South Bend Police shoot, kill bank robbery suspect Save Email Print
Posted: 3:16 PM Jul 25, 2008
Last Updated: 12:07 AM Jul 26, 2008

A | A | A

A bank robbery suspect is dead tonight, after being shot by South Bend Police. Around 2:20 p.m. Friday afternoon, police say a man robbed the First Source Bank on Portage Road, that's on South Bend's northwest side. When police chased the suspect down, they say he attacked them with a knife. Police then shot him. The suspect was pronounced dead on the scene.

Police say they had no choice but to shoot the suspect because he was going after them with a knife. Bank officials told police the suspect looked like the same man who robbed their bank just last week.

The man got away with some cash and a dye pack. As the suspect left the bank at least four police officers chased him. The pursuit ended in the Calvary Baptist Church lot. “He [suspect] stopped, turned with the knife in his hand and he attacked officers. One of the officers was backing up, trying to get out of the attackers 'kill zone,’ gave every alternative to not do what he did and he chose to attack him,” says Commander Tim Corbett, with St. Joseph County Metro Homicide.

Police say two officers shot at the suspect. He was pronounced dead at the scene. Gas station attendant Amber Bashore heard the gunshots and saw the chase moments before. “I stepped outside, saw two cop cars and undercover come running out and a guy was running up over the corner of the grass, shot out that way and then all of a sudden, I started hearing gunshots,” explains Bashore.

Police say the man was shot in the upper torso, but wouldn't say how many times he was shot. “It needs to be perfectly clear that this is an ongoing investigation, but that the officers defended themselves in that attack. When you're being attacked with a knife, that's lethal force... more than enough to penetrate a vest, more than enough to kill you,” adds Corbett.

Although Bashore was surprised by the robbery, she says she wasn’t too surprised with how it all ended. “Hopefully people will realize that you can't do this. You know, it's just not right. I understand the economy, everything is raising in prices, but still, it's just not right for somebody to rob a bank,” says Bashore.

Right now, the names of the officers involved and the suspect are not being released. Police want to notify the suspect's family before releasing names.

The investigation remains ongoing and is in the hands of the St. Joseph County’s Metro Homicide Unit.

An autopsy on the suspect will be done in the next few days.

The last time a South Bend Police officer used deadly force on a suspect was in April 2007. That's when Patrolman Michael Norby shot and killed Scott Barnaby. You may remember that came after Barnaby shot and wounded Norby and killed his partner, Corporal Nick Polizzotto.

More Stories
Job cuts announced at Mishawaka Hummer plant

Bicyclist killed in St. Joseph county

South Bend Police search for shooting suspects

Michiana delegates discuss the Democratic National Convention

Steel workers may strike if contract talks continue without compromise

Ivy Tech again sees record enrollment

Local hotel rooms reserved in hopes of strengthening Chicago Olympic bid

Identity of officer involved in overnight shooting released

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Anonymous Location: IN on Aug 4, 2008 at 06:19 PM
SBPD, was right on this one sorry citizens for taking one more bum off welfare! He chose the wrong path and he paid for it in full!

Posted by: Ed Location: SBI on Aug 4, 2008 at 04:25 PM
So many clueless people. I bet each officer's gun held about 15 bullets. Restraint is that he was not shot 30 times. I bet it comes out that they fired until the threat to them (and the public, and the tellers at the next bank he would have robbed) was over. When he went down and was not a danger, I bet they stopped shooting. Anybody that thinks the police used disproportionate force has not faced a knife. Trust me, the courts have long recognized that this course of conduct is reasonable and acceptable. It's a shame the guy died and didn't get to change his life around and become a good citizen, but that was a result of his decisions. The officers aren't glad they had to shoot the guy, I guarantee it. They are only glad they went home to their families, in spite of the bad guy's actions.

Posted by: mike Location: elkhart on Aug 4, 2008 at 02:52 PM
Bottom line is the police have a job to do which is stop the bad guys from doing bad things. If they feel their lives are threatened because some scum bag has a knife, gun, club, ax or whatever, and he approaches the police, they have the right to take deadly force to stop him. If everyone would realize that, we might see less crime. If our laws were MUCH stricter, and you knew ahead of time that if you do something wrong, the penalty is possible death or a long incarceration (no get out of jail free cards), you might think twice. This countries laws SUCK when it comes to making people pay the price - you almost always get off with a slap of the hand. Go to some of these third world countries and steal something and get caught - you might get your hand cut off, or spend a year in jail, get cained. These places don't mess around and therefore have much less crime. Toughen up our laws and let the police do their job in a manner that makes people think twice. We'll all be better off.......

Posted by: Son of a Cop Location: SB on Aug 4, 2008 at 12:08 PM
Great Decision making by the SBPD...... http://www.southbendtribune.com/apps/pbcs.dll/article?AID=/20080804/News01/587500215&template=247art

Posted by: Myrt on Aug 4, 2008 at 10:37 AM
I feel the police were justified in protecting themselves. Also, don't the officers involved in a shooting such as this have to take time off for counseling before they come back to duty?? (I know the MSP used to have that protocol, but I'm unsure if it still it true) If so, with a 40 officer layoff, will there be enough officers to cover for those who may be out because a situation such as this.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 4, 2008 at 10:00 AM
Vito is right. They shouldn't have killed him with a gun. They should have beat him to death with clubs. What? Vito? Isn't that what you meant to say?

Posted by: Brad Location: Niles on Aug 4, 2008 at 09:05 AM
Well we will never know if the suspect did or did not in fact turn to attack the police because now we only have one side of the story. I'm not saying the police involved here were wrong or right but it is a well known fact that police and government cover up mistakes, lie about the facts and prey on that lack of knowledge. I will employ the same scrutiny to the police as is would be me if I were in their situation. Don't like it? Too bad! People lie even though their outward appearance and behavior would suggest otherwise. Cop bashing is well deserved for some. True, honest and righteous Law Enforcement Officers do not take offense. It's the bad ones that attempt to dissuade and exploit and take advantage of situations like this as exampled by the name calling and condescending remarks as it provides an effective cover and canvas for them to work.

Posted by: m4 on Aug 4, 2008 at 05:25 AM
vito im sure that you would just love if our police and all other citizens were unarmed...just like in england where only special armed units are allowed firearms....then all of our violent criminals would be the only ones armed and free to do whatever they want without fear of being stopped. and just like across the pond you guys could attack our police everyday. what kind of criminal activity are you and your friends involved in that would make you worry about the police being armed? and they dont have the authority to kill anybody you maroon. they were defending themselves. even someone that wasnt a cop could have shot that guy and couldnt be charged with anything. in my opinion everyone working at that bank should have been armed and should have took that guy out the second he pulled out the knife. good job SBPD.

Posted by: Anonymous on Aug 4, 2008 at 12:35 AM
Vito your an idiot, with all due respect. All he had was a KNIFE?...So the police should have used harsh language and their FISTS to subdue someone trying to kill them? Real bright on your part. Heres a situation. Dirt bag takes YOU hostage with a knife to your throat and has no intention of giving up until YOU or him are dead. Would you like the Police sniper who has a bead on the suspects head put his rifle down to wait and see what happens or take out suspect before he opens up your throat? Think about that and get out of the bubble that you live in! We are in a land of dirt bags with guns and knives that kill people. We are not in the UK where cops don't carry weapons. Police are getting killed in this country almost every day and quite frankly they are tired of it. Let this be a lesson to all people who make bad choices.

Posted by: Vito Location: S B on Aug 3, 2008 at 12:38 PM
We should take all the guns away from the cops. They should not be given the authority to kill anybody. They could have easily beaten this guy, all he had was a knife.

Posted by: Annon Location: South Bend on Aug 3, 2008 at 04:12 AM
Esther you need some help or education. Probably both. What exactly is the FBI suppose to look for. Man robs bank (Numerous as we are now finding out) and runs from the Police. Then turns on the Police and confronts them with a knife. Police defend themselves and the suspect it mortally wounded. What should they investigate? I am sure you have just great information on the Barnaby situation. You know not what you speak of in either case so please be quiet.

Posted by: Esther is correct Location: area 51 on Aug 1, 2008 at 01:23 PM
Esther you are correct we should examine the reports. This poor guy was gunned down by a flying saucer, just like the one who shot down 2 jets in NY, one in PA and one in DC a few years back in Sept. Maybe, just maybe Dick Cheney was out in the field hunting?

Posted by: m4 on Aug 1, 2008 at 02:47 AM
i love how all of you crybabys beg to be protected by the police and then throw a crybaby fit about the way its done. ohh what a shame that poor nice bank robber man that attacked the police with a knife was killed. im gonna go cry myself to sleep. maybe they should have did a backflip round house kick and knocked the kinfe out of his hand like in the movies. im glad they were smiling in the pictures and i hope they had fun. you would be happy too if you survived a situation where someone tried to kill you. the police need to shoot more bad guys.

Posted by: Willie Location: Niles on Jul 31, 2008 at 04:54 PM
I think Esther from Rolling Prairie should go stand in a field with a knife-wielding 20-something bank robber before she shoots her mouth off. Just my opinion. :-)

Posted by: A friend Location: South Bend on Jul 31, 2008 at 04:48 PM
I know Chris Slager, I promise he did not panic. He is one of the most level headed police officer. I don't know the other officer, but Chris is a very good cop, he fired his weapon because he had to. There was no other choice.

Posted by: lucy Location: south bend on Jul 31, 2008 at 11:42 AM
Annonymous at 9:34, you had a good comment except about the kids getting a gun pulled on them for ringing a doorbell. I would do the same thing if I asked them to stop and wouldn't. Shouldn't have been trespassing!

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 31, 2008 at 10:46 AM
Well said anonymous on July 31 08:34 AM..All too true!

Posted by: Anonymous Location: LaPorte, IN on Jul 31, 2008 at 10:28 AM
While I don't agree with what Brian did, I certainly am sorry that he chose to end his life this way. I worked with Brian 10 years ago when he was nineteen. He was a nice young kid then with such a chance for a bright future. That is how I choose to remember him. My prayers go out to him and his family. I am glad no other lives were lost.

Posted by: Maxwell Smart on Jul 31, 2008 at 10:16 AM
If only he had used his genius for niceness instead of evil.

Posted by: Anonymous Location: South Bend on Jul 31, 2008 at 09:34 AM
Why is it always the police's fault when a SUSPECT gets killed by an officer. This man robbed numerous banks, pharmacies, credit unions, and ect, and when he finally got caught it came down to a suicide by police. Once he was cornered, he knew he was going to jail, but he decided that was not an option for him. It was his time to get caught because the more desperate he was getting, the next robbery he could have killed someone, with a gun or a knife. We have people pulling guns on kids for ringing door bells, we have drug dealers shooting innocent people, drive by shootings everyday, but when a POLICE OFFICER pulls his gun, shoots or kills someone they are in the wrong. These men and women are here to protect us, if he had robbed your business, or your family the shooting would be justified. WHen the mayor takes away the police it will be up to the owners and or tellers to shoot the suspect, and our city will be more of a mess.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 31, 2008 at 09:22 AM
It doesnt matter if the money is insured. Jeesh you bored people will bring up anythng. Find a hobby.. crossword puzzles or maybe circle the word. It is a crime regardless. A crime that involved a weapon. If it was so easy then why use a weapon? Ummm because its not and its a crime. It is frowned upon by most normal people when somebody robs a bank. It wasn't a pack of gum from your local 7-11. At that thought.. rob houses. Everyone has house insurance so go at it! Wow you really just raised the ignorance level alot! Congratualtions

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 31, 2008 at 09:22 AM
I'm glad the Police were smiling in the Photos. They should be happy they cleansed Michaian of more trash. They should smile because there is one less robber on the street. They should smile because the Police scored one for the good guys. For those that don't like it, may I suggest that you never call anyone for help or better yet move out of town.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 30, 2008 at 08:24 PM
Again..Some of you cop hating people are just ticked off because SBPD won the fight! If one of the officers had been killed you would still make excuses for the perpetrator of how mentally ill or whatever bad marbles were rolling around in his head that fateful day. Don't get mad. If you people got a family member that is robbing banks, tell them to quit or they may suffer the same consequences if they attempt to attack officers with a DEADLY weapon. Oh by the way, for you professionals that think you know everything about police work, you can still die from getting shot in the leg if you get hit in the right spot! Lets see if one of you sharpshooters could hit someone in that location if the perp is MOVING at you at a high rate of speed. No one had anything bad to say about the bank security guard in Niles that whacked a bank robber that had a deadly weapon. What's the difference?

Posted by: dexter Location: elkhart on Jul 30, 2008 at 08:07 PM
Hey carlos, Like Sean Connery said in the "untouchables" "He (the robber) shouldn't have brought a KNIFE to a GUN fight!" Dumb***. (Goes to the same bank in the same week w/ the same clothes.) One less fool in the gene pool)

Posted by: Mike Location: South Bend on Jul 30, 2008 at 07:21 PM
In walks TOM! Where have you been? It took longer than usual for you to begin your all to common Police bashing post. For everyone that doesn't know, Tom is our resident Police bashing idiot. He's been on the wrong side of the law so many times and gets off by posting on a news board bashing Police whenever possible. Hey Tom, you gonna come out of the closet soon and enter the real world or are you gonna remain a keyboard commando. Your brain is fried from watching to much "smarter than a 5th grader". Here's a thought, why don't you be a man and come out of the closet, look these Officers in the face and let loose your frustrations for Law Enforcement. Your a weak minded fool who can't hack it in the real world. You bash people from behind a keyboard where you feel safe only because there are Police Officers to protect your sorry butt. Just remember why you have your sorry life, because there are Police there to stop some thug from taking it from you! Have a nice day looser!

Posted by: cop Location: indiana on Jul 30, 2008 at 03:13 PM
There is a lot of back and forth here about the amount of force that was used maybe we should look at case law, Plakas V. Drinski, 19 F.3d 1143 7th cir. 1994 failure to employ alternative means of force less intrusive than deadly force DOES NOT render the use of deadly force unreasonable. That should cover the claims that an alternative force should have been used. Now on to shooting to wound there is a number of civil lawsuits that have come out of wounding a suspect in the leg or arm, because all the training that they recieve teaches them to shoot center mass which happens to be the middle of the chest. If the officer shoots the leg or arm intentionally then they will be held personally liable because they did not follow the training. Police do not shoot to kill they shoot to stop aggressive action, death is a side affect of being shot. If you place an officer in a situation where time is not a luxory and deadly force is in play I.E. gun, knife, ball bat... Good luck. SBPD good job.

Posted by: rusty shakelford on Jul 30, 2008 at 01:04 PM
Ever think maybee, just maybee the pictures of the smiling officers were file photos??? Nope? thought so. Rocket Science. Everyone jumps to conclusions and makes judgements based on a couple of paragraphs in the "news". Nice independent thought. Its like sheep. Oh well, I feel sorry for the people close to this guy who have to live with the guilt of knowing they did NOTHING to stop the multiple robberies he's been ID'd for.

Posted by: lucy Location: south bend on Jul 30, 2008 at 12:29 PM
GOOD!

Posted by: Esther Location: Rolling Prairie on Jul 30, 2008 at 11:39 AM
The FBI needs to examine this MHU investigation under a microscope. While they are at it, the need to find and scrutinize the Wooden Indian ballistic/forensic results from April 2007. Have any of you spoken with Barnaby's family? Morgan and Slager didn't have to kill Brian Szuflita. They panicked and made a bad decision they'll now have to live with the rest of their lives. Given the chance to turn back the clock, I'm sure these two cops would do things much differently .. as in non-lethally. Too much adrenaline and not enough training.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 30, 2008 at 11:32 AM
Hey Tom, go rob a bank and when Officers arrive, please take a knife out and run at them! Was wondering why it took so long for our resident cop hating IDIOT to show up. It's like clock work!

Posted by: Carlos Location: Sidney on Jul 30, 2008 at 09:28 AM
I am quite shocked at how desensitized we've become to death. The man wielding a knife was outnumbered and out gunned at a bank robbery. Why couldnt he be shot in his legs. His arms. Any where non-fatal. There is no excuse for this excessive force. There was no reason to take a life for these actions. If this occurred in an upscale area, and the knife wielder were caucasion middle class male...Oh man, i am sure there would be a much different reaction. Consider for a moment the rape, robberies, assaults, murder in the inner city occurring every day. When they occur in upper classcommunities, it makes national news, laws are passed, groups are formed. In the inner city those 'thugs' deserve it. I think we need to wake up. A human life is still just that no matter where it is.

Posted by: Tôm Location: South Bend on Jul 30, 2008 at 09:11 AM
The officers clearly enjoyed killing this man as evidenced by the photos of the giggling officers. At the very least they're sick in the head. Now the officers come here as "anonymous" and get angry because their hero status has once again been shot to hell.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 30, 2008 at 08:17 AM
He didn't get killed over the money!! How many times do they have to tell you? He got killed because he tried to attack officers with a knife! Got it now morons?! Brians Mother told South Bend tribune "Why couldn't they just shoot the knife out of his hand?". Is that possible? Yeh, maybe in a John Woo movie and some of you would believe that could actually happen. Some of you bleeding hearts who thinks theres this BIG conspiracy and cover up by officers need psychic help also. Theres help for everyone whether they have mental or financial problems. He chose to take the easy way out and paid dearly for it. Get over it! He lost a deadly fight which he initiated.

Posted by: This will solve nothing on Jul 30, 2008 at 12:32 AM
To S Location: South Bend NW SIDE on Jul 27, 2008 at 12:42 AM I have a family and yes I struggle. But I still do not agree with the situation and if you do stop being a baby and you grow up, theres more going on here, more important issues then money that you have no understanding.

Posted by: jon Location: mishawaka on Jul 29, 2008 at 11:25 PM
about time all those tax dollars spent on police officers got put to good use :)

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 29, 2008 at 09:21 PM
Doug, when anyone has a knife after robbing a bank--I would shoot to kill too. Get real, joker.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 29, 2008 at 08:26 PM
Wow Esther, maybe you should just stop thinking. I am sure he did have problems considering most normal people do not rob banks... 2 different times and then pull a knife out. I'm sure you would want the police helping you out if someone pulled a knife on you. Live somewhere else if you don't like the laws.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 29, 2008 at 07:19 PM
Now waitaminute...the guy robbed a bank...the money is insured..not a violent crime...he weilded a knife...what ever happened to billy clubs? Cops aren't trained for hand to hand combat? Just whip out the gun and problems solved? And to all the people who say robbing a bank is so bad, the Gubmint insures that money, no one loses anything. Now a rape, murder, or something similar may have warranted such a reaction from the cops, but protecting the goverments money? These cops just wanted to fire their guns. And they couldn't run away from a knife? Wow.

Posted by: chris Location: south bend on Jul 29, 2008 at 06:18 PM
Look you buncha gun happy idiots, next time you get pulled over and the cop see's a butter knife on your passenger seat maybe he should blow your head off too. What happened to tasers or did the mayor forget to buy double a' batteries.

Posted by: SBPD supporter Location: South Bend on Jul 29, 2008 at 05:11 PM
Monica and Esther, go back to your subscriptions of "Conspiracy Weekly" and leave common sense to the big people. These officers were chasing a felon, were attacked with a knife and made a tough decision that you would have not had the mental capacity or strength to make. I thank them for it. I guarantee you they were well-trained and made this decision to save their own lives. I know you hate the world when it makes people take responsibility for their own actions, but Brian chose this path, not the officers. Use rational thought. If our cops were not trained well and were just out to shoot everyone, they would be doing it all the time. I believe they show amazing restraint and that is why we have so many repeat offenders because of liberal judges rather than corpses because of cops. If you have trouble with the smiles, cut them some slack. Our police see AWFUL things day after day and have to develop coping mechanisms. You would not last two hours in their shoes!

Posted by: in-the-know Location: sb on Jul 29, 2008 at 04:35 PM
the autopsy is complete and it does not match the officers' versions of t