Father speaks out about 2-year-olds murder
Father speaks out about 2-year-olds murder Save Email Print
Posted: 12:00 AM Mar 8, 2008
Last Updated: 7:26 PM Mar 9, 2008
Reporter: Erin Logan
Email Address: erin.logan@wndu.com

A | A | A

He's guilty and he may never see the light of day for killing a little girl.

A jury in Kosciusko County Friday found 34 year-old Ian Clark guilty in the beating death of two-year-old Samantha Muchowicz.

Police found the child in Clark's home on Ridinger Lake last May.

Clark was dating Samantha's mother, and told police the little girl hit her head on the coffee table but, the jury didn't buy the story.

They're now deciding if they want to recommend life without parole for Clark.

Samantha's family and friends tell us that punishment is exactly what they're hoping for.

Minutes after the guilty verdict came down, a childhood friend of Samantha's dad called us overjoyed.

In fact, she hadn't seen John Muchowicz in about twenty years, until about nine months ago.

Shanna Coon says when she says when she heard about the way Samantha lost her life, she had to track down John.

Since then, Coon and her family have been helping Muchowicz get through these painful months.

While looking at Samantha’s picture, Coon says, “You can see it in her eyes, nobody had a reason to hurt her. There's no way.”

There's no way, Coon ever imagined having to tell her friend Muchowicz, who she hadn't seen in 20 years, "I'm sorry your two year-old daughter was murdered and I'm sorry her mother's boyfriend is the alleged murderer."

She says Muchowicz immediately said this, “I want him found guilty. I want him responsible.”

Now, eight and a half months later, the news he was waiting for...a guilty verdict.

Still, Coon could see the pain in his eyes.

She says, “He has to live everyday of his life for the rest of his life knowing his daughter's gone.”

Not to mention, he has to live with the details he heard in court.

Coon says, “There was not a dry eye in the house.”

Testimony during Clark's trial said Samantha's mother returned from work to find the girl lying naked on Clark's chest on a couch.

Authorities said the girl was bloodied with a broken jaw and broken left wrist when she was taken to the hospital.

Coon says, “I was disgusted from the beginning.”

Coon never met Samantha but, she feel like she knows her. She has five kids of her own. One of them is Samantha's age.

She says, “I spend a lot of time at the cemetery. I take my kids there and I tell them about what happened. Their response is basically, "Wow! How can people do that to children?”

More Stories
ATF agents raid the Warsaw home of a known white supremacist

Granger man turns hobby into business with D'Avella Family Winery

Update: Woman and children recovering after car crashes into store window

U93 kicks off annual Roofsit campaign to help prevent child abuse

Part of Cleveland Avenue closed in St. Joe

Man hospitalized after motorcycle accident

80-year-old Niles man shot, robbed at home; suspects arrested

Golfer Chris Smith and family still in shock over weekend accident

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
Posted by: karen Location: fairbanks,alaska on Jun 23, 2009 at 06:23 AM
i went to jr.h and h.s with ian for years.he was always looking for ways to hurt and humiliate people, i had two classes with him.there was a girl whom was quite homely that sat in front of him,he was terrible to her,he would spit in her hair and tease her mercilessly.i found out years later from him bragging about how he would befriend (they lived in the same neiborhood)her and invite her over for sex,then when he was finished with he would spit on her and kick her out.no one knew any of this.and the next day at school he was back to treating her like trash.it was disgusting.then years later he bragged to me what he had been doing to this poor lonely,insecure girl.i always knew he was sick and NOTHING GOOD would he make of his life,but what he has done to this child is absolutely repulsive and unforgiveable.Rest in peace sweet angel you are safe now.

Posted by: Desirea Bolin Location: Warsaw Indiana on Dec 17, 2008 at 02:11 PM
Ive known matara and her family since we were in kindergarten together but i havent seen her in years,so when i heard what happened i couldnt believe it. I never saw samantha until the paper and i couldn't believe how beautiful she was and how that could happen. Just remember matara your angel is still thought of everyday by everyone who has heard your story. She will always be in my heart and in my thoughts. Love you little angel.

Posted by: Shanna Location: Larwill, Indiana on Mar 26, 2008 at 08:07 AM
I finally made another online memorial site for Samantha. It is at www.samantha-muchowicz.last-memories.com. Feel free to add pictures, memories, condolances, or light a candle for Sam. Please keep in mind we would like this memorial to remain a positive thing, so any comments about Ian or the murder should be posted here or somewhere else. Thank you all for remembering this precious little angel.

Posted by: another juror Location: warsaw on Mar 17, 2008 at 10:39 PM
I never knew this child who was shown to us through images that stay on my mind. If you have ever known anyone in an abusive situation - they are often unable to see the reality of what is happening around them. They are often so worn down emotionally that they miss the signs of danger. I know the terrified voice I heard on the 911 call from the mother. She was frantic. She loved this child very much - it was so plain to see. I feel great sorrow for the whole family at the loss of this little girl. She should be a poster child for educating others for what to watch for and when to get out of a relationship. Ian showed himself to be a person used to convincing others to see things as he does. He is a controlling person and easily angered as was shown in the trial. Ian can't hurt another child. It is too bad no one prosecuted him for other offences before he destroyed a child. Something good can come from evil-how can we help the next child before it is too late??

Posted by: TroutDude49 Location: Fairbanks, Alaska on Mar 13, 2008 at 05:51 PM
I went to highschool with this waste to society. Everybody in Fairbanks knew him as Ian Portman. He was always in trouble back then and his future behind bars was quite predictable. I only wish we didn't have to waste tax payers money to keep this piece of crap breathing. My heart goes out to the family of this poor little girl.

Posted by: Carolyn Location: Niles, Michigan on Mar 12, 2008 at 01:27 PM
This case makes me physically ill. This man should have been sentenced to death for what he did to this poor little girl. I to was abused as a child but that was back in the 70's when no one never wanted to do anything about it and my father who did this to me is still walking around and his remark to me when I confronted him was "I'm sorry for whatever you think I did". I have no remorse for anyone who hurts a child in anyway shape or form. Children are a gift from God and must be taken care of as such and to abuse that must be dealt with in way they only way it can really get the point across take there life the way they took the life of the poor innocent child. If this sounds like I am bitter because of my childhood partly yes but I have 2 beautiful girls that I worship and no man or woman will hurt them the way that I have been. My children have never been around my father they have seen him know who he is but do not know him as "Grandpa" he does not deserve this title....God bless.

Posted by: Shanna Location: Larwill on Mar 12, 2008 at 07:48 AM
I don't understand why everyone is so hot on the death penalty for this case. Now, I used to be a death penalty supporter until this happened to Sam. I don't want to see Ian sit on Death Row for up to 15 years, putting the family through all these appeals and crap. Sitting on Death Row will not kill Ian as quickly as turning him out into general population. I would like to see this as an eye-opening experience for all parents. You don't ever really know someone, and if you ever hear that your boyfriend/girlfriend has a violent past, do NOT let them around your child. In this day and age, it just isn't safe. If you can't afford child care then check into assistance programs. There is no reason this needs to ever happen to anyone else's child. I would really like to see legislature passed to make killing a significant others a mandatory life sentence without parole. Anyone know how to get something like that started? My email is listed in one of hte other comments.

Posted by: disbelief Location: Elkhart on Mar 11, 2008 at 08:28 PM
I use to work with this guy and I always thought there was something wrong with him.I feel sorry for the mother and father of the child.Both of them sound like good parents and I wish them all the best in getting through this.I don't understand why this wasn't a "death penalty" case.It should have been and this guy is a prime candidate for the express lane.I have children of my own and if anyone was to hurt them ??????.

Posted by: Disgusted Location: Warsaw on Mar 11, 2008 at 01:55 PM
I agree with K8 that the mother is responsible also, as she 'chose' this man, and most probably knew what was going on?....was she held accountable? I blame her as much if not more than Clark. She basically chose a man over the life of her child. Not to mention that she wasn't even at work when this happened. Per the prosecuting attorney......"Samantha's mother left the child in the care of Clark, went to work, and then a relative's home and McDonalds". The police had been called to their house many times so I do not believe that the mother though Clark was a saint and a "good father". She should be sitting next to Clark in prison.

Posted by: Mother of 4 Location: North Webster on Mar 11, 2008 at 12:27 PM
James in Pheonix, I couldn't have said it better.. God Bless Sam!

Posted by: James Location: Phoenix, AZ on Mar 10, 2008 at 11:58 PM
I am Sam's uncle, and while I never got to meet her living in another state my heart was shattered when I found out what happened. Thank you to the jury for not letting the pittiful story from Ian sway you from the truth, I know you wish you could have done more. For those out there asking for him to get the death penalty, I feel that it would be more appropriate let him rot in jail untill another inmate finds out what he did and then he will get the torcher that he inflicted.

Posted by: Concerned Location: Warsaw Indiana on Mar 10, 2008 at 08:34 PM
There is no one to blame in this case other than Ian Clark. It is not the mother's or the father's fault nor is it any family members fault. Justice has been served in this case. May this case bring awareness to our community so that future acts of violence can be stopped before we lose another child. May God bless Samantha, her family and the dedicated members of law enforcement who brought this man to justice.

Posted by: Bonnie Location: Elkhart on Mar 10, 2008 at 07:15 PM
Shanna - I am sorry that you felt I was bashing the parents of the child, I wasn't. I am just angry that too many children are harmed. In Indiana both parents have rights to their child not someone who is not an immediate family member. I applaud you that you are setting up a Memorial Site for this little girl, but I still do not have any sympathy for child abuse. Children do not have any rights and we need more child advocates to fight for the safety and rights of every child. I am sorry if I upset you it was not my intent.

Posted by: ? on Mar 10, 2008 at 05:05 PM
This whole thing makes me want to vomit. How could this not be seen coming? How can something of this caliber happen out of nowhere? I have to opt with the posts about "prison justice" as they are what this jerk deserves.

Posted by: Juror Location: Warsaw on Mar 10, 2008 at 01:22 PM
There were several times during the trial that I cried, I couldn't help it. When Mr. Hearn turned around that photo of Sam in his closing statement, I just lost it. That gorgeous little girl lost her life unnecessarily because a very evil man was born on this earth and came across her path. It came out after the trial that this wasn't Mr. Clark's first battery on a child. I too hope that Mr. Clark has a short, miserable life in prison. He deserves it.

Posted by: k8 on Mar 10, 2008 at 01:08 PM
The mother is responsible also, as she 'chose' this man, and most probably knew what was going on?....was she held accountable?

Posted by: Shanna Location: Larwill on Mar 10, 2008 at 12:42 PM
Bonnie, I can tell you that John and his mother were BOTH off work all day on the day that Sam died. There is NO reason why Sam had to be left with Ian. All it would've taken was a simple phone call, but the way I understand it, Ian demanded that John only be allowed to have Sam the minimum time allowed by the court. John did all he could to protect his daughter but was quickly dismissed as a "jealous" ex-husband and father. Also, John paid his support. I used to live in Kosciusko county and know there are programs available for child care assistance. I will say over and over, there was NO reason for this to happen, but it is not John's fault. He did all he could and sadly, it wasn't enough. As for the jurors wanting pics, I also have some. I am in the process of making a memorial website for Sam as well. shannacoon@yahoo.com (If you want to email to bash the parents/family, don't waste my time.)

Posted by: Mother of 4 Location: North Webster on Mar 10, 2008 at 09:15 AM
Chaz, Did this sick monster, who unfortunately I personally know, Did he think about WWJD, when he brutally beat and murdered this innocent two year old girl? No he didn't, so why should we christians or not, give a *****? To Samantha's family, I pray you find peace in knowing that your little one is at peace now. i wish I would have had the chance to meet you before all this happened, I would have told you what a monster Ian really is. My prayers are with you in your time of pain.

Posted by: ? Location: kosciusko on Mar 10, 2008 at 07:47 AM
I will pray for Clark alright, that his soul burns forever. As far as God forgiving him, I do believe there are certain things that if you commit them in this world your chance of salvation is gone. Murder being one of them. Clark is evil, plain and simple and that can not be saved.

Posted by: Bonnie Location: Elkhart on Mar 10, 2008 at 06:49 AM
Again a child is dead because the wrong people are having children! I can't believe that this was the first time the child was harmed. Child abuse is disgusting! Why didn't the father of the child have her while her mother worked? I just have no sympathy for anyone who abuses a child!

Posted by: juror #10 Location: Milford on Mar 10, 2008 at 06:40 AM
I called Matara's grandmother asking her for a recent pic of Samantha so I would have something to remember her by besides the horrible hospital and autopsy photos. If any other juror wants a copy, call the baliff and ask her for my phone number and I will send you a copy. We as a jury know justice was done on our part, my hope is that he gets a slow and painful death while in prison. He needs to feel what he did to Samantha.

Posted by: Michelle Location: Syracuse on Mar 10, 2008 at 05:48 AM
I am glad they gave Mr. clark life in prison w/o parole.. People like him do not have it easy in prison and now he will have to fear for his life.. Little Samantha will always be in my heart and mind. Her family deserves closure on this at finding justice has been done..

Posted by: Shannon Location: Niles on Mar 9, 2008 at 10:55 PM
I grieve for Samantha's family and all they have been through, my children are priceless gifts from God, and in my mind, only a fool would attempt to bring spiritual judgement into this discussion. Jesus said if we are to judge then to do so righteously, and to remember, "the judgement we use on others will be used on us, be careful of the beam in your own eye when you are pointing out the speck in your brothers' eye" I can go on, but I am sure you see the point. As the officer said it is up to us to hand down judgement on earth, God will do so in heaven. God will bless all involved with this case, Ian "would be better off to have a mill-stone tied around his neck and be cast into the sea than to hurt a child".

Posted by: jackie Location: plymouth on Mar 9, 2008 at 10:02 PM
continuation from previous post:im not judging the mother.i am just asking questions.the neighbors stated the cops had been called to his home before due to things he has done but they didn't state if it was things he done to the child the mother or just something he done wrong.you know dean i have read and heard people state i found god while i was locked up but they end right back in the system because they can't control themselves and they break the law again.so let me ask you this everytime a murderer tells the parole board i found god while i was locked up.should they be released from prison?just because someone says they found god doesn't mean they are not going to commit the same crime or a diffrent one.and may i remind you god sent a flood to rid the earth of all the sinners so how can u sit there and say that god forgives all sinners and that there is no sin scale in god's eye.i think you need to reread the bible.and there are some sins god will not forgive and murder is one.

Posted by: jackie Location: plymouth on Mar 9, 2008 at 09:46 PM
My thoughts and prayers are with this family.This is no way for any child to die. My question is. How many times has he hurt this child in the past?I am a mother of 3 children and I will be the first to admit if i walked in and found my deceased child in the arms of the person that killed her I would be the one going to jail because I would have lost my mind and took him out before the police could arrive.I myself have never been in jail or prison but i do know people that have been and i know there will be no mercy for Clark if the inmates don't get him the guards will.But whoever gets him i'm sure they will give him what they think he deserves.No child deserves to be beaten no matter what.Why did he do it? How could he do it?Does he have a past history of child abuse? If so and it is a history with child abuse on Samantha why would the mother stay with him?And if this has happened before with the same child why did mom leave her with him knowing he may do it again?I'm not judgin her?

Posted by: local folk on Mar 9, 2008 at 09:41 PM
Shanna: "I have friends who know some inmates, and Ian will not grow old in prison, that is for sure." ---- Ewwwwwww, yer so neat!

Posted by: Svengali Location: Elkhart on Mar 9, 2008 at 09:05 PM
Justice has been served. As for the Christian bashers out there... Jesus said this.. Passage Mark 9:42: 42And whosoever shall offend one of these little ones that believe in me, it is better for him that a millstone were hanged about his neck, and he were cast into the sea. This verse applies explicitly to situations like this...

Posted by: Dean Location: Warsaw on Mar 9, 2008 at 07:02 PM
Who are we to judge? Mr Clark was convicted of murder by a jury of his peers. While it is easy to say that he must pay with his life, most people don't realize that in prison, his life as he knows it, is over. You have to understand prison life. It is about survival and is not an easy way out. I know this from personal experience. I accepted the Lord in prison. It would be far easier for Mr Clark to be executed then what he faces in the prison system. I don't condone what Mr Clark was convicted of. As Christians, we need to pray for Mr Clark, his defiant attitude, and that God will prevail in his life. God will forgive a sinner such as Mr Clark since there is no sin scale in God's eyes. A beautiful little girl was lost in all of this but she now rests in God's loving arms. Our hearts and prayers go out to Samantha's parents, family and friends.

Posted by: another juror Location: warsaw on Mar 9, 2008 at 11:49 AM
I was also chosen to sit in on this horrific case as a jury member. Let me assure you that the entire jury wanted to see justice served on behalf of this little girl. The evidence presented to us was overwhelming. The majority of our nights were sleepless imagining what Samantha endured in her final hours. It is brutal and disgusting. The amount of time spent in the jury room was to primarily make sure we were completing the paperwork correctly and not leaving any loophole to make it easy for this disgusting waste of human flesh to appeal. We took longer only to be thorough. We took our charge from the judge very seriously. Everyone agreed that nothing we could do would ever be enough for what happened to this innocent child, but at least this way, he won't ever hurt another one. I pray for the family, that they may find a way move forward. I know they won't forget. My concern now, is how do we prevent another child from suffering the same fate by another monster?

Posted by: dale Location: nappanee on Mar 9, 2008 at 11:40 AM
i made my comment based on all of the "thats not very Christian" talk. was what this man did to this girl along the lines of WWJD? HELL NO! the jury did what they were instructed, but i hope the general population can take care of the rest. the death penalty may not deter crime with anyone else, but this jerk wouldn't be able to kill another child, would he? it it only saved one life, frying this guy would be worth it in my opinion. i want everyone who thinks that is not true to look into the eyes of their child and think of them lying in a casket. and a little mesg to all the parents out there who think their kids are possibly being abused buy their "significant others"- get out while you can. no one needs a mate that bad.

Posted by: Shanna Location: Larwill on Mar 9, 2008 at 09:25 AM
To So Very Sad, it does not bother me or the family that Ian is going to "live out life" in prison. I have friends who know some inmates, and Ian will not grow old in prison, that is for sure. I saw the post from a Juror as well and wanted to thank you. As I sat in the courtroom Friday morning, I stared at the jury a long time. One woman juror was already dabbing her eyes with Kleenex only 15 minutes into the hearing. And I told Sam's father later that it looked like every juror looked very pale, like they hadn't slept, and they wanted to vomit just being in the same room with Ian. I am so sorry that you also, along with Sam's family, will have to live with the memory of those pictures and that testimony. Don't let what Ian did haunt you for the rest of your life. Sam is in a much better, happier, and safer place now. Feel good about what you did, putting Ian in prison for life. To the officers and hospital workers, all I can say is thank you.

Posted by: Dee Dee Location: Mi on Mar 8, 2008 at 09:34 PM
This is the first I'v seen of this story,, I would like to know what happend,, If someone could E-mail me what happend ,, would be so kind ct_moon_pixy@yahoo.com thank you ...

Posted by: So very sad Location: Michigan on Mar 8, 2008 at 09:31 PM
Children are a gift. They are a precious miracle that we are blessed with. Every child deserves a loving touch and a safe home. I am so sorry for the loss of this sweet little one. Just seeing her picture on the screen causes tears to drop as I think of my own children and how much I love them. As a fellow parent I cannot imagine the pain her mom and dad are enduring. Please know that she is safe from harm now, a little angel returned to Heaven. I am a believer of the Lord, and I am not one to seek revenge...except when it comes to child abuse. Makes me sick to know that he will have three squares a day and live out life until he dies a natural death after he took the life of someone so young. Whatever happens to him, he has asked for it. One day he will answer for it as well. God bless little Samantha's family and friends.

Posted by: CISD Location: Kosciusko County on Mar 8, 2008 at 05:25 PM
To the officer; thank you for all your hard work. Without guys like you the "evil" would never face justice. To the juror; I am proud of you and your fellow jurors for making the right decision. I know the things you heard/saw were horrific and you'll never forget them. It's true, little Samantha was handed to God with loving hands and each of us will forever carry a small memory of her in our hearts and souls.

Posted by: Jay Location: SB on Mar 8, 2008 at 04:04 PM
Tatoo "Child Killer" on his forehead and throw him in general population. He just may hit his head on a coffee table also.

Posted by: Chaz Location: South Bend on Mar 8, 2008 at 03:00 PM
Ah yes. Good ole' Leviticus and "an eye for an eye"! Of course you realize that it also says in the same chapter that you can sell your daughter into slavery so clearly that must be OK too right? But please, show me where Jesus advocated the death penalty or even seeking vengeance yourself. I must have missed it.

Posted by: dale Location: nappanee on Mar 8, 2008 at 12:56 PM
i believe God said "send them to me" - and the only way to get this dufus there is execution or 10 minutes alone in a room with didntgetkissedfirst. either way, he's not taking up any space in prison.

Posted by: Read the bible on Mar 8, 2008 at 11:31 AM
Doesn't the bible say an eye for an eye? Wouldn't a Christian know that bible says...?

Posted by: Officer Location: Kosciusko on Mar 8, 2008 at 10:21 AM
A question of being a christian should not even play into this. We, Society, will judge the physical acts, God will judge his soul. This type of comments is not about vengence, its about good people standing in the face of evil, and saying it will not survive here. To the Muchowics family I know it will be hard to find peace is this world now, but Ians evil hand was not the last thing Samantha experienced in this world. Samatha felt the love of and the loving touch of an entire community from Police officers, firemen, EMT's, Doctors, Nurses we might not have known her very well but she was handed to God with loving hands. I would only have one thing to say to the monster that did this, The fires of hell can not burn hot enough to bring you to justice, the ones that you will expericnce in time will have to do.

Posted by: Brian Location: Walkerton on Mar 8, 2008 at 09:26 AM
I am a father of a beautiful two year old. And there is no way that I can even concieve something like this. I wish the father would have found him rather then the police, we would spend a lot less on a wooden box then a trial! As everyone else stated...JUICE HIM

Posted by: Juror Location: Warsaw on Mar 8, 2008 at 08:23 AM
This was not a death penalty case. We were told that from the very beginning. The jury once they found him guilty could only recommend life without parole or 45-65 years in prison. The jury chose life in prison without parole.

Posted by: Margaret Location: South Bend on Mar 8, 2008 at 06:25 AM
To Chaz-Yes I am a Christian and I still stand by what I said before-crank up old sparky and JUICE HIM!

Posted by: Brittney Location: Elkhart on Mar 7, 2008 at 09:13 PM
He needs to get executed rite away.. He took a baby's life so they need to take his... My prayers are out for Samantha's family, May GOD BLESS

Posted by: Chaz Location: South Bend on Mar 7, 2008 at 08:00 PM
So are any of you that are calling for his death Christians? Sure doesn't seem very Christ-like. I don't think I ever want him to see the outside of a prison again but killing him is certainly not very WWJD is it?

Posted by: Charles Location: Nappanee on Mar 7, 2008 at 06:49 PM
You know we have the death penalty here for a reason, and this is ONE person who really needs it. I think that this country has gotten way to soft on its criminals and are letting way to many people who have been convicted of violent crimes and sentenced to death sit in our system way to long, to get a degree and health care, etc. EXECUTE HIM AS SOON AS POSSIBLE

Posted by: steve Location: warsaw on Mar 7, 2008 at 06:46 PM
Why should he spend life or even the death sentence this is crazy the taxpaters are going to pay for him to stay alive in prison for life and even if he gets the death sentence the taxpayers still have to feed him clothe him why not just do to him what he did to that poor little girl or even better yet start at the toes and cut each part of his toe off till they reach each joint then continue on from there the scumbag should not even be alive he is just as bad as a child molester if not worse sick s.o.b.

Posted by: Margaret Location: South Bend on Mar 7, 2008 at 06:05 PM
Killing an innocent child should be a no brainer-JUICE HIM!!

Posted by: Shanna Location: Larwill on Mar 7, 2008 at 05:49 PM
I, for one, am glad to see Ian get life in prison. I want him to see Sam's face every night when he goes to sleep. Plus, it costs me more money as a taxpayer for him to be on Death Row versus spending his life being tortured in prison. Come on, there are some bad people in prison, but they haven't done anything like HE did. Above all, I am grateful that this is over. The family and friends can finally have closure. As they said in the closing arguments, no one knows what Sam's dreams and goals were or would have been, but I know that this verdict and sentence has her smiling down on all of us.

Posted by: Roger Location: Warsaw on Mar 7, 2008 at 05:42 PM
Looks like the jury deliberated for a whole hour before recommending life without parole. That's more mercy than this guy gave little Samantha. I agree with didtgetkissedfirst, maybe this is the type justice we should do in a LOT of cases. It would save the taxpayers money and could be the solution to some of the tax problems occuring in this and other states.

Posted by: Keith Location: Warsaw on Mar 7, 2008 at 05:34 PM
Life with out parole is to good for him. He should with out question recieve the Death Pentalty !

Posted by: Rhonda Location: Warsaw on Mar 7, 2008 at 05:07 PM
I have a VERY hard time figuring out how the jury can have to deliberate whether or not to recommend life with out parole. This idiot took the life of an innocent baby. He needs to pay with HIS life. If the death penalty is one of the options, that's what he deserves, if it isn't then he definitely deserves life without parole. Hope he meets some people in prison that do the same things to him as he did this innocent baby. That's one thing most convicts don't tolerate, abuse of a child. There is NO reason to do these kinds of things to a baby. God Bless Samantha's family. May Samantha rest in peace. Samantha is inside Heaven's Gate now watching over her family. May God be with her family and those that truly loved her when she was here.

Posted by: Melissa Location: SB on Mar 7, 2008 at 04:12 PM
Lock him up and throw away the key. Let him rot in jail. Hopefully he will live a long agonizing life.

Posted by: didtgetkissedfirst Location: intherear on Mar 7, 2008 at 03:39 PM
I think he should spend about 10 minutes with me in a locked room. When the door opens, we won't need to worry about should he or should he not get life without parole. This could be a good start at saving the taxpayers some money.

Posted by: Amanda on Mar 7, 2008 at 03:07 PM
I think he should get the death pentalty for what he has done!!!!

Posted by: BIG O on Mar 7, 2008 at 02:57 PM
INSTANT EXOCUTION is what this dirt bag needs


Five Day
WNDU News Poll
There are currently no active polls at this time.
Click here to view other polls on our site and past poll results.
MichianaGuide.com