & I'm saddened by this.
Posted by: Anonymous on Nov 1, 2008 at 11:08 PM
Mistakes happen, but running him over AFTER hitting him, and fleeing? Let this POS rot in hell. I hope he gets killed in prison.
Posted by: KJ Location: South Bend on Nov 1, 2008 at 10:36 PM
I was at the hospital ER with my ill mother when he came in. They worked on him for over three hours. What a shame.They went above and beyond to save him. My prayers to the family.
Posted by: Sherri Dabney Location: Roseland on Nov 1, 2008 at 10:34 PM
This is such a sad loss....we will miss you Craig. Roseland will keep you and your family in their thoughts and prayers.
Posted by: Edison Park Home Owner Location: South Bend on Nov 1, 2008 at 10:10 PM
That is down the street from our home. People drive way to fast through the neighborhood cutting through to the main roads. People need to slow down so that tradgies like this do not happen again.
Posted by: Sad on Nov 1, 2008 at 09:57 PM
I hope this piece of trash is convicted of every charge and gets the maximum sentence. Craig was a good man and did nothing wrong in this case!
Posted by: Karma Location: Indiana on Nov 1, 2008 at 09:44 PM
The philosophical explanation of karma can differ slightly between traditions, but the general concept is basically the same. Through the law of karma, the effects of all deeds actively create past, present, and future experiences, thus making one responsible for one's own life, and the pain and joy it brings to him/her and others. The results or 'fruits' of actions are called karma-phala. In religions that incorporate reincarnation, karma extends through one's present life and all past and future lives as well. Karma don't cross me.
Posted by: mike Location: south bend on Nov 1, 2008 at 09:36 PM
'subsequently ran over'...meaning he stopped, saw him on the ground, and THEN ran him over. SICK. He needs to die. My prayers are with Toner's family and friends.
Posted by: David & Dorothy Snyder Location: Roseland on Nov 1, 2008 at 09:31 PM
Marshal Toner was a very good soul and this is so tragic. We are praying for his family and we are so sorry for your loss. Craig touched so many with his thoughtfulness and kindness, on and off duty, he will be greatly missed.
Posted by: Jack T. Location: Mishawaka on Nov 1, 2008 at 09:14 PM
Craiger you will be greatly missed my friend. You were always there when anyone just needed to talk. I know that you are in heaven my friend, as we all have walked through hell. God Bless your daughter,son,brother and your grandchildren. I will always cherish our talks together and your honesty. You will always be a wonderful example of all that is good in people. Rest in piece now my friend, we will now take your watch. I love you brother . . .
Posted by: Mr. Obvious Location: South Bend on Nov 1, 2008 at 09:06 PM
Heartless and gutless. He should get the death penalty. Not only did he hit him once, but he had so little compassion that he drove over him too. No excuse. The world would be better off without him.
Posted by: Jim Location: Warsaw on Nov 1, 2008 at 09:05 PM
He gets back into the SUV and then runs over him again? The Lord might have mercy on this persons soul, but the court should not. Sounds like they forgot one important charge...Murder. He got back in the vehicle, knowing full well that the Marshall was right there and ran over him again. Anyone think this other than myself? My heart goes out to the family of the deceased, and my sympathies to the family of Mr. Orta, they are in for some tough times ahead. Apparently that wasn't a concern of his at the time.
Posted by: Shayne Location: South Bend on Nov 1, 2008 at 08:34 PM
God speed Craig. A truly good, decent man.
Posted by: Dan Location: South Bend on Nov 1, 2008 at 08:30 PM
Rest in Peace you will be greatly missed!
Posted by: Nichole Location: Mishawaka on Nov 1, 2008 at 08:15 PM
We have lost a truly great man. My thoughts and prayers are with your family.

Five Day
16 Curb Appeal - Vote
WNDU News Poll
There are currently no active polls at this time.
Click here to view other polls on our site and past poll results.
MichianaGuide.com
 

Most Popular Headlines
NewsCenter16 iWitness - Send us your pictures and video

Be an iWitness: Send us your pictures and video.