Mortgage Misery - Part 1: How scams happen Save Email Print
Posted: 11:36 PM Jul 15, 2008
Last Updated: 4:04 AM Jul 18, 2008
Reporter: Sarah Platt
Email Address: sarah.platt@wndu.com

A | A | A

It's no secret that the country is facing a mortgage crisis. A record number of homes are in foreclosure. Many people were approved for and took on risky mortgages that, in the end, they couldn't afford. Some had adjustable rate mortgages and couldn't re-finance in a tough economy. And others were the victims of mortgage scams.

Local FBI officials tell us scam artists are part of the recent mortgage downturn. Officials say loopholes in the mortgage industry combined with tough economic times have allowed crooks to carry out schemes. The crimes have become so rampant that the FBI even launched a massive investigation dubbed "Operation Malicious Mortgage."



Tom Gancarz

Over the last few months, the "American Dream" of owning a home has been tarnished for many people. With foreclosures up, the FBI says many innocent victims are losing a home because they put their trust in the wrong people. "I think this problem increased due to the fact that people are scam artists, they figured out, 'Hey, this is something I can take advantage of and make money at,'" explains Tom Gancarz, an FBI Special Agent who investigates mortgage fraud schemes.

The FBI says mortgage fraud investigations have more than tripled in recent years. In 2003, the FBI had more than 400 open mortgage fraud investigations. And as of May 2008, the FBI already had more than 1,400 open investigations. "Some of these scams really take a sophisticated understanding of the entire process," says Indiana U.S. Attorney David Capp.

"It's the methodical review of documents, interviews -- some of these investigations could take up to a year, two years, before they're ready to be prosecuted," adds Gancarz.



David Capp

Right now, Indiana's Northern District has at least three pending investigations. One of those cases involves a former South Bend cop. In May, Robert Culp pleaded guilty to bank fraud. Culp admitted he was part of a mortgage scam that involved close to 200 homes in the area.

As part of a plea deal, Culp has to testify against others involved. "Culp is the first in what we believe will be a series of charges related to that scam," explains Capp.

Newscenter 16 contacted Culp and his attorney. They have no comment on the case. The FBI says the Culp case is typical of many mortgage lending schemes, where several people are working together.

Here's how a scam like it might work. Person "A" acts as a salesperson or realtor. They help find a home for the buyer. Meantime, Person "B," the appraiser, appraises the home at an inflated price, far over what the home is actually worth. And then Person "C," the mortgage broker, approves the buyer for a loan at the inflated price. In the end, it's the buyer and/or lender who lose out and fall victim to the scam.


The FBI says each player in the scam makes a cut of the inflated profit, and each depends on the other to pull off the hoax. "You need appraisals, brokers, supposed purchasers," adds Capp.

To protect yourself from becoming a victim of a mortgage scam, the FBI says the best advice is to do your research, read the fine print, know what you're signing, and know what the home is actually worth. "You want to really do your homework. It's really simple to go down to the county area where you're purchasing a home, to see what the value of that home really is," says Gancarz. "Usually if you're dealing with a reputable lender, they're not going to put you in a situation that you're in over your head."

The FBI also says these scams should be a reminder about the dangers of identity theft. In May, a Hammond woman was charged with stealing people's identities and using the information to secure mortgages or loans in those victims' names. The FBI advises people to beware of any cold calls or e-mails where people ask for identifying information.





To read the other parts of this series, visit the following stories:
Mortgage Misery - Part 2: Talking to a scam victim
Mortgage Misery - Part 3: A local Realtor's perspective

More Stories
Local Italian restaurateur Rocco Ameduri passes away

Day After the Game: Weis reflects on San Diego State win

Officials announce federal takeover of Freddie Mac, Fannie Mae

Three Oaks family to reunite after immigration misunderstanding

Irish fight for ugly win over San Diego State in week one

After disappointing 2007 season, Irish ready to start fresh

Nearly 100 Elkhart National Guardsmen deploy to Iraq

South Bend condo project unveiled

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
Email will not be displayed on site. For station contact purpose only.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: Brooke Location: St. Joseph MI on Jul 16, 2008 at 04:07 PM
Quit whining! Under Reagan everyone wanted deregulation of the industry & they got it. As a tax payer I don't want to bail the banks or the supposed victims out of their messes. Interest only loans, 2nd & 3rd mortages, ARMs...who in their right mind would sign on the dotted line for something like this? All schools should mandate Consumer Education classes for high school students. I used to work at a call center for a mortgage company. When buyers bought a brand new house all they cared about was the monthly payment. A year later when the property taxes were assessed higher due to the fact that a home now sits on the land, buyers would call screaming that they could not afford their payments. Is that the mortgage company's fault? The tax assessor's? I say it is the buyer's problem.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 16, 2008 at 03:00 PM
A fool and their money are soon parted --quote by my Mom

Posted by: not Jack Maynard Location: south bend on Jul 16, 2008 at 02:25 PM
To Jack Maynard: Sounds to me like you may be in on this deal. How can you use the word "honest" in the same sentence with Robert Culp? This man obviously has NO morals and therefore I seriously doubt that he was (past tense) an honest cop. Pack your bags and butt plug Robert...Prison should be fun:)

Posted by: anonymous Location: south bend on Jul 16, 2008 at 01:47 PM
To Jack: Did you just crawl from under a rock or are you really this ignorant? It's scum like Culp that are to blame for our mortgage crisis. He is a CRIMINAL and a SCAM ARTIST! "In may,Robert Culp pleaded guilty to bank fraud.Culp admitted he was part of a mortgage scam that involved close to 200 homes in the area." This does not sound like the work of a "great man and a great honest cop." He'll soon get what he deserves.

Posted by: s Location: bremen on Jul 16, 2008 at 01:24 PM
They never should have started the 100% financing of homes. There is no room for refinancing if needed. No equity to help with refinancing. Dumb dumb dumb.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 16, 2008 at 01:20 PM
Having property taxes double for many people certainly hurt. Thanks Luecke.

Posted by: Annie Location: Elkhart on Jul 16, 2008 at 11:37 AM
The people that took out these mortages are just as much to blame. If you are making 40k a year you should know you can't afford a 250k house. Most of these people bought these big houses with no money down. So all they have done is the same as pay high rent for the time they were in these houses. It's not like they made a down payment and lost their life savings.

Posted by: Anonymous on Jul 16, 2008 at 11:07 AM
I don't think irresponsible people who bought houses out of their price range should be rewarded. The lenders are to blame for preying on ignorance, but the buyer is ultimately responsible for their purchase.

Posted by: Matt Location: Mishawaka on Jul 16, 2008 at 10:23 AM
Who cares?

Posted by: jack maynard Location: edwardsburg on Jul 16, 2008 at 01:23 AM
there is no crisis. get off your rear and pay your bills.robert is a great man and a great honest cop. let him go.

Five Day
WNDU News Poll
There are currently no active polls at this time.
Click here to view other polls on our site and past poll results.