Windmills appear in Michiana
Windmills appear in Michiana Save Email Print
Some regulators caught by surprise
Posted: 6:32 PM Sep 30, 2008
Last Updated: 6:45 AM Oct 1, 2008
Reporter: Mark Peterson
Email Address: mpeterson@wndu.com

A | A | A

You might be surprised to find out what’s being sold as ‘the next big thing’ in home appliances.

Apparently, windmills aren’t just for Holland anymore.

“I think every home should have something like this,” said David Smith, with Wind-Wire Energy Solutions.

In St. Joseph County there are five pending requests for windmill construction permits.

Recently, units have also been built in Marshall, Elkhart, and Berrien counties. There are those who would like to see a windmill in every yard.

“Why not with the increased cost of fuel this is one way
to save money,” Smith said.

Today Smith showed News Center 16 a unit in the back yard of a LaPorte County home. It stands 40-feet high, and costs $13,700 installed.

Some say it’s worth it, just to see the occasional impact on the electric meter. “It’s rotating backwards right now, and that’s the key to the ball game,” said Smith. “All of the sudden they’re getting credited for that electric that’s going back into the grid.”

Smith contends that the unit can generate as much as 15-hundred kilowatts per month. That’s designed to be enough to eliminate the electric bill for a 20-thousand square foot home.

When asked if the company was ever denied permission to install a residential wind energy conversion system, Smith held up one finger and said that the “City of Schererville” once told him it wasn’t going to issue a building permit for a windmill project.

After all, windmills aren’t lawn ornaments, and there may be some negative as well as positive aspects to ‘do it yourself’ at-home electrical generation.

“What I do want to guard against is having too many, too close, to too many properties, and that’s primarily in the city,” said Chuck Bulot, the St. Joseph County Building Commissioner.

St. Joseph County officials want to write specific rules geared at wind generation devices, before the infatuation with windmills gets out of hand.

“Right now, I've gotten a recent rash of calls from people who insist that it's their constitutional right to put one of these up in their yard, and its not,” said Bulot.

There are currently two windmills located in the city limits of Mishawaka. Those windmills were part of the construction of a new First Federal Savings branch off Edison near Hickory.

For more information on Wind-Wire Energy Solutions, you can write to them at P.O. Box 10208, South Bend, Indiana, 46680. The company can be reached by telephone at 574-261-6539.

More Stories
ATF agents raid the Warsaw home of a known white supremacist

Granger man turns hobby into business with D'Avella Family Winery

Update: Woman and children recovering after car crashes into store window

U93 kicks off annual Roofsit campaign to help prevent child abuse

Part of Cleveland Avenue closed in St. Joe

Man hospitalized after motorcycle accident

80-year-old Niles man shot, robbed at home; suspects arrested

Golfer Chris Smith and family still in shock over weekend accident

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Joe Location: St. Joseph County on Oct 3, 2008 at 12:22 PM
Mitch Daniels sitting on his Harley with the big wind turbines in the back ground telling that renewable energy is the way, then why is it our local officials making it hard and more costly for the people of this state to put their own personal wind turbine up. Then you have Bulot stating it's against our contitutional right well far as I'm concerned he should be handed his walking papers. I did not know that the state of Indiana is under a Dictatorship.

Posted by: Steve Location: Goshen on Oct 1, 2008 at 10:07 PM
I'm a great believer in wind power, but the claims made in this article are highly inflated. First, 1500 KWHr per month might be lots of power for a 2000 sq ft house, but I suspect a 20,000 sq ft house would use much more that 1500 KWHr per month. Was this a typo? Second and even more important, a $13,700 windmill will likely generate only about 2 -3 KW peak during a wind of about 25 MPH. This doesn't happen very often in these parts. 2 KW x 24 hrs x 30 days = 1440 KWHr per month. The big problem here is that the unit makes no power below a typical start-up wind speed of 8 - 10 mph. Also, 40' up is no where near high enough to get out of ground and tree turbulance, and into the higher wind speeds aloft. Most of Indiana is not known in the wind industry as a good place for wind power because of a chronic lack of regular winds of sufficient speed to generate useful energy. Take the claims in this article with a grain of salt... or two!

Posted by: Jeff Location: South Bend on Oct 1, 2008 at 04:54 PM
Saying that windmills will use up all of the wind is like saying solar panels will use up all of the heat we get from the sun. A windmill is shaped like a fan, and what does a fan do? Just like Chuck Bulot, it blows.

Posted by: Glenn Location: Nappanee on Oct 1, 2008 at 03:54 PM
I'm sure what Bulot MEANT to say was to check your local zoning ordinances first. Check your subdivision by-laws. Check for utility and setback easements. Obtain schematics from install company and get a consultation from a licensed electrician to install a commercial-grade surge surpression system, and be sure your home's system can handle everything. I'm sure this is all what Mr. Bulot MEANT to say.

Posted by: Willie Location: Niles on Oct 1, 2008 at 03:48 PM
Is anyone allowed to do anything without a government permit anymore? Mr. Bulot, can you tell me if it's within my Constitutional rights to call you an idiot?

Posted by: Glenn Location: Nappanee on Oct 1, 2008 at 03:21 PM
"take it down when tornadoes are around"? "we woont need no lectric lines no more either"? "their constitutional right to put one of these up in their yard, and its not”? How much aspirin will $13,700 buy me? Hey Bulot, show me the aerial rights zoning law. Bet it says 100' high for something without "improvements with square footage". By all means assume everyone's as ignorant as you.

Posted by: Bob Location: SB on Oct 1, 2008 at 02:55 PM
Apparently Bulot forgot who he works for. Lets remind him come election time.

Posted by: Harry Location: South Bend on Oct 1, 2008 at 02:25 PM
Like many products, the costs are high in the beginning, but as this technology grows and more companys get involved, the retail prices should go down and make the purchase of these windmills more cost-effective. Vince - you are absolutely spot-on with your comments. Time to get rid of the 'arrogant' bureaucrats.

Posted by: M Location: V on Oct 1, 2008 at 01:44 PM
You have a good point T. If we take the energy out of wind, will we change weather systems like global warming is? Will Chicago's nickname change to "the not-so-windy City"? Maybe Don Quixote was right.

Posted by: worker Location: indiana on Oct 1, 2008 at 01:25 PM
The bottom line to this issue is that the wealthy, like T. Boone Pickens, want to invest in this energy and he will make hundreds of millions more (and he admittedly states he doesn't need any more) and us poor folks will just keep on paying. That's why we can't put them in our back yard. Those in control will see to it that the rich get richer.

Posted by: T Crimmins Location: Lakeville on Oct 1, 2008 at 11:56 AM
Don quijotes? Is that a restrawnt chain? I been to don pablos coupel times, pretty nice, I like that spanish food so another place with same stuff might be nice. I worry about this wind power really, cos I think they'll use up all the wind and then sail boats and planes wont be able to move anyplace. And no more flyin kites for the young uns. gotta think about the consqunces.

Posted by: Rex Location: Kokomo, IN on Oct 1, 2008 at 11:48 AM
As Congress wrung its hands and twisted arms yesterday over a bill aimed at saving the nation from an epic financial crisis, time continued to run out for the extension of crucial tax credits for the renewable energy industry. What have they been doing for the last 7 years outside filling their pockets, why are they bailing out foreign financial institutions because thats where they have been putting their money for years tax free free. $700 Billion to bail out Wall Street but they can't renew the Wind & Solar tax credit for home owners. Yes we are installing a wind turbine but we live on 15 acres and I have a permit from Howard Co. and our power company is working with us which is a PLUS. We also get Geo Thermal tax credits, water is free if you live in the country why not wind its free anywhere.

Posted by: Don Quijote's coming Location: South Bend on Oct 1, 2008 at 10:58 AM
Has anyone seen Don Quijote yet?

Posted by: Rick Location: South Bend on Oct 1, 2008 at 09:59 AM
At $14,000 and 10-cents per kilowatt-hour (the unit we pay for), that's 140,000 kWh to make up the initial cost. My own usage, for a 2,600 square foot house is less that 1000 kWh per month. That's about 12 years to pay off the unit--which may well wear out in that time. Selling energy back to the grid helps, but we are not in a prime wind zone. The economics are shaky here.

Posted by: Don Location: South Bend on Oct 1, 2008 at 09:29 AM
We DO have a constitutional right to take Bulot out of office. Our leaders better start thinking about how the people they serve are going to survive in the future, not keep finding reasons to take more money out of their already going flat pockets or reduce their rights.

Posted by: Tristan Location: Mishawaka on Oct 1, 2008 at 09:12 AM
I love green power, this is exactly what this town needs! But seein as we live in a tornado area, I think it probly is pretty dangerous to have like one in every yard and such. Instead, the city should put a BIG one on each water tower and just take it down when tornados are around. Also, since it would be right there on the water tower they could probably just pump the lectric along the same pipes as the water and then we woont need no lectric lines no more either. Just a thought. PS it would pretty high up too so it could catch lighterning too during storms. This is a great idea I think and will save this city billions!

Posted by: Ryan Location: Granger on Oct 1, 2008 at 09:11 AM
It is a good thing to see that renewable energy is really catching on. Even better that private citizens and companies are paying for the cost of wind power generation and not my tax dollars. However, for the same reason I don't want my neighbors to have a 12' fence or travel trailer parked in the front yard, I would not necesarily want a landscape of windmills as my view. It's a tough one, I imagine folks with more land would obtain permits with less hassle.

Posted by: M Location: V on Oct 1, 2008 at 09:05 AM
Anonymous7:48 is right. What about our right to bear wind farms? Vince is also correct - Bulot said that "Constitutional right" statement with way too much attitude. Remember who you work for Chuckster.

Posted by: Brian Lewis Location: nappanee on Oct 1, 2008 at 08:39 AM
Very soon there will be lawsuits over noise, visual pollution and the impact on the mating habits of fruit bats. Then at some point one of the windmills will throw a blade and some precious child will end up with a chunk of carbon fiber sticking out of the top of his head. Oh the lawyers can't wait for these to start popping up in a yard near you.

Posted by: Anonymous on Oct 1, 2008 at 08:17 AM
a 14 thousand dollar eye sore.

Posted by: Bill Location: Niles on Oct 1, 2008 at 08:16 AM
Thanks to the people who have put up the windmills and those who will. There is obviously some $'s recieved from the utility due to net metering which reduces the payback Brad of Goshen uses to deride this great opportunity to reduce our dependencee on fossilized fuel and thinking.

Posted by: Brad Location: Goshen on Oct 1, 2008 at 06:54 AM
If this guy's electric bill is $100 per month (which it probably isn't) his payback would be almost twelve years, and that doesn't take into account the interest used to finance this purchase. Since most of the people in this area don't want such a beast in their yard there is also devalued property prices if he attempts to resell the property.

Posted by: Amy Location: Laporte on Sep 30, 2008 at 10:12 PM
I just built a home in LP in the country and would like one in my yard can multi houses share?

Posted by: Anonymous Location: Mishawaka on Sep 30, 2008 at 09:06 PM
See there Mayor Rea, the river and windmills. The wind there and Police department, the wind on the flags LOOK AT THEM. Google this http://www.mishawakacity.com/police.asp

Posted by: Vince Gatto Location: South Bend on Sep 30, 2008 at 08:21 PM
Remember what the federal government did for antennas/dishes, local government needs to be careful how much you try to regulate the windmill. Be Very Careful, don’t forget who you serve and there ability to remove individuals who don’t serve the majority of their constituents. Windmills are NOT the next big thing to TAX. Wind is free, well except the thousands it takes to buy, build, and maintain. Now add local government. Let’s see how we can make money off people trying to save money. 1.We will tax you to just apply to build one. 2.We will tax you on what it cost to build; you know the property improvement tax. 3.Now you have a taxable improvement on your property, we can tax that every year. With the money you save you can afford to pay us. 4. Hey you are selling electric, that’s income, give us our cut. Do you see my point local government, you can try and get what you can, while you can, but citizens pressure will force elected officials to pass the same kind of federal law.

Posted by: Anonymous on Sep 30, 2008 at 07:48 PM
I'd like to know why Bulot thinks it's not a constitutional right to have a windmill in your yard.

Posted by: Jim Location: Mishawaka on Sep 30, 2008 at 07:31 PM
Can't even put something up on your own property without the county sticking their nose in it.


Five Day
WNDU News Poll
There are currently no active polls at this time.
Click here to view other polls on our site and past poll results.
MichianaGuide.com