MIKE: Tornadoes..."Super" Outbreak II ?
MIKE: Tornadoes..."Super" Outbreak II ?WNDU Blog Listing
MIKE: Tornadoes..."Super" Outbreak II ?
Topic Author: Mike Hoffman
Posted: 11:45 PM Apr 28, 2011
Replies Posted: 8 comments
Save Email Print
Recent Blog Topics

Font Size:

I never expected to see 300 people die in a tornado outbreak ever again.  I figured that even if we DID have another outbreak like 1974, we would be able to warn everybody on TV and that would protect most families.  The strong tornado that hit Nappanee a few years ago wipe out several neighborhoods, but nobody died because most got the warnings and they knew to take cover.  Unfortunately, there were several factors that did not keep people protected during this latest huge outbreak in the southeast.

First of all, it's been a very active April because of a very strong flow of air, called the jet stream, that has been slamming into the west coast and then buckling and producing storms in the middle of the country.  This jet stream is extra strong for this time of the year because of the La Nina, a cold pool of water in the Pacific Ocean.  While the La Nina is weakening, it has still been enough to help increase the speed of the winds at the jet stream level.  By the way, the Palm Sunday 1965 tornado outbreak and the "Super" outbreak of April 3rd, 1974 both came after a winter La Nina that was weakening, so this same thing has happened in the past.  The strong jet stream allows the top of thunderstorms to act like a chimney, sucking the warm, humid, air upward, which just increases the power of the thunderstorm, and therefore the tornado.

Secondly, because of the strong winds in the jet stream we had multiple EF-4 and EF-5 tornadoes...these are monster tornadoes, the strongest kind.  Most tornadoes are not this strong, thank goodness, so we see things like trees and power lines toppled, or part of a roof off, or even the top floor of a building.  These monster tornadoes basically "level" everything right to the ground.

This leads me to reason number 3, the lack of basements.  In this part of the country, because of a high water level in the ground, they typically do not build basements due to the likelihood of flooding.  So, without a basement, many people had no place to hide.  They needed to get out of the path of these monster tornadoes, which is very hard to do in time.  This definitely caused more deaths that it would have in an area with basements.

So how does this latest outbreak compare to previous tornado outbreaks?  It definitely surpasses the Palm Sunday tornado outbreak of 1965.  That's probably the worst one here in Michiana.  Although Palm Sunday may come close in the number of EF-4 and 5 tornadoes.  As for the grandaddy of them all, the Super Outbreak of April 3, 1974, I think this one will compare.  In fact it may eventually be called Super Outbreak II, although that is not for me to decide.  On April 3, 1974, there were 148 tornadoes across 13 states, which caused 319 deaths.  This latest outbreak, as of 11pm Thursday evening, had 292 dead with an estimated 150 tornadoes across 6 states.  In my opinion, it will be close on the number of deaths.  However, I think it will come up slightly short on the number of tornadoes.  Some of that 150 might be multiple reports of the same tornado, so where they thought there were 2 tornadoes, they'll find only one path.  We'll find out in a few days.  But the number of monster tornadoes will come up short.  In 1974, there were 30 EF-4 and 5 tornadoes during that 24 hour period!!  Incredible!

We have to remember, though, that even if this tornado outbreak across the southeast comes up short of 1974, there are millions of our fellow Americans affected and thousands grieving for their loved ones right now.  It was a very sad day for me as a Meteorologist.  I love the weather, but it's tough to watch when it causes so much havoc and affects so many people.

Mike 

Post Your Comments
First Name:
Location:
Enter Comments: characters left
Email (optional):
By posting this comment I have read and agree to the Terms of Use and Privacy Policy:
You must agree to the Terms of Service to continue.
Read Comments
Comments are posted from viewers like you and do not always reflect the views of this station.
  • by The Annoying Orange Location: North Liberty on Jan 3, 2012 at 08:28 PM
    It so sad that many lost their lives on those days.
  • by Bob Location: Bremen on Jul 1, 2011 at 04:45 PM
    Your weather for July 1st was about as far away as it can be. It's 5:00 PM and still storming.
  • by Jenny Location: South Bend on Jun 20, 2011 at 03:37 PM
    Whoa, i hope we don't get a tornado :/
  • by jib Location: La Porte on May 25, 2011 at 03:26 PM
    Sirens in La Porte signal two weather events: dangerous cloud to ground lightning and tornadoes. You can check out the radar if you have electrical power. Weather Radio is more reliable but limited. Hearing the threat still isn't seeing the threat. TV and cell phone towners can get knocked out. There comes a point in all these warning systems where people are simply stranded.
  • by Erin Location: Granger on May 5, 2011 at 01:56 PM
    Probably a dumb question but why has it been so cold? and when do you think the cold spell will pass?
  • by Crystal on Apr 29, 2011 at 11:42 AM
    Another reason so many were without warning until it was to late was the digital signal boxes. I have several family and friends from that area and almost all of them said that as things got worse the digital signal gave out on them. They had to wait to listen for the sirens. And when a tornado that big is bearing down on you let me tell you this. You don't hear those sirens. At least with the old TV's you were able to get some picture even if it was fuzzy. In a situation like this fuzzy is better than none.
  • by Jeff Lepird Location: South Bend on Apr 29, 2011 at 03:20 AM
    I believe another factor for so many deaths may be apathy toward the warnings. Surely they are used to seeing Tornado Warnings, but when you see them so many times with very localized damage or a false alarm altogether, people naturally dismiss the warning. We see more strong tornadoes in Great Lakes Region than they see in the deep south, so I imagine their apathy is greater than ours. I see the need for not only a recognition of a more localized threat area (possibly by Zip code or Township), but a scale of the severity of the threat. Meteorologists today seem to have a handle on whether the threat in a warning situation is marginal or high risk, yet there is not an official system for conveying this to the public. Mike does a nice job with the WNDU Severe Weather Index and will tell you how big a threat there is when he goes live, but you don't usually get that from other sources. In this digital age when everybody gets a text message about the warning, I think we can do better.
7 - 15 - 1 - 0

WNDU News Poll
There are currently no active polls at this time.
Click here to view other polls on our site and past poll results.